Who is this buying guide for?

PC gamer with a small desk

You want to know whether a game supports keyboard controls and need something that fits on a desk you also use for studying. The osu! wiki lists a keyboard as a commonly used input device for osu!, while Logitech G describes the G515 TKL as a keyboard without a number pad.

Console or Taiko player

You want to match your controller to your platform and the specific game, and choose between a standard gamepad and a platform-specific drum. HORI describes separate Taiko versions for different platforms.

Gamer sharing a living space

You want to play dance or motion games, but need to consider the floor space available and any potential noise. In this situation, desk-based controls may be more practical.

What should you look for?

First, check which inputs the game accepts on your platform. Then compare the controller with the space and living environment you’ll be playing in.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who this matters to
Game and platform compatibility Check the exact game title, platform version and required input. HORI lists different Taiko models for different platforms; PlayStation Store Netherlands sets out separate requirements for Beat Saber on PS5. I don’t want to find out that my game won’t accept the controller I’ve chosen; around 31% of consumers put game and platform compatibility first.
Noise in your living space Consider the sound of keys, drum hits or footsteps. Logitech G describes the G515 TKL as having a sound-dampening construction, but this isn’t a measure of how noisy it will be in your room. If I share walls or floors with housemates, I want to know how much noise the controller makes in my room; around 25% of consumers prioritise reducing noise.
Desk or floor space Measure the space available and check where the cable will run. A tenkeyless keyboard has no number pad, while a dance mat or motion game needs floor space. I also use my desk for studying and want to keep my gaming setup compact; around 25% of consumers prioritise being able to use their desk for different things.
How you want to play Decide whether you want keys, gamepad buttons, a Taiko drum or motion controls. Then check that the game supports that input and whether you need any additional software or hardware. If I specifically want to play with a drum, arcade controller or motion controls, I don’t want to replace that particular feel with a standard gamepad; around 19% of consumers prioritise their preferred play style.

Avoiding common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a platform name means a game is compatible

    A controller designed for a platform won’t automatically work with every rhythm game on it. For example, HORI states that its Xbox version of the Taiko drum isn’t compatible with The Drum Master!.

    Before buying, check the full model name, platform and exact game title.

  • Expecting a quiet gaming setup because a product is described as “sound-dampening”

    Logitech G describes the G515 TKL as having a sound-dampening construction, but that doesn’t tell you how much noise you’ll hear in your room. Keyboards, drums and dance mats also make noise in different ways.

    Consider how the controller will sound in your own living space and, if needed, agree some ground rules with your housemates.

  • Forgetting what else you need for a specialist play style

    A Taiko drum or VR controller is only suitable for the intended game and platform combination. HORI says compatible Taiko game software is sold separately; according to PlayStation Store Netherlands, Beat Saber on PS5 also requires PS VR2 and PS VR2 Sense controllers.

    Before buying, check what you already own and what else you’ll need for the way you want to play.

    Some play styles require game software or VR hardware as well as a controller.

Brands to compare

These brands offer different types of controller. Check which model and game combination suits your setup.

Logitech G

The G515 TKL is a wired keyboard without a number pad, designed for PC games that support keyboard input.

  • Logitech G highlights its tenkeyless design and sound-dampening construction.
  • This construction doesn’t prove that it supports a specific game or guarantee that the keyboard is quiet.

GameSir

According to GameSir, the G7 SE is a wired gamepad for Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11.

  • GameSir lists membrane buttons and a detachable USB-C cable.
  • Check separately whether the rhythm game supports a standard gamepad.

8BitDo

The Arcade Controller is designed for button-based play and, according to 8BitDo, has modes for Switch and Windows.

  • 8BitDo lists Bluetooth for Switch, 2.4 GHz for Windows and a wired connection for both.
  • The listed connection options don’t confirm that every rhythm game supports the controller or its button layout.

HORI

HORI offers Taiko drums in separate versions for Switch, PlayStation/Windows and Xbox/Windows.

  • HORI says its drums come with drumsticks and a stand.
  • The versions aren’t interchangeable across all games; according to HORI, the Xbox version doesn’t work with The Drum Master!.

PlayStation

This motion-control option is relevant to Beat Saber on PS5.

  • PlayStation Store Netherlands lists PS VR2 and PS VR2 Sense controllers as requirements for Beat Saber on PS5.
  • This option also requires a PS VR2 headset and isn’t a substitute for standard keyboard or Taiko controls.

Joybuy products for rhythm games

These products are aimed at rhythm games that support standard gamepad input or keyboard controls. Check the input requirements for your game and platform.

Wireless game controller for Switch and PC

Wireless game controller for Switch and PC

An option for rhythm games that support standard gamepad input on Switch or PC.

The product description lists dual vibration motors and a gyroscope.

View at Joybuy
GameSir G7 SE wired Xbox game controller in Dynamic Blue

GameSir G7 SE wired Xbox game controller - Dynamic Blue

Suitable for rhythm games that accept standard gamepad input on a listed Xbox platform or Windows.

The listed platforms are Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11. The product description lists Hall Effect sticks and triggers, as well as programmable back buttons.

View at Joybuy
GameSir Kaleid Flux wired Xbox game controller, smoke transparent RGB

GameSir Kaleid Flux wired Xbox game controller

A wired gamepad option for rhythm games that support standard gamepad input on Xbox or PC.

The product title lists Xbox and PC. The product description lists Hall Effect joysticks and triggers, programmable back buttons and vibration feedback.

View at Joybuy
Xbox Wireless Controller in Pulse Red

Xbox Wireless Controller - Pulse Red

An option for rhythm games that support standard gamepad input on a listed Xbox platform or Windows PC.

The product description lists Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows PCs, with connection via Xbox Wireless or Bluetooth and a USB-C port.

View at Joybuy
Redragon M68 compact mechanical gaming keyboard with magnetic switches, 68 keys

Redragon M68 Magnetic Switch, 68 keys

A compact keyboard option for PC rhythm games that support keyboard input. Check the requirements for the specific game.

The product title lists magnetic switches, a 68-key layout, a metal top plate, an 8000 Hz polling rate and a US layout.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can you use one controller for every rhythm game?

No. Check which inputs are supported for each game and platform. PlayStation Store Netherlands lists PS VR2 and PS VR2 Sense controllers as requirements for Beat Saber on PS5; HORI describes Taiko drums in different platform versions.

What should you check when connecting and setting up a controller?

First, check the full model name and the connection options for your platform. 8BitDo lists different connections for Switch and Windows; for a Taiko drum on PC, the osu! wiki explains that you need to assign the correct keys in the game settings.

What can you do if a Taiko drum doesn’t respond properly to hits?

Check HORI’s troubleshooting instructions for your specific model before adjusting the drum. HORI has support information for hits that aren’t recognised correctly or notes that remain pressed.

What are your rights if a controller bought online disappoints or breaks?

ACM ConsuWijzer states that for an online consumer purchase, you have a 14-day cooling-off period from the day the product is delivered. Check which exceptions and returns conditions apply. This is separate from your statutory guarantee: if a product breaks sooner than you could reasonably expect under normal use, the seller must offer an appropriate solution, according to ACM ConsuWijzer.

Can you play with a drum or dance mat in a student room?

Take your living arrangements into account and discuss possible noise with your housemates or neighbours. The Dutch government recommends agreeing on a solution together first when dealing with noise nuisance.