Who are these scanning methods for?

35mm photographer with limited storage space

Wants to scan black-and-white negatives at home and work out whether a specialist scanner or a stowable camera setup will fit the space available.

Collector who scans without a computer

Wants to view old film and save files directly, without setting up a computer for every scan.

Photographer with 35mm and 120 film

Has several film formats and wants to check that the chosen method and its included film holders support them all.

Which buying priorities should guide your choice?

Compact computer-connected film scanner

Best for: mainly scanning 35mm black-and-white film and adjusting the settings yourself.

Bear in mind: computer and software compatibility, as well as space to use the film holders.

Standalone scanner

Best for: capturing 35mm film without a computer and saving files straight away.

Bear in mind: the supported film format, and what sensor resolution and interpolated output actually mean.

Camera scanning kit with film holder

Best for: working with different film formats and packing the setup away afterwards.

Bear in mind: you’ll need your own camera or smartphone, and space for the setup while you’re using it.

Flatbed scanner with film unit

Best for: scanning originals other than film as well, and having room for a larger scanner.

Bear in mind: the availability of suitable film holders and software; Epson says the Perfection V600 Photo has been discontinued.

First decide which film formats you want to scan and whether you’ll be using a computer. Then measure both your storage space and the room needed for the complete setup while you’re scanning.

What to consider What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Storage and working space Measure the scanner when stored away, as well as the full setup with the film holder and camera or phone in place. If I have limited shelf space, I also want to know how much room scanning itself takes. Around 33% of consumers give storage and working space top priority.
Control over the scan Check the scanning settings and software; don’t expect the usual infrared dust detection to work with traditional silver-based black-and-white film. If tone, detail and the ability to make corrections afterwards matter to you, it’s worth understanding the scanning process first. Around 27% of consumers prioritise control over the black-and-white scan.
Film format Check whether the exact scanner or kit supports 35mm, 120 or your other film formats, and which holders are included. If I have different formats, I want to know whether one setup will work for them all. Format compatibility is a top priority for around 20% of consumers.
Scanning without a computer Check how files are saved and which output formats are available. If you want to scan and save files directly, you won’t want to need a computer while capturing them. Around 20% of consumers give standalone scanning top priority.

Common pitfalls when buying a film scanner

  • Choosing infrared as a fix for dust on traditional black-and-white film

    With traditional silver-based black-and-white emulsion, the usual infrared defect detection doesn’t work. LaserSoft Imaging cites certain black-and-white films developed using the C-41 process as an exception.

    Check how your film was developed and look at a test scan. Assess software-based correction separately if you want to deal with dust or damage.

    Bear in mind that cleaning or retouching may take extra time.

  • Confusing interpolated megapixels with sensor resolution

    An output figure increased through interpolation isn’t the same type of specification as sensor resolution. For example, KODAK distinguishes between 14MP sensor resolution and 22MP interpolated output.

    Compare like-for-like resolution specifications and consider whether the files will suit your editing or printing needs.

  • Measuring only the scanner’s stored dimensions

    Film holders need to be fitted during scanning, and a camera scanning kit also uses your own camera or smartphone. The setup may therefore take up more room in use than the stored item does.

    Measure your available workspace and check which equipment and parts you already own.

    A camera scanning kit also needs a suitable camera or smartphone, plus space to set it up.

  • Buying a discontinued flatbed model without checking the holders and software

    Epson says the Perfection V600 Photo has been discontinued. Whether it will work for your film also depends on having suitable holders and software that works with your computer.

    If buying old stock or second-hand, check which film holders are included and whether the software will work on your computer.

Relevant brands to consider

Plustek

Plustek describes the OpticFilm 8100 and 8200i SE as specialist 35mm film scanners for use with a computer.

  • Plustek lists support for black-and-white negatives and an optical resolution of 7200 dpi for the OpticFilm 8100; this specification isn’t an independent measurement of image detail.
  • As LaserSoft Imaging explains, the OpticFilm 8200i SE’s infrared feature does not provide the usual dust detection for traditional silver-based black-and-white film.

reflecta

According to reflecta, the x33-Scan is a standalone scanner for 35mm film strips and slides.

  • Reflecta lists JPEG storage on an SD card and a built-in 5-inch screen.
  • Reflecta specifies a 15.3MP sensor as well as a maximum interpolated output; don’t treat these as the same type of resolution.

KODAK Photo Plus

According to KODAK Photo Plus, the Slide N Scan is a standalone scanner for the listed 135, 110 and 126 colour and black-and-white negatives.

  • The product specifications list a 14MP sensor and 22MP output through interpolation, so 22MP is not the stated sensor resolution.
  • Check which film adapters are included with the version on offer.

Lomography

According to Lomography, the DigitaLIZA Max is a film holder and light source kit that lets you use your own smartphone or digital camera to scan formats including 35mm and 120 film.

  • The manual lists a smartphone stand as part of the kit.
  • Check which holders and any additional masks are included in each package; you’ll need to supply the camera or phone used to take the picture.

Epson

Epson lists support for 35mm and 120/220 film for the Perfection V600 Photo. Epson Netherlands says this model has been discontinued.

  • As well as film, a flatbed scanner can handle other originals.
  • The stated dimensions are 280 × 485 × 118 mm. If buying old stock or second-hand, check that the film holders are complete and the software will work.

Joybuy product picks

For computer-based 35mm scanning, consider the Plustek OpticFilm 8100, which supports black-and-white negatives. If you want a standalone option for 35mm film strips and slides, look at the reflecta x33-Scan, with JPEG storage on an SD card. For a flexible setup covering 35mm and 120 film, the Lomography DigitaLIZA Max lets you use your own camera or smartphone. Check compatibility, included holders and the space each setup needs before choosing.

Frequently asked questions

Does infrared dust removal work with my black-and-white negatives?

Not with traditional silver-based black-and-white film: the emulsion prevents the usual infrared defect detection from working. LaserSoft Imaging cites certain black-and-white films developed using the C-41 process as an exception. Check how your film was developed and assess software-based correction separately.

What do I need for a camera scanning kit?

According to Lomography, the DigitaLIZA Max works with your own smartphone or digital camera. The manual describes film holders, a light panel and a smartphone stand; before buying, check which parts and any masks are included in the package on offer.

What can I do if my scanner doesn’t work properly after I buy it?

In the Netherlands, a product you buy must conform to the agreement; if it’s faulty, the seller must provide a solution, as the Dutch government explains. For many purchases made online from a business, you also have a 14-day cooling-off period. Check which terms apply to your purchase.

Can I scan and share other people’s photos from negatives?

Making a copy for your own use is different from distributing or publishing a photo. According to the Dutch government, you need the creator’s permission to distribute or publish copyright-protected photos.

Is it worth paying someone to digitise a large collection?

Outsourcing can save time and is worth considering if you have a lot of film or valuable images. The Dutch Consumers’ Association advises asking in advance about resolution, file format and any corrections included in the service.