Who is this choice relevant to?

Players with an analogue console

You want to record composite or S-video and need a capture input that matches the connection. Elgato and StarTech.com describe analogue USB capture options for these signals.

Players who want a separate screen

You want to record on your computer while playing on a separate HDMI screen. AVerMedia describes HDMI pass-through on the GC311; if you have an analogue console, you’ll also need a suitable signal converter.

Players short on desk space

You want to keep the number of devices and cables to a minimum. So look beyond the capture card itself and consider any converters, screens, power supplies and computer requirements too.

What should you consider when choosing?

Record directly from an analogue console

Choose this setup: if your console outputs composite or S-video and you want to use that connection directly.

Bear in mind: this isn’t an HDMI setup. Elgato lists a recording resolution of 640 × 480 for Video Capture; StarTech.com describes SD capture and software for Windows 7–10.

HDMI capture with pass-through

Choose this setup: if your source outputs HDMI and you want to send the picture to a separate HDMI screen while recording.

Bear in mind: you can’t connect an analogue console directly. AVerMedia specifies up to 1080p60 for recording and pass-through on the GC311; a converter means extra equipment and cables.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Console connection Compare your console’s video and audio outputs with the capture card’s inputs. Also check which signal formats it supports, such as PAL, PAL/60 or NTSC. If my console only has composite or S-video, I want a compatible input without an unnecessary converter. Around 36% of consumers prioritise connectivity.
Playing on a separate screen Check whether the exact model has HDMI pass-through and whether your source and screen work within the specified resolution. Treat any claim about lag as a manufacturer’s claim, not an independent measurement. I want to keep playing on a separate screen while recording, rather than just watching the picture on my computer. Around 29% of consumers prioritise this way of playing.
Space and computer Count all the devices, cables and connections you’ll need. Check the computer and software requirements for the specific model. On a small desk, I want the whole setup to fit and work with my computer. Around 21% of consumers prioritise this practical fit.
Aspect ratio and sound Check the supported aspect ratio, signal format and audio input. Make a short test recording and check the picture and sound. I want the game picture to look undistorted and the recording to include sound. Around 14% of consumers prioritise the quality of the recording.

Common buying mistakes

  • Mistaking an HDMI capture card for an analogue input

    According to the manufacturer, the AVerMedia GC311 has HDMI video input. You can’t connect a composite or S-video signal to it directly.

    Before you buy, map out the entire route from your console to the capture card, computer and, if needed, gaming screen. Choose an analogue capture input or check which converter suits your signal.

  • Assuming every retro gaming signal is supported

    RetroTINK warns of possible issues with certain composite signals from the Sega Genesis and PS1 when using the 2X Pro. This warning applies to specific models and doesn’t automatically apply to all converters.

    Check the documentation for your console, output, cable and signal format before connecting your devices.

  • Focusing only on the size of the capture card

    A compact capture card doesn’t guarantee that the whole setup will take up little space. Connecting an analogue console to HDMI equipment may also require a converter and extra cables.

    Consider the space and connections needed for the entire setup, including your computer and screen.

Brands to compare

Elgato

According to Elgato, Video Capture is a USB option for analogue sources with composite or S-video output.

  • Elgato lists support for PAL, PAL/60 and NTSC, among other formats, as well as 4:3 and 16:9 settings.
  • According to Elgato, Video Capture has no HDMI input. Elgato lists a recording resolution of 640 × 480 when using its own software.

AVerMedia

According to AVerMedia’s product specifications, the Live Gamer MINI GC311 is an HDMI capture card with HDMI pass-through.

  • AVerMedia specifies up to 1080p60 for both recording and pass-through, and lists dimensions of 100 × 57 × 18,8 mm.
  • The manufacturer’s claim of lag-free pass-through hasn’t been independently measured. The GC311 has no listed analogue video input and, according to AVerMedia, doesn’t support HDCP-protected signals.

StarTech.com

According to StarTech.com, the SVID2USB232 is a USB adapter for composite or S-video and two-channel RCA audio.

  • StarTech.com specifies SD capture for PAL/SECAM and NTSC, with USB power.
  • The manufacturer describes the included software as being for Windows 7–10. Check compatibility with your own computer and operating system.

Products at Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I connect a composite cable directly to an HDMI capture card?

No, not if the capture card only has HDMI video input. According to the manufacturer, the AVerMedia GC311 has an HDMI input; for an analogue console, you’ll need a suitable converter or a capture card with the right analogue input.

How can I stop the retro gaming picture from looking stretched?

Check that the aspect ratio setting matches your source. Elgato lists 4:3 and 16:9 settings and warns that choosing the wrong one can stretch the picture. Check the result with a short recording.

What can I do if my capture card doesn’t work properly after I buy it?

Contact the seller and describe your console, connections and the problem. According to the Dutch Government, statutory guarantees in the Netherlands don’t have a fixed duration, as products vary; what you can expect also depends on the product.

Can I publish or stream retro game recordings without permission?

Don’t assume that owning the game or capture card automatically gives you permission to make recordings public. The Dutch Government distinguishes between making a copy for personal use and distributing or making it public. If other people can be recognised in the footage, the exception for personal or household use may also be relevant; the Dutch Data Protection Authority points out that this exception doesn’t apply to sharing with a wider circle.