A group with negatives in different formats
You have material whose film format still needs to be identified, and are looking for a suitable way to handle 35mm, 120 film or other formats. Support varies between scanners and models.
Start by identifying whether the collection contains 35mm, 120 film or other formats; a landscape-oriented photograph tells you nothing about the film format. A standalone scanner may be suitable for simply viewing and sharing compatible film, while a film scanner or flatbed with a film unit may be worth considering for more careful work or mixed formats. If the collection is large, weigh the total scanning time against using a professional service.
You have material whose film format still needs to be identified, and are looking for a suitable way to handle 35mm, 120 film or other formats. Support varies between scanners and models.
You want to assess and preserve landscape photographs carefully, and are prepared to spend time scanning and editing them to retain control over the files.
You share the tasks of feeding in, checking and storing images among several people. For your group, the total time involved and the ability to follow a repeatable process are key.
First, take stock of the film formats. Then decide which matters most to your group: archive-level detail, processing time or easy sharing.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who is this important to? |
|---|---|---|
| Film format and holders | Identify the physical film and check the scan area and compatible holders for the exact model. | If I’m not sure whether the collection contains 35mm or 120 film, I want to find out what the scanner can handle first. Around 33% of consumers prioritise format compatibility. |
| Archive-level detail | Ask for a test scan of your own film and compare it for your intended use; also check which file formats are available. | If I want to assess or preserve landscape images carefully, I want to be able to tailor the scan and file to my needs. Around 27% of consumers prioritise detail and control over archive files. |
| Feeding and processing time | Count the strips and individual frames, then test a full session, including checking, naming and storing files. | If volunteers have a lot of images to process, I want to know how much work each usable scan really takes. Around 20% of consumers prioritise throughput and volunteer time. |
| Easy viewing and sharing | Check the controls, whether an SD card is needed, the output files, and how to transfer and name them. | If different volunteers want to view and share scans straight away, an easy-to-follow process matters. Around 20% of consumers prioritise getting started easily and sharing files. |
The orientation of an image doesn’t tell you which physical film format was used. So a scanner with a 35mm scan area won’t automatically handle 120 negatives.
Identify and sort the negatives before choosing a model. Then check the scan area and holder for each format.
If a holder isn’t compatible, you may need to use a different scanning method for part of the collection.
Sensor values, stated hardware resolution and measured resolution are different specifications and aren’t directly comparable.
Compare test scans of your own film for the same intended display or print size, and check which resolution measurement is being quoted.
A higher quoted figure could mean more scanning time and larger files, without being necessary for your intended use.
Automatic feeding can make it easier to load compatible film strips, but sorting, cleaning, checking and editing are still part of the process.
Start by testing a representative batch and keep track of the entire workflow, not just the quoted scanning time.
The group will also need to set aside volunteer time for checking and editing files.
Epson lists the Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro as discontinued on its Dutch product pages.
If you’re considering a specific model, check its condition, the film holders required and whether it’s supported by the group’s computer.
Missing holders or compatible software could mean extra preparation and work.
Plustek offers models for specific 35mm film and for the stated 35mm and 120 formats.
The RPS 10S is worth considering if the collection contains a lot of compatible 35mm strips.
The Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro illustrate when a flatbed scanner with a film unit may be useful for mixed formats.
The 5-inch Slide N Scan offers a standalone option for the film formats listed on the EU product page.
No. The orientation of the photograph doesn’t determine the film format. Identify the film first, then check the scan area and holder for the exact model.
For this version, Kodak Photo Plus lists holders for 135, 110 and 126 film. The product page says an SD card is required but not included; check the version and the parts supplied before buying.
Not on conventional silver-based black-and-white film. According to LaserSoft Imaging, the silver-based emulsion blocks the iSRD infrared method. Clean the film carefully and consider a different editing method for this material.
It depends on the number of images, the equipment and the time volunteers can give. Compare quotes for the same film format, desired resolution and file format. The Consumentenbond points out that scanning images yourself can take a lot of time.
First, check the rights and any personal data involved in the intended publication. The Dutch government says that permission from the creator is needed to publish copyright-protected photographs. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that organisations need a legal basis under the GDPR to process personal data, and that in most cases they need the consent of the people concerned to publish it online. These are requirements for publication, not general requirements for a scanner.