Start by separating the original film formats from the digital files you want: support for several film types doesn’t automatically mean you can choose between JPEG, TIFF or PSD. If you want JPEG files on an SD card, a standalone scanner could be a good fit. For a choice of digital output formats, a computer-connected film scanner such as the Plustek OpticFilm 120 Pro is an option, while a magazine scanner is only worthwhile if you have compatible magazines. Then check the holders and software, and allow time to sort, scan and check your entire collection.
Who is this for?
A family with a mixed box of film
You have holiday slides and perhaps negative strips in different sizes. First, check which originals fit the holders supplied with the exact model you’re considering; reflecta and Kodak Photo Plus list different film formats and holders.
Someone who wants editable scans
You want to choose an output format for editing or archiving later, as well as files that are easy to share. Plustek lists JPEG, TIFF and PSD for the OpticFilm 120 Pro; the available output formats vary by model.
Owner of full slide magazines
You want to scan lots of mounted slides with fewer individual loading steps. reflecta lists Universal, CS and LKM magazines for the DigitDia evolution; check which type you have.
What should you look for in a film scanner?
The Consumers’ Association highlights the amount of material, the quality you want and the time involved as factors to consider. So first decide which originals you want to scan and what kind of digital file you need.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Compatible film holders |
Sort your originals by film type and check which holders are included with each model. Also check whether you’ll need to buy a special holder separately. |
I want to scan slides and possibly negatives from a mixed box of film, so the film formats must actually fit. Around 34% of consumers say compatibility with the original film is their top priority. |
| Digital file formats |
Check whether the exact model creates JPEG, TIFF, PSD or another format you need. If possible, open a sample file on your own computer. |
I want to do more than share my scans: I also want to edit or archive them later. Around 25% of consumers prioritise choosing their digital output files. |
| Image checking and editing |
Compare sample scans of your own slides and check the software and settings. Don’t treat interpolated output resolution as equivalent to sensor resolution. |
I want to assess and, if necessary, adjust the scan results, even if that means extra work. Around 25% of consumers prioritise having control over scanning and editing. |
| Steps involved for the whole collection |
Count your slides and check that a magazine scanner is compatible with your magazine type. Remember to allow time for sorting, loading, checking and saving, as well as scanning. |
For a large collection, I want to avoid loading slides individually as much as possible. Around 16% of consumers say reducing the number of loading steps is their top priority. |
Film scanner buying pitfalls
-
Confusing film formats with file formats
Support for several types of original film doesn’t tell you which digital files the scanner can create. For example, the reflecta x66-Scan is described as saving JPEG files to an SD card, while Plustek lists JPEG, TIFF and PSD for the OpticFilm 120 Pro.
Check the supported originals, the holders included and the available output formats separately for the exact model.
If the output file you want isn’t available, you may need a separate scanning or conversion step.
-
Assuming an interpolated megapixel figure represents captured detail
reflecta lists a 14MP sensor and 22MP interpolated output for the x66-Scan. These figures describe different things.
Where possible, compare sample scans for your intended use and don’t base your choice on the highest figure alone.
-
Assuming a memory card or special holder is included
Kodak Photo Plus says the Slide N Scan needs an SD card, which isn’t included. For 126 film on the x66-Scan, reflecta lists an optional holder.
Check what’s included with the specific offer and compare it with your film collection and storage needs.
Allow for the cost of a separate SD card or compatible holder if you need one.
-
Treating a discontinued model as if it were available new
Epson marks the Perfection V600 Photo as discontinued. Previously published product specifications don’t, by themselves, tell you the condition of a specific item for sale.
For a particular item, check its condition, the film holders included, software compatibility and the terms of sale.
If you buy a used model, you may need extra time to check its condition, holders and software are working properly.
Brands to consider
reflecta
The x66-Scan and DigitDia evolution show that different reflecta models are designed for different ways of working.
- According to reflecta, the x66-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card; the manufacturer says the DigitDia evolution is designed for compatible Universal, CS and LKM magazines.
- These model-specific features don’t mean that every reflecta model supports all film or digital file formats.
Kodak Photo Plus
The Slide N Scan is a standalone option for mounted slides and the 135, 110 and 126 originals listed by Kodak Photo Plus.
- Kodak Photo Plus lists compatible adapters and storage on SD or SDHC cards up to 32 GB for this model.
- The product information says an SD card is required but not included. Don’t treat claims about image quality as independent test results.
Plustek
The OpticFilm 120 Pro is designed for a computer-connected workflow with 35mm slides and supported 120 film.
- Plustek lists JPEG, TIFF and PSD as output formats, along with specific 120 film formats.
- The listed formats don’t confirm that 110 or 126 film will fit. Also check that the software is compatible with your computer.
Epson
The Perfection V600 Photo is an example of a flatbed scanner with a transparency unit for prints, mounted 35mm slides and 120/220 film.
- Epson lists JPEG and TIFF output, among other formats, for this model.
- Epson marks the V600 Photo as discontinued. Check the condition and completeness of any particular item before you buy.
Rollei
According to Rollei, the DF-S 310 SE is a standalone scanner for slides and negatives.
- Rollei lists extra inserts for 110 film and Super 8, as well as internal memory and an SD/SDHC slot for cards up to 32 GB.
- The mention of Super 8 doesn’t automatically mean that moving film can be digitised as video. Check the output you need for this use separately.
Joybuy products
Related products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
Does ‘several film formats’ mean the scanner also saves different file formats?
No. Film formats describe the originals and holders; file formats describe the digital output. reflecta lists JPEG storage on an SD card for the x66-Scan, while Plustek lists JPEG, TIFF and PSD for the OpticFilm 120 Pro. Check both lists for the exact model.
How should I prepare a batch of holiday slides?
First, sort the slides by film and frame type, then use the appropriate holder. Make a few sample scans, keep the scanner and originals as dust-free as possible, and check the files before scanning the whole batch. Then arrange storage and make a backup of the files.
What should I check when buying online and looking at the warranty in the Netherlands?
According to the Dutch Government, when you buy online from a business you often have 14 days to change your mind, although there are exceptions. ACM ConsuWijzer also says that you’re entitled to a legal guarantee if a product doesn’t meet what you could reasonably expect; the retailer is your point of contact.
Can I share someone else’s digitised slides online?
Not simply because you own the slide or scanned it yourself. According to the Dutch Government, you can make a private copy of someone else’s copyright-protected photos for your own use, but you can’t distribute or publish them without permission. Check the rights to the specific photo before you publish it.
Where can I take an unwanted scanner?
According to the Dutch Government, as a private individual you can, among other options, hand in an old appliance when you buy a new, similar one. Other options include suitable collection points and your local council’s recycling centre.