Start with your console’s video output: composite or S-video is suited to an analogue USB video grabber, while an HDMI capture card needs a compatible HDMI signal. To record an analogue console via HDMI and play on a modern screen, you’ll also need a suitable scaler or converter. Check the entire signal chain and your computer’s compatibility before choosing.
Which setup is right for you?
Playing on an analogue console
If your console outputs composite or S-video with audio, you can connect a grabber with those inputs directly to your computer. Also decide how you’ll play on a screen while recording. AVerMedia and Hauppauge describe models with analogue video inputs and stereo audio.
Playing through via HDMI
For a console with HDMI, check that the input is supported and whether there’s an HDMI output for your screen. Elgato lists HDMI input and HDMI passthrough for the Game Capture Neo; an analogue console first needs a suitable converter.
Recording on a dedicated PC
Check that the exact model works with your computer’s operating system, USB connection and recording software. AVerMedia states that macOS isn’t supported for the DVD EZMaker 7 C039; Elgato specifies USB 3.0 for the Game Capture Neo.
What should you look for?
Recording directly from an analogue source
Choose this if: your console outputs composite or S-video and you want to record on your computer.
Bear in mind: you’ll need to plan separately how to get the picture onto your screen while you play.
Recording via HDMI
Choose this if: your console outputs an unencrypted HDMI signal supported by the capture card.
Bear in mind: an analogue console first needs a suitable scaler or converter.
Using an analogue console with a scaler
Choose this if: you want to connect an analogue console via HDMI to a modern screen and an HDMI capture card.
Bear in mind: check that the scaler’s output is compatible with the card’s input and recording settings.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Console connection |
Note your console’s video and audio outputs, then compare them with the inputs on the exact model. AVerMedia lists composite, S-video and stereo audio for the DVD EZMaker 7 C039. |
I want to connect my console directly without adding an unnecessary conversion step. Around 36% of consumers say the console connection is their top priority. |
| Playing while recording |
Check whether your chosen setup has a suitable output for your gaming screen. Elgato specifies HDMI passthrough for the Game Capture Neo; this is separate from the maximum recording quality. |
I want to keep playing on a separate screen while recording and know what connection I’ll need. Around 29% of consumers say playing while recording is their top priority. |
| Video signal support |
Compare your console’s standard and resolution with those supported by the grabber, or by both the scaler and capture card. Elgato lists PAL and PAL/60 for Video Capture; those specifications don’t automatically apply to the Game Capture Neo. |
I want the equipment I choose to work with the signal from my specific console. Around 21% of consumers say source signal support is their top priority. |
| Computer and software |
Check your operating system, the required USB connection and your recording software’s settings. OBS recommends checking the available resolution, frame rate and audio settings for the video source. |
I want to know in advance whether the capture card will work with my recording PC and software. Around 14% of consumers say computer and software compatibility is their top priority. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Confusing 4K passthrough with 4K recording
For the Elgato Game Capture Neo, Elgato lists passthrough up to 4K60 and recording up to 1080p60. So the picture passed through to your screen doesn’t tell you what the card itself records.
Check the specifications for the exact model, comparing supported input, screen passthrough and recording formats separately.
-
Connecting an HDMI capture card directly to an analogue console
A card with HDMI input only won’t accept composite or S-video directly. To use an analogue console via HDMI, you’ll need a suitable scaler or converter; compatibility across the entire setup still matters.
First check your console’s output, then find out what signal the scaler sends to the capture card.
-
Assuming general software information applies to every model
Support varies by device. AVerMedia states that macOS isn’t supported for the DVD EZMaker 7 C039. Since 17 July 2025, AVerMedia has also stopped issuing new serial numbers for PowerDirector 15 with this product.
Before buying, check current support for your operating system and confirm which software you actually want to use.
-
Assuming every HDMI signal can be recorded
Elgato says its capture devices can’t record HDMI signals with active HDCP protection. So having an HDMI connection alone doesn’t mean the signal is suitable.
Check which output your console uses and whether the capture card can record the signal it sends.
Relevant brands
AVerMedia
The DVD EZMaker 7 C039 is an analogue option for older sources with composite or S-video.
- AVerMedia specifies stereo audio and a maximum PAL/SECAM capture resolution of 720 × 576 for this model.
- The manufacturer lists OBS Studio as supported software.
- AVerMedia states that the C039 doesn’t support macOS; check the operating system requirements for your computer.
Elgato
Video Capture is an analogue range; Game Capture Neo is a separate model designed for HDMI.
- Elgato lists PAL and PAL/60 for Video Capture. For Game Capture Neo, the brand specifies HDMI input, HDMI passthrough and USB 3.0.
- The features of these two models aren’t interchangeable. Elgato states that signals with active HDCP protection can’t be recorded.
Hauppauge
USB-Live2 is an analogue USB option; HD PVR 2 model 1512 has different connections and specifications.
- Hauppauge specifies composite, S-video, stereo audio and PAL sources up to 720 × 576 for USB-Live2.
- For HD PVR 2 model 1512, Hauppauge lists composite, component and HDMI without HDCP as inputs.
- The connections on HD PVR 2 model 1512 aren’t available on USB-Live2; check the model number and computer system when comparing them.
Joybuy products for HDMI capture
This Joybuy product selection is suited to recording from an HDMI source and playing on a screen while you record.
No image available
VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card with USB 3.0
The HDMI connection suits an HDMI setup. If your console only has composite or S-video, you’ll first need a suitable converter or scaler.
The product title lists USB 3.0, 4K passthrough and video recording up to 1080p. 4K is specified for passthrough, not recording.
The product title also mentions a microphone input and headphone output. Check that the connections and recording settings suit your computer and screen.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can I connect a console with a yellow composite plug directly to an HDMI capture card?
No, not to a model that only has HDMI video input. Choose a grabber with a composite input, or use a suitable scaler or converter first. Then check that the capture card supports the resulting signal. AVerMedia specifies a composite input for the DVD EZMaker 7 C039.
How do I check that video and audio are coming through in OBS?
Add a video source for the capture device in OBS, then check the available resolution, frame rate and audio settings. According to the OBS Project, the picture may not appear if the device doesn’t support the selected resolution.
Am I always entitled to a two-year statutory warranty on a capture card in the Netherlands?
No. The Dutch government states that there’s no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands. You’re entitled to a product that works as it should; what you can reasonably expect depends, among other things, on the product information and whether the product is new or second-hand. If a product is faulty, contact the seller.
Do I have a cooling-off period if I buy a capture card online?
For distance purchases from a business, the Dutch government says that in many cases you have a 14-day cooling-off period. This doesn’t automatically apply to every transaction: for example, according to the government website, buying online from a private individual doesn’t count as a distance purchase.
Can I publish recorded gameplay online without asking?
Don’t assume that recording for personal use and making content public are the same thing. The Dutch government says that a private copy for personal use can’t simply be distributed or made public, and permission may be needed for copyright-protected material. Whether you can publish a particular gameplay video depends on the rights involved, permission and the circumstances.