Manager of a mixed negative collection
Wants to process old portraits that may come in different film formats, starting by cataloguing the originals and holders.
Start by identifying the film formats and checking the condition of the negatives. Then choose a scanner and holder that suit the originals. A dedicated scanner is designed for a collection made up solely of 35 mm film, while mixed formats may call for a compatible multi-format model or a flatbed scanner. Also consider whether you want to review files on a computer or scan straight to JPEG without one, and allow time for test scans, checking and organising your files.
Wants to process old portraits that may come in different film formats, starting by cataloguing the originals and holders.
Wants to scan lots of 35 mm portraits and weigh up how much manual checking is needed alongside automatic film transport.
Wants to review and organise scans, and find them again later. The National Archives describes selection, organisation and making records accessible as part of digital archiving.
Start by identifying the formats and holders, then decide which file format and scanning process best suit your archive.
Choose this option: if your collection consists solely of 35 mm negatives or mounted slides, and you want to review scans on a computer.
The trade-off: the Plustek OpticFilm 8200i SE is specified for 35 mm; don’t assume it also supports 120 film.
Choose this option: if your collection includes 35 mm and the 120 formats up to 6 × 9 cm listed by reflecta, and scanning without a computer is important to you.
The trade-off: the reflecta x66-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card; its stated 22 MP output is interpolated from a 14 MP sensor.
Choose this option: if you need to process larger film formats or prints as well as 35 mm film.
The trade-off: Epson lists the Perfection V850 Pro as discontinued. If you buy one second-hand, check the holders, software and condition, among other things.
| Consideration | What to check before buying | Who is this important to? |
|---|---|---|
| Film formats and holders | Measure the originals and check the scan area and supplied holders for each model. | If I manage negatives in different formats, I want to know whether they will actually fit in the scanner and holder. Around 29% of consumers say format compatibility is their main concern. |
| Files for the archive | Check the output format and software for the exact version; plan test scans, file names and quality checks. | If scans need to be found and reviewed later, I look beyond capturing the image to how files are organised and described. Around 29% of consumers prioritise useful archive files. |
| Work involved for the whole collection | Count strips and individual frames, then use a test batch to assess the entire process, including loading and checking. | When there are lots of portraits to process, I want to account for the time needed for the whole workflow, not just the scanning time. Around 24% of consumers prioritise the amount of processing work involved. |
| Scanning without a computer | Check how files are saved and transferred, and whether volunteers can open and review them. | If the shared workspace needs to stay simple, standalone scanning may be appealing; I weigh this against the output file format I need. Around 18% of consumers prioritise standalone operation. |
The reflecta x66-Scan has a 14 MP sensor; its stated 22 MP output is interpolated, so it does not represent that number of sensor pixels.
Compare the original specifications and assess representative test scans instead of focusing only on the highest output figure.
Scanning time doesn’t automatically include preparation, file naming and quality checks. The National Archives describes digitisation as a process with separate stages.
Test a representative batch and assess how long the complete workflow takes.
Allow time for preparation, loading, naming and checking too.
Epson lists this model as discontinued, although its product specifications are still available to view.
If you buy one second-hand, check its condition, film holders, software and terms of sale.
Finding compatible holders or working software may take extra time.
According to LaserSoft Imaging, silver particles in traditional black-and-white film can interfere with infrared detection.
If possible, test a representative negative and assess what further correction is needed.
An unsuitable correction process may mean extra manual editing.
The OpticFilm 8200i SE is a computer-connected scanner for 35 mm negatives and slides.
The RPS 10S is designed for 35 mm film transport; the x66-Scan is a standalone model for 35 mm and medium formats listed by the manufacturer.
The Perfection V850 Pro is an example of a flatbed scanner for different film formats and prints.
No. Identify the film format first, as the scanners and holders mentioned support different formats. Check the fit and results with a test scan.
No. Don’t rely on it for traditional silver-based black-and-white film without doing a test scan first. According to LaserSoft Imaging, silver particles can interfere with infrared detection, so identify the film types in your collection.
No. The National Archives also describes digital archiving as selecting, organising and describing records for future use. Plan to check your scans and store your files safely too.
Not without first considering the privacy and copyright implications. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that identifiable people in images may be classed as personal data; publication does not automatically fall under the exception for exclusively personal or household use. The Dutch Government also states that someone else’s copyright-protected photos may not be made public without permission. Scanning does not, in itself, give you the right to publish.
Epson lists the Perfection V850 Pro as discontinued. If you buy one second-hand, assess its condition, the holders available and the software separately.