Which drive is right for you?

Keeper of family letters

You’re digitising letters that you don’t want to scan again. You want to be able to find important files and check that they’re still readable after copying. The Library of Congress recommends opening a sample of copied files to check them.

Collector with a growing scan archive

You’re storing more and more scans at a home workspace. Check the size of your current folders and estimate how much they’re likely to grow before choosing a capacity.

User with multiple workspaces

You regularly connect your archive to another computer or take the drive with you. So check not only the cable, but also the file system and the specifications of the exact variant.

What should you consider?

When choosing a drive for a home archive, don’t focus on capacity or speed alone. Think about how you’ll restore your scans, which computer you’ll use the drive with and how often you’ll move it.

Portable external HDD

Choose this if: you mainly need space for a growing archive that will usually stay at your home workspace.

Consider: Consumentenbond says HDDs are more susceptible to wear and shock than SSDs.

Portable external SSD

Choose this if: you often take the drive with you or regularly use files directly from it.

Consider: a stated maximum speed doesn’t tell you how much time you’ll save when copying scans of your letters. Also check that your computer supports the model’s connection.

What to consider What to look for Which consumers prioritise this
Restorable copy Decide where you’ll keep the second copy, then open a few important scans after copying to check them. If I can’t scan the letters again, I want to know there’s a readable copy somewhere else too. Around 42% of consumers prioritise being able to restore their files.
Connection and file system Compare your computer’s port with the cable, and check the file system before transferring your scans. If I want to use the drive straight away with my home computer, I check both the port and the file system. Around 33% of consumers give top priority to direct connection and usability.
Space for scans Check the size of your current scan folders and allow room for new files and any copies. For a growing collection, I want to know how much space my folders take up and how many more scans I can add. Around 17% of consumers prioritise archive capacity.
Moving the drive and working from it Decide how often you’ll take the drive with you and check that your computer supports the connection on the model you’ve chosen. If I often take the drive with me or work directly from it, that matters more to me than simply having plenty of storage. Around 8% of consumers prioritise portability and working from the drive.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a bigger or faster drive makes a complete archive

    If a drive is lost or becomes unreadable, you could also lose the only digital copy of your letters. Digital archiving also involves organising and checking your files.

    First, check the size of your scan folders and decide where to keep a separate copy that you can check. The Library of Congress recommends opening important files after copying to make sure they’re OK.

  • Assuming every USB drive works straight away with every operating system

    Having the right cable doesn’t guarantee that your computer can use the drive without any extra steps. Toshiba says Canvio Basics needs to be reformatted for the macOS versions specified by the brand.

    Before your first transfer, check the port, cable and file system on the exact variant.

  • Assuming products with similar-sounding names are the same model

    Seagate has several model numbers in its Expansion Portable range, while Toshiba Canvio Basics and Canvio Ready are separate product lines.

    Compare the full model number and the variant’s specifications, not just the brand name, capacity or product photo.

Brands to compare

These brands are useful points of comparison. The features mentioned apply to the product lines and variants described, not necessarily to the entire range.

Western Digital

Elements Portable is a range of portable HDDs for local storage. The WDBU6Y0020BBK-WESN described here is the 2 TB variant.

  • Western Digital lists USB 3.2 Gen 1/USB 3.0 and an included USB-A cable for the variant described.
  • Western Digital lists Windows compatibility; reformatting may be needed for other operating systems.

Seagate

Expansion Portable includes portable HDDs for uses such as storing documents. Seagate lists the 2 TB variant as STKM2000400, with other model numbers available.

  • Seagate lists USB 3.0 and use with Windows and Mac for this product line.
  • Seagate says reformatting is needed for use with Time Machine. Check the exact model number before comparing specifications.

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a range of portable HDDs powered via USB. Toshiba lists HDTB520EK3AA as the 2 TB variant.

  • Toshiba lists NTFS for Windows and connection via a single USB cable.
  • For the macOS versions it specifies, Toshiba says reformatting is needed. Canvio Basics and Canvio Ready are different product lines.

Samsung

The blue Portable SSD T7 MU-PC1T0H/WW is the 1 TB variant described here, for those who regularly connect a compact drive or take it with them.

  • Samsung lists included USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables, as well as optional password protection with AES-256 encryption.
  • Samsung quotes sequential speeds of up to 1.050/1.000 MB/s. This doesn’t guarantee the speed you’ll get with individual scans or protect files from loss without a backup.

Joybuy products for a scan archive

This selection includes portable external SSDs and HDDs for storing scans, with options for a growing archive and for anyone who takes their drive with them.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1 TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1 TB

A portable SSD option if you want to use your scans at other workspaces too.

The title lists 1 TB; the product description quotes read speeds of up to 800 MB/s and drop protection from heights of up to 2 metres.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C, graphite black

WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C, Graphite Black

A portable HDD option for a growing archive that will mostly stay at your home workspace.

The title lists 5 TB and USB-C; the product description mentions USB 3.2 Gen 1 and plug-and-play use.

View at Joybuy
WD My Passport for Mac 2 TB, blue

WD My Passport for Mac 2 TB, blue

A portable HDD option with a variant name that explicitly mentions Mac use.

The product description mentions password protection, hardware encryption, a USB-A cable and a USB-C adapter. Check the file system and compatibility of the exact variant before transferring your scans.

View at Joybuy
WD My Passport 6 TB, white

WD My Passport 6 TB, white

A portable HDD option if you need plenty of capacity for scans and documents.

The title lists 6 TB; the product description mentions USB 3.0, password protection and 256-bit AES hardware encryption.

View at Joybuy
WD My Passport 2 TB, blue

WD My Passport 2 TB, blue

A portable HDD option for scans and documents, with a stated capacity of 2 TB.

The product description mentions USB 3.0, password protection, 256-bit AES hardware encryption and an included USB cable.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one external drive enough for scanned family letters?

No. Keep important scans as a separate copy somewhere else too. The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on different storage media and in separate locations. After copying, open a few important files to check that they’re readable. The National Archives of the Netherlands stresses that digital archiving involves more than just making a backup.

Do you need to format a new drive before connecting it to a Mac?

It depends on the exact model and how you plan to use it. Toshiba says Canvio Basics needs to be reformatted for the macOS versions specified by the brand; Seagate says Expansion Portable needs reformatting for use with Time Machine. Check the instructions for your variant before transferring files.

How can you make a digital archive of letters easy to search?

Use clear folder and file names, check that copied scans are complete and readable, and plan how you’ll transfer them to up-to-date storage later. These steps don’t guarantee how long an HDD or SSD will last.

How do you work out how much storage space you need?

First, check the size of your current scan folders and allow for new scans and any copies you want to keep on the drive. Compare this with the capacity listed for the full model number; a capacity specified for one variant won’t necessarily apply to the whole product line.