Start with the system you play on and the buttons your games need. Then choose between a gamepad you can put away and a joystick that needs space on your desk. In a shared room, the clicking noise matters too. Before you decide, check the connection, any extra accessories you may need and the correct CE marking for the exact version.
Who is this guide for?
Player with multiple systems
Wants to know first whether the exact version works with their PC or console. Controllers with similar names can differ in their receiver and supported systems; 8BitDo, for example, describes different versions of the M30.
Player with limited desk space
Is looking for a controller that fits while they play and can be put away afterwards. A compact stick and a gamepad take up space in different ways; HORI gives the Fighting Stick Mini for Nintendo Switch dimensions of around 8 × 6 inches.
Player in a shared room
Weighs up the arcade-style controls they want against the sound of the switches and the number of buttons needed. Speedlink describes the microswitches on the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB as making a loud clicking sound.
What should you look for when choosing?
First choose the type of controls that suits your games, then check system compatibility, available space and how noisy it will be in the room.
Compact retro gamepad
Choose this if: you have little permanent desk space and can play with a directional pad and the buttons you need. Retro-Bit describes its wired SEGA Saturn 8-Button Arcade Pad with USB as suitable for systems including PC and Switch.
Trade-off: you won't get the physical joystick controls of an arcade stick. Also check your games' button layouts and input modes.
Small arcade stick
Choose this if: you want a joystick with eight action buttons that you can put away after playing. HORI gives the Fighting Stick Mini for Nintendo Switch a footprint of around 8 × 6 inches and lists PC compatibility.
Trade-off: you'll also need space for your hands, the joystick and the cable. The PlayStation version is a different product with its own system compatibility.
Larger or customisable arcade stick
Choose this if: you have enough desk space and are looking for extra connection or configuration options. 8BitDo lists the Switch and Windows as compatible with its Arcade Stick; Mayflash lists systems including Windows and Switch for the F300.
Trade-off: according to the manufacturer, the 8BitDo Arcade Stick measures 303 × 203 × 111,5 mm. Mayflash requires a wired controller to be connected when using the F300 with PS4, Xbox One and Xbox 360.
Classic USB joystick
Choose this if: your game works with the available buttons and you want a joystick for retro games on a Windows PC. Speedlink lists four fire buttons for the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB.
Trade-off: Speedlink describes the microswitches as making a loud clicking sound. Bear this in mind if you share the room.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| System compatibility |
Check the full model name, receiver, connection and explicit support for your system. |
If you want to be sure the controller works with your PC or console, check the exact version. Around 31% of consumers put compatibility with their own system first. |
| Desk space |
Measure the available space and compare it with the dimensions of the version you’re considering. Leave room for your hands and the cable too. |
If your desk is already full, you’ll want to be able to put the controller away after playing. Around 25% of consumers prioritise the space available. |
| Controls and buttons |
Check your games’ button mappings and compare them with the controller’s layout. |
If you want smooth control in your retro games, check which buttons each game needs. Around 19% of consumers choose the controls as their main consideration. |
| Noise |
Read what the manufacturer says about the switches and consider the room you share. |
If someone else in the room is studying or sleeping, you’ll want to know how much clicking noise the controls make. Around 13% of consumers put consideration for their housemates first. |
| Extra equipment |
Read the connection instructions for your system and work out which accessories you already have. |
If you don’t want to buy extra equipment, check what you’ll need for your controller and system combination. Around 12% of consumers prioritise the equipment required. |
Buying pitfalls
-
Assuming wireless controllers with similar names use the same receiver
The 8BitDo M30 Bluetooth and M30 2.4G versions can differ in their receiver and system compatibility.
Before choosing, compare the full version name, the receiver included and the systems it supports.
-
Comparing only the dimensions of the casing
When you play, a joystick and cable also need space for your hands and the movement of the stick.
Measure the available space and allow extra room for your hands, the cable and the controls.
-
Assuming a clicky joystick will automatically suit a shared room
Speedlink says the microswitches on the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB make a loud clicking sound.
Weigh up the noise against the joystick controls you want, and don’t assume other models will be quiet.
-
Assuming console compatibility means no extra accessories are needed
Mayflash requires a wired controller to be connected when using the F300 with PS4, Xbox One and Xbox 360.
Check the instructions for your console and see what equipment you already have.
Relevant brands to consider
HORI
Makes compact Fighting Stick Mini versions for various systems, among other products.
- HORI gives the Fighting Stick Mini for Nintendo Switch a footprint of around 8 × 6 inches and lists PC compatibility.
- The PlayStation version is a different product. Check the system compatibility of the exact version.
8BitDo
Offers a larger Arcade Stick and M30 retro gamepads with different connection options.
- 8BitDo says the Arcade Stick supports Bluetooth, 2.4G and wired USB-C.
- Receivers and system compatibility can vary between M30 versions, so check the full version name.
Mayflash
The F300 is an arcade stick for anyone looking to customise the controls and find PC or console support.
- Mayflash lists XInput and DInput for PC, and support for replaceable parts.
- Mayflash requires a wired controller to be connected when using the F300 with PS4, Xbox One and Xbox 360. This does not confirm that it works with every other console.
Retro-Bit
Offers a wired SEGA Saturn 8-Button Arcade Pad with USB as a gamepad alternative to a joystick.
- Retro-Bit lists systems including PC and Switch for the USB version. The European manual explains how to switch between DInput and XInput.
- The USB version is different from the pad with a connector for an original Saturn.
Speedlink
The COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB is a classic joystick option for Windows retro games, among other uses.
- Speedlink lists four fire buttons and DirectInput.
- Speedlink describes the microswitches as making a loud clicking sound. Check that the buttons and input support suit your games.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Why does a controller sometimes work in Windows but not straight away in your game?
Check whether the game uses the controller’s input mode, and set up the buttons if needed. Mayflash lists XInput and DInput for the F300 on PC; the European manual for the wired Retro-Bit Saturn gamepad explains how to switch between these modes.
Do you need another controller to use a Mayflash F300 with a PS4, Xbox One or Xbox 360?
Mayflash requires a wired controller to be connected when using the F300 with these consoles. Check the instructions for your exact setup and see what equipment you already have.
Do all 8BitDo M30 versions use the same receiver and support the same systems?
No. 8BitDo describes differences between the Bluetooth and 2.4G versions, as well as between the 2.4G receivers. Check the full version name and the systems the specific version is designed for.
Should you check for a CE marking on a game controller sold in the Netherlands?
Yes. The Dutch Authority for Digital Infrastructure says that electrical and electronic equipment must have the correct CE marking. Check this for the exact version; compatibility information alone tells you nothing about its marking.
What are your rights if a controller you bought online isn’t suitable or breaks?
For an online consumer purchase, ACM ConsuWijzer says you generally have up to 14 days after delivery to change your mind, although exceptions may apply. This is separate from your statutory guarantee: if a product breaks during normal use sooner than you could reasonably expect, the seller must put it right free of charge, for example by repairing or replacing it, or giving you your money back, according to ACM ConsuWijzer.