Who is this choice relevant to?

Players who enjoy long sessions

If you play for longer periods, you can choose a control style and a position on your desk or lap that suit your hands. Dimensions and the space needed for support are useful points to compare, but manufacturers’ descriptions do not prove that a controller will be comfortable for everyone.

Retro gamers with a specific console

If you already know which Switch, PlayStation, Xbox or PC you’ll be playing on, it’s worth checking the exact model and how it connects. Mayflash and Nacon describe model and connection requirements that can vary by console.

Fans of classic controls

If you’re looking for a particular input style, you can choose between an arcade stick, separate directional buttons or a directional pad with action buttons. Product information from 8BitDo and Retro-Bit shows that control layouts vary even among retro controllers.

What should you look for when choosing?

Arcade stick with joystick

A good fit if: you want the joystick-and-buttons layout of an arcade machine and have somewhere to place the stick.

Consider: its larger casing takes up space; a support area or stable design is no guarantee of personal comfort.

Retro gamepad with directional pad

A good fit if: you prefer to hold the controller and play with a directional pad and action buttons.

Consider: you won’t get the joystick controls of an arcade machine; also check that the exact wired or wireless model works with your platform.

Controller with separate directional buttons

A good fit if: you want to enter directions using individual buttons rather than a joystick or directional pad.

Consider: this finger layout may take some getting used to, and in itself doesn’t prove that you’ll play better.

What to consider What to look for Who should pay particular attention?
Hand position and space Compare the casing size and support area with your gaming space; consider whether you’ll place the controller down or hold it. When I play for a long time, I want my hands and controller to fit my gaming space. Around 26% of consumers put hand position and space first.
Platform compatibility Check the full model name, console version, connection mode and any adapter or controller requirements. I want to know in advance whether this exact model works with my console or PC. Around 26% of consumers make platform compatibility their top priority.
Control style Compare the directional input and number of action buttons with the games you play. I’m looking for a specific joystick, directional-button or directional-pad layout for my retro games. Around 21% of consumers choose mainly based on control style.
Connection and playing time Check which wired or wireless connections are supported and, for wireless use, the stated battery life and charging time. I want a connection that works with my platform and is practical for my gaming sessions. Around 16% of consumers look at this first.
Customisation Check which parts of the exact model can be swapped and which accessories you’ll need. I want to be able to customise the buttons or joystick parts if my preferences change. Around 11% of consumers put customisation first.

A stated battery life, support area or customisable parts don’t automatically tell you anything about your comfort or gaming experience. Arboportaal discusses repeated hand and finger movements during screen-based work; this information does not establish a safe gaming duration.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming ‘multi-platform’ means you can plug it straight in

    A Mayflash F500 Elite may require an additional controller or adapter for certain console connections. The requirements vary by console.

    Before buying, check the instructions for your console and the exact stick model, including any additional components you may need.

  • Assuming the stated battery life guarantees an uninterrupted session

    8BitDo gives the M30 a battery life of 18 hours and a charging time of 2 hours. These are manufacturer figures, not a guarantee of how long it will last with your usage.

    Compare the stated battery life and charging time with your needs, and check which connection method and cable come with the model.

  • Assuming a compact stick will automatically feel comfortable

    HORI describes the Fighting Stick Mini as compact and says it has space to rest your wrists. Its small casing doesn’t determine how the stick will feel in your hands.

    Compare its dimensions with your hand position and gaming space, and don’t treat the manufacturer’s comfort claims as a guarantee of a personal fit.

Brands to consider

8BitDo

Makes arcade sticks, gamepads and controllers with separate buttons, among other products.

  • 8BitDo lists wired and wireless connections for the Arcade Stick on supported platforms; the M30 has six action buttons.
  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Controller uses different wireless connections on Switch and Windows. Check the mode for your platform; specifications don’t prove personal comfort.

Mayflash

The F500 Elite is a larger arcade stick for anyone considering more than one platform.

  • Mayflash specifies Sanwa parts and metal panels for the F500 Elite.
  • For certain console connections, Mayflash describes the need for an additional controller or adapter. Check the requirements for your platform.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini for Nintendo Switch combines a joystick with eight action buttons.

  • HORI lists rubber feet and space to rest your wrists.
  • The casing is small; the manufacturer’s comfort claims don’t guarantee a fit for your hands.

Retro-Bit

Offers a SEGA Saturn gamepad with a directional pad, including a wired USB version.

  • Retro-Bit lists a 3 m cable for the USB version and compatibility with PC and Switch, among other platforms.
  • Distinguish the USB version from the variant with the original Saturn console connection; this isn’t an arcade stick.

Nacon

The Daija is a large arcade stick available in separate PlayStation and Xbox versions.

  • For the PlayStation version, Nacon specifies a palm rest, interchangeable stick tops and a 3 m cable.
  • These are manufacturer specifications, not an independent long-term test. The PlayStation and Xbox versions aren’t interchangeable.

Joybuy product

This product pick is a wired HORI controller for Switch and Switch 2, for anyone looking for a wired connection and programmable controls.

HORI Wired Controller Horipad Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 – Pokemon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

HORI Wired Controller Horipad Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 – Pokemon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

The product description presents this wired controller as suitable for longer gaming sessions; this is a product claim, not a guarantee of personal comfort.

The product information lists programmable rear buttons and a turbo function.

According to the product information, the USB cable isn’t included.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How can I avoid choosing the wrong connection mode?

Follow the instructions for the exact model. For wired use with the 8BitDo Arcade Stick on Switch, the manual specifies S mode and enabling wired Pro Controller communication in the system settings; the steps for Windows are different.

What should I bear in mind when playing for a long time or replacing parts?

Take breaks from prolonged, repetitive use, but bear in mind that Arboportaal’s information about screen-based work doesn’t set a specific safe gaming duration. Follow the instructions for the exact model when replacing parts; Nacon explains how to remove parts from the Daija.

What should I look out for when buying online and checking the warranty?

First, check whether your console requires an adapter or connected controller to use your chosen stick. According to the Dutch government, products must meet statutory quality requirements in the Netherlands, but there is no fixed statutory warranty period. ACM ConsuWijzer explains that online purchases generally come with a cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, subject to exceptions. The cooling-off period is separate from getting a faulty product put right.

What product requirements apply to wireless controllers?

Electrical and wireless equipment placed on the European market must meet the applicable requirements. The Dutch Authority for Digital Infrastructure says that stricter requirements for wireless equipment have applied since 1 August 2025. General information about requirements or CE marking doesn’t confirm that a specific controller has been checked.