Archivist with a small desk
You occasionally scan minutes at a shared workspace and want to put the scanner away neatly afterwards. Compare the space it takes up when stored upright with the space it needs while in use.
For loose or bound club minutes that you want to place carefully on the glass, an A4 flatbed scanner is well suited to the task. A model with a stand for upright storage can be put away compactly after scanning, but still needs room for paper and the lid while in use. If you often scan stacks of suitable loose sheets, compare a flatbed model with one that has an automatic document feeder, and check the computer and software requirements for your archive files.
You occasionally scan minutes at a shared workspace and want to put the scanner away neatly afterwards. Compare the space it takes up when stored upright with the space it needs while in use.
Your archive includes booklets or loose documents that you would rather place individually on a flatbed. Check the document size and lid design before choosing a document feeder.
You regularly scan several pages in one session and want to weigh up how much manual page handling is involved compared with a flatbed scanner with an automatic feeder for suitable loose sheets.
Best for: loose pages, fragile documents or booklets that you place individually on the glass, and a scanner you want to put away after use.
Bear in mind: you place the pages on the glass yourself, and need to leave room for paper and the lid while scanning. Canon Netherlands lists a vertical position and a Z-lid for the LiDE 400; Epson Netherlands lists a built-in stand for the Perfection V39II.
Best for: a club that scans both individual originals and large volumes of suitable loose sheets. HP describes the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 as combining a flatbed with an automatic feeder.
Bear in mind: measure the space needed to feed and collect the paper too; the feeder speed does not tell you how quickly the flatbed scans.
Best for: mainly suitable loose sheets, when you do not need a flatbed. Brother lists an automatic 20-sheet feeder for the ADS-1300.
Bear in mind: this is not a flatbed scanner; you will need another scanning method for bound, fragile or unsuitable documents.
| What to consider | What to check before buying | Who should pay particular attention? |
|---|---|---|
| Space in use and storage | Measure the space for the scanner itself, as well as the room needed for paper and an open lid. Canon Netherlands gives the LiDE 400 dimensions as 250 × 367 × 42 mm; these are the scanner’s dimensions, not the space it needs in use. | If you use a shared or temporary scanning desk, you will want to know whether the scanner can be put away between sessions. Around 33% of consumers prioritise limited desk space. |
| Bound or fragile documents | Check the maximum page size and whether the lid design suits your booklets. The maximum flatbed size of the Canon LiDE 400 is 216 × 297 mm. | If you would rather place a booklet or fragile sheet on the glass individually, also check whether the text near the spine remains legible. Around 27% of consumers prioritise careful scanning. |
| Large numbers of loose pages | Estimate how many sheets you scan per session and check whether the originals are suitable for automatic feeding. Only compare speeds when the scanning method and settings are the same. | If you regularly scan stacks of suitable loose sheets, reducing manual page handling may matter more to you. Around 20% of consumers prioritise processing speed. |
| Easy-to-find archive files | Check the software for the exact model and your operating system. Create a test file and check that the text is legible and searchable. | If you want volunteers to be able to find minutes later, check the file output and organisation as well as the scanning function. Around 20% of consumers prioritise being able to find files easily. |
A stand can save space between scanning sessions, but you still need room for the glass, paper and lid while scanning.
Measure the setup when the scanner is in use, and don’t mistake the scanner’s dimensions for the total space required.
Canon Netherlands lists around 8 seconds for an A4 colour scan at 300 dpi on the LiDE 400; this does not include transfer to the computer. That is not the same as the total time needed to position, scan and check a document.
Try out a workflow with a representative booklet and a stack of loose pages before making speed your deciding factor.
Allow time for handling pages, transferring files and checking the results.
A PDF button or text enhancement feature does not automatically mean the text in your minutes will be recognised and made searchable.
Check the software for the exact model and operating system, then test the search function in a sample file.
Text recognition, corrections and file organisation may require extra work.
Scans may contain personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that organisations must protect personal data properly and must not keep it for longer than necessary.
Decide who can access the digital archive and how long it needs to be kept. Don’t treat a cloud feature as automatic permission to share files.
The CanoScan LiDE range includes compact A4 flatbed scanners. The LiDE 400 is worth considering if you want to compare upright positioning and a Z-lid.
The Perfection V39II is an A4 flatbed scanner with a stand for upright storage. This could be useful if you want to put the scanner away between sessions.
The ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 is worth considering if you want to combine a flatbed with automatic feeding for suitable loose sheets.
The ADS-1300 is a compact document feeder scanner for situations where the minutes mainly consist of suitable loose sheets.
These Joybuy products combine a flatbed with an automatic document feeder, so you can scan both individual originals and stacks of suitable loose sheets.
No image available
The combination of a flatbed and automatic feeder suits both individual documents and stacks of suitable loose pages.
The product information lists A4, 600 × 600 dpi, double-sided scanning and an automatic 50-sheet feeder. Use the flatbed for bound or fragile documents; the feeder is designed for loose sheets.
No image available
The flatbed and document feeder give you different ways to scan individual originals and suitable loose sheets.
The product information lists an automatic 100-sheet feeder, speeds of up to 25 pages per minute and single-pass double-sided scanning. Place bound or fragile documents individually on the flatbed.
No image available
This model combines a flatbed for books and bound documents with automatic feeding for suitable loose pages.
The product information lists 1200 × 1200 dpi, USB and wireless connectivity, and double-sided scanning. Scan bound documents individually on the flatbed; the feeder is designed for loose sheets.
No. An automatic feeder is designed for suitable loose sheets. Bound documents or those that cannot be fed need a flatbed or another suitable scanning method. The HP ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a flatbed with a feeder, while the Brother ADS-1300 is a feeder-only scanner.
As well as measuring the space for the scanner, allow room to position paper and open the lid. A stand for upright storage can make it easier to put the scanner away, but it does not remove the need for workspace during a scanning session. Also check that the connection and software are compatible with the computer you use.
No. A PDF button or text enhancement feature does not show that the text in your minutes will be recognised. Check the software for the exact model and your operating system, then test whether you can actually search a sample file.
Check that sample scans are legible and organise files clearly. The National Archives offers individuals and small organisations guidance on keeping and using digital files; this is archiving advice, not a legal requirement for choosing a scanner.
Not without considering the purpose, access and security. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that organisations must not keep personal data for longer than necessary and must protect it properly. Carefully consider who can receive the scans too; the applicable retention period depends on the purpose and contents of the archive.