Who is this for?

Creator with a 35mm archive to scan

You want to scan and edit black-and-white negatives. Having control over the scanning process, suitable film holders and software matters more to you than one-button operation. Plustek lists SilverFast SE Plus software as included with the OpticFilm 8200i SE.

Creator with several film formats

Alongside 35mm, you may have 120 film, for example, and want to check in advance that the exact model and its holders support those formats. The reflecta and Epson models differ in the film formats their manufacturers say they support.

Creator working to a moving deadline

You want to catalogue a lot of images in time and work out how much manual loading, checking and file management you can realistically manage. The reflecta RPS 10S lists automatic feeding for compatible strips; the Library of Congress recommends keeping verified copies on different storage media and in separate locations.

What should you look for?

Before choosing a scanning method, match the film formats you have to the files you want, and consider how much time you can spend loading and checking them before the move.

What to consider What should you check? Who should pay particular attention?
Supported film formats Check that the exact model and supplied holders are suitable for 35mm, 120 or any other formats in your archive. If I also have 120 negatives, I want to be sure the scanner and holder are suitable for them. Format is the top purchasing concern for around 36% of consumers.
Detail and file format Compare native sensor or scanning specifications and available output formats; an interpolated resolution doesn’t capture extra sensor detail. If I want to edit important images later, I look at the scan settings and usable output files. Archive detail is the top purchasing concern for around 29% of consumers.
Feeding and checking time Count the images and strips, then test whether loading, checking and backing them up will all fit into your schedule. With a moving deadline, I want to know in advance how much work my collection will involve and set aside time to check the files. A manageable workflow before the move is the top purchasing concern for around 21% of consumers.
Operation and accessories Check whether you need a computer or memory card, which software is required and whether adapters are included. If I want to get started easily, I want to know whether I’ll have the right card, power supply and adapters straight away. Ease of use is the top purchasing concern for around 14% of consumers.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming infrared correction will automatically remove dust from black-and-white film

    The usual infrared method doesn’t work for dust correction with traditional silver-based black-and-white emulsion. So a scanner feature with that name isn’t a reason to spend less time inspecting and correcting your scans.

    Check the condition of your negatives and make a test scan. Inspect any software-based correction on the image yourself.

    Allow extra time to check for dust and make any manual corrections.

  • Assuming a high dpi or megapixel rating means more captured detail

    According to reflecta, the reflecta x66-Scan has a 14MP sensor and an interpolated 22MP mode. That higher setting doesn’t mean the sensor has captured more detail.

    Compare native specifications and output files, and test-scan a representative negative before processing your whole collection.

  • Treating a discontinued flatbed as a new purchase

    Epson Netherlands lists the Perfection V600 Photo as discontinued. If you’re considering a second-hand or remaining unit, its condition, complete film holders and software compatibility will all help determine whether it’s suitable for your archive.

    Check the holders, test it with your computer and review the terms offered by the specific seller.

    You may need to find suitable film holders or compatible software.

  • Keeping scans in just one place during a move

    If a card or drive contains your only copy, losing it could also mean losing the only digital version of your scans. The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on different storage media and in separate physical locations.

    Open a sample of the files and check the copies before packing away your originals and scanning equipment.

    Allow extra time to check your files and set up a second storage device.

Brands and models to compare

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8200i SE is designed for 35mm negatives and slides; Plustek lists SilverFast SE Plus software as included.

  • Plustek lists an optical resolution of 7200 dpi.
  • That stated resolution isn’t an independent measure of visible detail. The scanner is designed for 35mm; don’t count infrared dust correction as an advantage for traditional silver-based black-and-white film.

reflecta

The RPS 10S is designed to automatically feed suitable 35mm strips; according to reflecta, the standalone x66-Scan also supports 120 black-and-white film.

  • reflecta lists automatic feeding of 3 to 40 images for the RPS 10S. The x66-Scan saves directly as JPEG and has a 14MP sensor.
  • The x66-Scan’s stated 22MP mode is interpolated. The RPS 10S’s infrared correction won’t remove dust from traditional silver-based black-and-white film.

KODAK Photo Plus

The 5-inch SLIDE N SCAN is a standalone option for 135, 110 and 126 black-and-white negatives, among other formats.

  • Kodak Photo Plus lists a 14MP sensor and direct saving to an SD card.
  • An SD card is required but isn’t included; 120 film isn’t among the listed formats. The Consumers’ Association places simple sensor-based scanners below a good film scanner in terms of quality.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed option for 35mm and 120/220 film, as well as prints.

  • Epson Netherlands lists film holders and TIFF output.
  • Epson Netherlands lists the V600 as discontinued. Don’t treat a second-hand or remaining unit as a confirmed new purchase, and check the holders, operation and computer support.

Products at Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does infrared dust removal work on my black-and-white negatives?

Not as a general solution for traditional silver-based black-and-white film. According to SilverFast, the silver-based emulsion reflects infrared light, which means the iSRD infrared method can’t be used with it. Check your negatives and visually inspect any software retouching.

What should I check before my first large scanning session?

Start with a test scan of a representative negative, then check the holder, crop and file on your computer. Assess delicate originals before loading them; the Library of Congress recommends considering the condition of the material and the risks of the scanning workflow.

How should I store my scans during the move?

Check that the saved images can be opened, and keep copies on at least two different storage media in separate physical locations. This is preservation advice from the Library of Congress, not a legal retention requirement for a private studio.

Do I need to buy a memory card or software separately?

It depends on the exact model. Kodak Photo Plus says the 5-inch SLIDE N SCAN needs an SD card, which isn’t included; reflecta lists SD card storage for the x66-Scan. For a scanner that connects to a computer, also check that the required software works with your operating system.

What consumer rights apply when buying online in the Netherlands?

If you buy online from a business as a consumer, the Dutch government says you’ll often have a 14-day cooling-off period; an online purchase from a private individual isn’t covered by distance-selling rules in the same way. If a product is faulty, contact the seller. The Dutch government says there’s no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands: what you can expect also depends on the product and the circumstances of the purchase.