Choose a scanner based on the agreed file format and the time you have available. For checking and correcting 35mm slides, a dedicated film scanner is a natural choice, while a standalone scanner can save JPEG files to an SD card. The Consumentenbond highlights the quantity of material, desired image quality and time available as important considerations. Also check that the slides, software and file format meet your client’s requirements.
Who is this relevant to?
Image-conscious contractor
You want to deliver 35mm holiday slides and assess and correct each scanned image. The Consumentenbond discusses image quality as a consideration when digitising slides; Plustek describes the OpticFilm 8200i SE as a scanner for 35mm film.
Contractor with a large number of slides
For a large job, loading, checking and organising the slides can have a significant impact on your schedule. The Consumentenbond highlights the quantity of material and time involved as factors to consider; reflecta says the DigitDia evolution automatically processes compatible magazines.
Creator putting together a straightforward image selection
You want to select and supply files stored locally, without a complex scanning workflow, if the client is happy with the format. reflecta describes the x33-Scan as saving JPEG files to an SD card; the European Kodak Slide N Scan requires an SD card, which is not included.
What should you look for when choosing?
Start with the required file format and agreed image quality. Then consider the total processing time and the practical costs of the job.
| Factor |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Detail and correction |
Compare the optical or sensor output with the files required. Also check which correction options and software are available. |
If you want to assess and edit the detail in each slide before delivery, image checking is your top priority. Around 40% of consumers prioritise detail and correction options. |
| Processing time |
As well as scanning time, allow for loading, checking, cleaning and organising the slides. Check that the magazines are compatible with the slides. |
If you have a lot of images and a firm deadline, the time needed for the whole job matters, not just the time per scan. Around 30% of consumers prioritise the throughput of the collection. |
| File format |
Agree the format and organisation with the client, then check that the scanner and software can produce the required files. |
If the client needs to use the files straight away, you’ll want to know in advance which format and delivery method have been agreed. Around 20% of consumers start with files that are ready to hand over. |
| Job costs |
Weigh up the number of slides, post-processing and potential future use of the scanner against outsourcing the work. Check which holders, software and storage media are included. |
For a one-off job, you’ll want to compare the total cost with the alternatives available. Around 10% of consumers make job costs their top priority. |
Common pitfalls
-
Mistaking interpolated output for extra captured detail
The higher 5760 × 3840-pixel output from the reflecta x33-Scan is interpolated. That does not automatically mean the slide contains more original detail.
Compare the sensor or optical specifications with the client’s requirements and, if possible, check a representative sample file.
A larger file does not automatically provide more useful information from the slide.
-
Looking only at seconds per scan
The time taken for one scan doesn’t tell you how long it will take to load, check, clean and organise the slides. Automatic magazine processing is only helpful if the slides and magazines are compatible.
Check that the holders or magazines are compatible, and plan the full workflow for the job.
Even when scanning is quick, you’ll still need time to check the images and organise the files.
-
Assuming a discontinued flatbed scanner is still available new
Epson Netherlands lists the Perfection V600 Photo as discontinued. Old product specifications alone don’t tell you whether a specific unit is available new or complete.
If you find one for sale, check its condition, the included holders and whether the software works on your computer.
Missing holders or software that doesn’t work on your computer could mean extra work for the job.
Brands to consider
Plustek
The OpticFilm 8200i SE is a dedicated option for scanning 35mm slides using a computer.
- Plustek specifies 7200 dpi optical resolution and infrared detection of dust and scratches for this model.
- Check that the software is compatible with your operating system. The specifications are not an independent comparison of the final image quality.
reflecta
The x33-Scan offers standalone JPEG storage; the DigitDia evolution is designed for compatible slide magazines.
- According to reflecta, the x33-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card. The manufacturer describes the DigitDia evolution as automatically processing compatible magazines.
- You load slides manually into the x33-Scan. Check that your magazine is compatible with the DigitDia evolution; these features apply to the models mentioned.
Kodak Photo Plus
The European 5-inch Slide N Scan has a screen and SD storage for supported slide and film types.
- The supplier specifies a 14MP sensor, screen and SD storage for this version.
- An SD card is not included. Note that this is different from the separate 7-inch Slide N Scan.
Rollei
The DF-S 310 SE is designed to process slides and several film types independently.
- Rollei lists 128 MB of internal memory and support for SD/SDHC cards up to 32 GB.
- The stated speed for scanning a batch of slides is not the same as the total time needed to check and transfer them.
Epson
The Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed scanner with holders for framed 35mm slides and support for other materials.
- Epson Netherlands describes this scanner as suitable for several types of scanning material.
- Epson Netherlands lists the model as discontinued. If you find one for sale, check its condition, holders and whether the software works.
Joybuy products for this purpose
These flatbed scanners could be an option if you also want to scan materials other than slides. Before buying, check that the transparency unit, slide holders and software you need are available for your job.
No image available
Canon imageFORMULA DR-F120
A flatbed option to consider if you want to scan materials other than slides too; check that the slide accessories and software you need are suitable for your workflow.
Flatbed and ADF scanner; 600 × 600 dpi; A4; black.
Joybuy
No image available
Epson WorkForce DS-1660W
A flatbed option to consider if you also scan other materials; check that the slide holders and software you need are suitable for your job.
Flatbed scanner; 1200 × 1200 dpi; A4; black and white.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Should I choose the highest megapixel count or dpi?
No. Start with the file the client expects. For the x33-Scan, reflecta distinguishes between the standard sensor output and higher interpolated output; don’t treat them as if both capture extra detail from the film.
What should I check before scanning the first slide?
Check that the slide and mount fit the holder, scan a representative image and view the saved file before processing the whole batch. reflecta specifies that the x33-Scan holders accommodate framed slides up to 3.2 mm thick.
How can I make sure the digital handover is useful?
Agree the file format and organisation with the client, check the exported files and store the selection as agreed. The National Archives distinguishes purposeful selection, organisation and description from simply making a backup.
Can I hand over holiday slides showing identifiable people to a client without making any further arrangements?
There’s no general yes-or-no answer without knowing who is processing the images, for what purpose and who will receive them. According to the Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens, identifiable people may be personal data; the exception for purely personal use does not apply to business processing. If you process such data solely on behalf of another organisation as a processor, the Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens says a data processing agreement is required. Consent is not automatically the only possible legal basis under the GDPR.
Does owning the slides automatically give me permission to publish the images?
No. Auteursrecht.nl states that even a holiday photo may be protected by copyright. If you plan to publish, establish who holds the rights and what use is permitted; the exact rights to these slides depend on the circumstances.