Who is this guide for?

Players with an analogue console

You want to record via composite or S-Video, so you’ll first need an input that matches your console’s video output. Elgato and StarTech.com list models with analogue connections.

Players who want to play on a screen at the same time

You want to use a separate screen while your computer records. With an analogue console, this may require a signal path via a suitable scaler and HDMI pass-through.

Collectors with consoles that have different video outputs

You use consoles with different connection types and want to know whether one device can handle their signals. Magewell lists multiple inputs for the USB Capture AIO.

What should you consider when choosing?

First, choose a signal path that matches your console’s output. Then decide how you want to play while recording, and only then check your computer, audio and any accessories you’ll need.

Direct analogue via USB

Choose this option if: your console outputs composite or S-Video and you want to record that analogue source directly.

Keep in mind: the capture card won’t automatically provide a separate picture on an HDMI screen for you to play on.

Analogue console via scaler to HDMI

Choose this option if: you want to connect your analogue console to an HDMI capture card and a separate screen via a suitable scaler.

Keep in mind: you’ll need a scaler, power supply and suitable cables as well as the capture card.

Multi-format capture

Choose this option if: you really do want to use several connection types, such as composite, S-Video, component and HDMI.

Keep in mind: check which breakout and conversion cables are included and whether you can play on your chosen screen.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Connection and signal Make a note of your console’s video and audio outputs, then check that the capture card supports the connection and PAL, PAL/60 or NTSC standard. If I want to connect my console, I first need to know whether its signal is compatible as is. Around 36% of consumers prioritise this connection.
Playing while recording Plan the signal path to your screen and computer. Check whether the HDMI capture card has a pass-through output and whether an analogue console needs a scaler. If I want to play on a separate screen while recording, I check the gameplay signal path separately from the computer preview. Around 29% of consumers prioritise the gameplay display.
Computer, software and audio Compare your computer with the model’s system requirements, connect the audio outputs and make a short test recording with picture and sound. If I want my recording computer ready for both picture and sound, I check the system requirements and audio source in advance. Around 21% of consumers start with the computer and recording setup.
Complete setup Make a list of the components you need for your console, screen and computer. Check what’s in the box and allow for any scaler, power supply and cables you’ll need. If I need extra converters or cables, I want to include them before choosing a signal path. Around 14% of consumers first consider the complete setup.

Pitfalls to avoid

  • Confusing 4K capture with support for an analogue console

    An HDMI input won’t accept a composite or S-Video signal directly. A higher stated resolution doesn’t change the type of input.

    First check your console’s video output, then choose a compatible analogue input or a suitable converter to HDMI.

    An analogue-to-HDMI setup may also need a scaler, power supply and suitable cables.

  • Assuming HDMI pass-through is the same as the recording preview

    Sending a signal to a separate screen and viewing it in your recording software are two different things. A pass-through specification alone tells you nothing about recording-preview latency.

    For HDMI capture, connect your screen to the pass-through output and assess the software preview separately.

  • Assuming the exact model and included cables

    StarTech.com lists the SVID2USB23 as a discontinued model; it is not the same model number as the SVID2USB232. Elgato says that an HDMI cable is not included with Game Capture Neo.

    Check the full model number and box contents before planning your connections.

    If an HDMI, console or breakout cable is missing, you may not be able to connect your setup straight away.

Relevant brands and models

Elgato

Elgato describes both an analogue Video Capture option and the HDMI-based Game Capture Neo.

  • According to Elgato, Video Capture supports PAL, PAL/60 and NTSC. Elgato lists a maximum recording resolution of 640 × 480 for its software.
  • Video Capture has no HDMI input. According to its model specifications, Game Capture Neo offers HDMI pass-through and capture at up to 1080p60; an analogue console will first need a suitable converter.

StarTech.com

According to StarTech.com, the SVID2USB232 is a USB recording option for Windows, designed for composite or S-Video.

  • StarTech.com lists support for PAL, NTSC and SECAM. For PAL, the company specifies a maximum of 720 × 576 at 25 frames per second.
  • Check that the model on offer is the SVID2USB232; StarTech.com lists the SVID2USB23 as discontinued.

Magewell

According to Magewell, the USB Capture AIO is designed for a range of analogue and digital input types.

  • Magewell lists composite, S-Video, component and HDMI, with some connections requiring breakout or conversion cables.
  • Check which connections are included and how you want to play on a screen. The listed inputs don’t confirm that every console will work without further checks.

AVerMedia

According to AVerMedia, the Live Gamer MINI GC311 is an HDMI capture option for a compatible HDMI source.

  • AVerMedia specifies HDMI pass-through and recording up to 1080p60, and lists a built-in H.264 encoder.
  • According to AVerMedia, the model has no analogue input and doesn’t support 4K, HDR or HDCP-protected signals.

Joybuy products for an HDMI setup

This product selection is for an HDMI setup with a screen connected via pass-through. An analogue retro console will first need a suitable converter to HDMI.

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card with USB 3.0 and 4K pass-through

VIELLAN HDMI video capture card, USB 3.0, 4K pass-through, recording up to 1080p

Designed for an HDMI source. If you have an analogue console, you’ll need a suitable converter to HDMI before you can connect this card.

The product name lists USB 3.0, 4K pass-through and video recording up to 1080p.

The product name also mentions driver-free installation, a microphone input and a headphone output. HDMI pass-through alone tells you nothing about recording-preview latency.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I connect my console’s phono plugs directly to an HDMI capture card?

Not if your console outputs composite video: an HDMI input isn’t an analogue input. Use a capture device with suitable analogue inputs, or check for a converter that’s compatible with your console’s signal and the HDMI capture card.

How can I check that picture and sound are being recorded together?

For an analogue setup, connect the audio outputs too, then select the video and audio sources in your recording software. Make a short test recording; OBS warns that selecting the same audio source twice can cause an echo.

What can I check if the capture card isn’t displaying a picture?

Check the source, cable, signal standard, device detection and software settings in turn. For the SVID2USB23, StarTech.com recommends testing the cable, source and capture device separately, among other steps. Apply these checks to the model you have, but don’t assume they prove general compatibility with consoles.

What are my rights when buying online in the Netherlands?

According to the Dutch government, when you buy online from a business you’ll often have a 14-day cooling-off period. The same guidance doesn’t apply in the same way to purchases from a private individual. If a product is faulty, the seller is your point of contact for your statutory guarantee. The Netherlands doesn’t have a fixed statutory two-year guarantee period for all products.

Can I publish recorded gameplay without any restrictions?

Don’t assume that rules allowing private use automatically give you permission to make gameplay public. The Dutch government distinguishes between a private copy for personal use and sharing or making content public. Before publishing, check the game footage, music and any relevant permissions or terms of use.