Who are these scanners for?

35mm photographer who wants to edit their scans

If you mainly scan 35mm black-and-white negatives and want to edit the files yourself, compare the available settings and software with the extra time required for a computer-based scanning workflow. Plustek specifies that the OpticFilm 8100 is designed for 35mm black-and-white negatives.

Collector with a mix of negative formats

If you also have 120 film or printed photos, check that the scanner and supplied holders support those formats. Epson lists 35mm and 120/220 film among the formats supported by the Perfection V600 Photo.

Quick home digitisation

If you want to scan without using a computer, look for standalone models that save files to a memory card. The Consumers' Association (Consumentenbond) points out that basic scanners generally capture less detail than good film scanners, so consider whether the files will be suitable for how you plan to use them.

What should you look for when choosing?

Choose a scanner based on the files you want to keep, your film formats and how much manual work you’re prepared to do.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this most important for?
Scan detail and black-and-white editing Check the scan settings and dust-correction process. Infrared does not work on traditional silver-based black-and-white film. If I want to enlarge my scans or edit them extensively, I want to know how much control I have over the scan and how much extra time it will take. Around 31% of consumers put scan detail and the black-and-white workflow first.
Saving files locally Check whether files are saved to a computer or memory card, which formats are available and whether a card is included. If I want to keep my scans locally and edit them later, I look at where they’ll be saved and which file types are available. Around 31% of consumers give local file output top priority.
Supported film formats Compare the exact formats supported and the holders supplied with your collection, such as 35mm versus 120/220 film. If I have different film formats, I want to avoid finding that some of my collection won’t fit the holders. Around 23% of consumers put support for multiple formats first.
Feeding and manual work Check whether film feeding is automatic and which strip lengths are supported. If I have a large pile of negatives, I want to spend less time positioning each frame. Around 15% of consumers give processing speed and reduced manual work top priority.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming infrared correction works on every black-and-white negative

    Infrared dust removal does not work on traditional silver-based black-and-white film. If you’re relying on it, you may still need to deal with dust after scanning.

    Check which type of film you have, and consider cleaning and any software correction separately from the infrared specification.

    Allow extra time to clean your film or correct scans afterwards.

  • Confusing an interpolated megapixel figure with captured detail

    The Kodak SCANZA is listed with a 14MP sensor and a 22MP setting achieved through interpolation. These are different specifications and do not mean the same thing.

    Compare the stated sensor or optical specifications and think about how you plan to use the files. Don’t base your choice on the highest megapixel figure alone.

  • Focusing only on the speed of a standalone scanner

    The Consumers' Association (Consumentenbond) describes basic scanners as fast, but says they generally capture less detail than good film scanners. A quick scan may therefore be less suitable if you need a high level of detail.

    Decide whether you mainly want a quick-to-view archive or files that you can edit further.

    If the scans aren’t suitable for your needs, you may have to spend extra time making them again.

  • Assuming cards, software and film holders are the same with every model

    The film holders, computer requirements and accessories supplied vary from model to model. For example, a memory card is not included with the Kodak SCANZA.

    Before buying, check what’s included, which film formats are supported and whether the software is compatible with your computer.

Brands to compare

Plustek

According to Plustek, the OpticFilm 8100 is a computer-based film scanner for 35mm negatives, including black-and-white film.

  • Plustek specifies 7200 dpi and includes SilverFast SE Plus software.
  • According to Plustek’s range comparison, the model does not have a built-in infrared channel. The stated resolution is a manufacturer’s specification, not a standalone measure of the detail captured in a scan.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed scanner for 35mm and 120/220 film, among other formats, as well as printed originals.

  • Epson lists holders for the film formats mentioned and TIFF and JPEG output.
  • Check that the software works on your computer. If you’re scanning traditional silver-based black-and-white film, don’t assume that DIGITAL ICE will use infrared to remove dust from it.

reflecta

According to reflecta, the RPS 10S is a computer-based 35mm film scanner with automatic film feeding.

  • reflecta specifies automatic feeding for strips of 3 to 40 frames and DNG output for raw data.
  • The listed MagicTouch feature uses infrared. This does not mean dust correction will work on traditional silver-based black-and-white film.

Rollei

According to Rollei, the DF-S 310 SE is a standalone slide and negative scanner with internal memory and an SD/SDHC slot.

  • Rollei says the model can scan without a computer and comes with holders for formats including 110 film.
  • Scanning without a computer is a different approach from using a film scanner and software. Don’t compare the two on stated megapixels alone.

Kodak Photo Plus

According to the retailer, the SCANZA is a standalone film-to-JPEG scanner for formats including 35mm, 126 and 110 film.

  • The retailer lists a 14MP sensor, 22MP through interpolation and storage on an SD/SDHC card.
  • JPEG is listed as the output format, and a memory card is not included. Check whether this suits your editing needs.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does infrared dust removal work on my black-and-white negatives?

Not on traditional silver-based black-and-white film. First, find out what type of film you have. You can reduce dust before scanning and consider software correction afterwards separately. Check the features of the specific software you plan to use.

What should I install or get ready before my first scan?

According to Plustek, the OpticFilm 8100 requires computer software, so check that it’s compatible with your operating system. The retailer says the standalone Kodak SCANZA uses an SD/SDHC card, which isn’t included. Clean your negatives and the scanning surface before you start, too.

Who can help if a scanner bought in the Netherlands doesn’t work properly?

When you buy as a consumer, the seller must offer a solution if the product is faulty. According to the Dutch government, the Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period. Any manufacturer’s guarantee is separate from your statutory rights.

How does the old-for-new scheme work for household appliances?

According to the Dutch government, when you buy a similar new household appliance, a shop must take your old appliance away free of charge. This also applies to online purchases, although the practical arrangements for returning it may vary.