Who is this buying guide for?

Players with a specific system

You’re looking for a controller that works with your console or PC and your game. Models for Switch, Xbox and PlayStation aren’t automatically interchangeable, so check the platform list for the exact version.

Players in a dark room

You want to be able to find the controls, but a lighting effect doesn’t necessarily mean the button labels are illuminated. 8BitDo describes one Xbox model as having an RGB light ring.

Fans of classic controls

You can choose between a joystick with arcade buttons, a six-button pad or separate buttons. Retro-Bit describes BIG6 versions with different connections.

What should you look for?

Arcade stick with joystick

Choose this if: you’re looking for a physical joystick and arcade buttons. 8BitDo lists Switch and Windows compatibility for the Arcade Stick; HORI lists PS5, PS4 and Windows 11/10 for version SPF-038U.

Trade-off: a stick takes up more space than a compact pad; the models mentioned don’t confirm that the arcade buttons are illuminated.

Controller with separate buttons

Choose this if: you play on Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One or Windows and would prefer not to use a physical joystick. 8BitDo describes the Arcade Controller for Xbox as having an RGB light ring.

Trade-off: the light ring doesn’t confirm that the button labels light up, so check exactly what is illuminated.

Compact six-button arcade pad

Choose this if: you prefer a six-button layout and D-pad to a large joystick. Retro-Bit describes BIG6 versions with connections including USB and the original Mega Drive connector.

Trade-off: connections vary by version; a status LED doesn’t mean the arcade buttons are illuminated.

Consideration What to look for Who is this for?
Compatibility Check the full model name, supported systems and connection or input mode. I want to know whether the controller works with my console or PC and game; around 29% of consumers prioritise compatibility.
Visibility in the dark Check which part lights up and whether the brightness is adjustable; don’t rely on ‘RGB’ alone. When I play in a dark room, I want to be able to find the controls without relying on a lighting effect; around 24% of consumers prioritise visibility.
Control layout Compare the joystick, D-pad and separate buttons with the controls used in your games. I choose based on how I want to move and press buttons; around 23% of consumers focus mainly on the control layout.
Space and connection Measure the available space and decide whether you want to play wired or wirelessly. With limited room to play, I want a controller that fits my space and has a practical cable route; around 12% of consumers prioritise this consideration.
Parts and settings Check what’s included in the box and whether your specific setup needs an adapter; also check which settings affect how it works. I want to know in advance what I need to use my setup; around 12% of consumers prioritise parts and settings.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming RGB means illuminated button labels

    For the 8BitDo Arcade Controller for Xbox, the manufacturer describes an RGB light ring. That doesn’t, on its own, mean the buttons light up clearly.

    Check the product information for the exact version to see which part lights up and whether the setting suits your preferences.

  • Choosing a version for the wrong system

    Arcade controllers can vary by version in their platform support, connection and input mode. A similar brand or model name doesn’t guarantee that the controller will work with your system.

    Before buying, compare the full version details with the official platform list and the connections available on your setup.

    If you choose the wrong version, you may need a different controller. Only use an adapter if it’s supported for your particular combination.

Brands to compare

8BitDo

8BitDo describes different controller ranges for different systems: a joystick model for Switch and Windows, and a separate Xbox controller with buttons only.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick offers Bluetooth, 2.4GHz and USB-C connectivity, as well as a customisable visual button layout.
  • The RGB light ring on the Arcade Controller for Xbox doesn’t confirm that the button labels are illuminated; check platform support for the exact version.

Retro-Bit

The BIG6 range is designed for those who prefer a compact six-button arcade pad with a D-pad.

  • Retro-Bit describes versions for connections including the original Mega Drive, USB and wireless use.
  • Connections and settings vary by version; a status LED doesn’t mean the arcade buttons are illuminated.

HORI

According to HORI, the Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U has a compact joystick and an eight-button layout for PS5, PS4 and Windows 11/10.

  • HORI describes this version as compact and wired.
  • The product description doesn’t confirm that the arcade buttons are illuminated; also check that you’re looking at version SPF-038U.

MAYFLASH

The F500 V2 is a larger, wired arcade stick for those who want to compare supported platforms and input modes.

  • MAYFLASH lists XInput and DInput for use on PC.
  • Check the mode and firmware required for your system, and don’t assume it offers universal compatibility or includes an adapter.

SNK

According to SNK, the NEOGEO Arcade Stick Pro is for those looking for a joystick and built-in NEOGEO fighting games.

  • SNK lists twenty pre-installed NEOGEO fighting games and the option to use it as a controller with a NEOGEO mini or PC.
  • The built-in game selection is specific, so check that the games and connection options suit how you want to use it.

Game controllers at Joybuy

These Joybuy products are gamepads for the systems listed for each version. Check that their button layouts suit the retro games you play.

NAXSIR wireless Bluetooth gamepad with phone holder

NAXSIR Wireless Bluetooth Gamepad with Phone Holder

An option if you’re looking for a wireless gamepad for one of the listed systems.

The product name mentions Bluetooth 5.2, 2.4G wireless, dual vibration and a phone holder, with compatibility for Android, iOS, PC, Smart TV, PS3 and Switch.

Joybuy
NAXSIR wireless PS5 controller with Hall Effect joysticks

NAXSIR Wireless PS5 Controller

An option if you’re looking for a wireless controller for PS5 with programmable buttons.

The product name mentions Hall Effect joysticks, RGB lighting, programmable buttons and a 1000mAh battery.

Joybuy
Game controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

Gaming Controller with Dual Vibration & Gyro for Switch & PC

An option if you’re looking for a controller for Switch or PC and want to use the motion sensor mentioned.

The product information lists Bluetooth 4.0, turbo, dual vibration, a 6-axis gyroscope and an included USB-C charging cable.

Joybuy
BEITONG PanGu modular wireless gaming controller

BEITONG PanGu Modular Wireless Gaming Controller

An option if you want to customise the controls for one of the listed systems.

The product name mentions interchangeable joysticks, buttons and D-pads. The product description lists wired, wireless and Bluetooth connectivity, and mentions PC, Nintendo Switch, Switch 2, Steam and Android.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Are RGB lights the same as illuminated arcade buttons?

No, unless the product information confirms this separately. 8BitDo describes the Arcade Controller for Xbox as having an RGB light ring; check the exact version before expecting illuminated button labels.

How do I connect the 8BitDo Arcade Stick to a Switch via Bluetooth?

According to 8BitDo’s instructions, set the connection switch to BT and the mode switch to S, start pairing, then select ‘Controllers’ on the Switch followed by ‘Change Grip/Order’. These steps apply to the Arcade Stick and don’t automatically apply to other 8BitDo models.

What should I check if a wireless controller doesn’t work straight away?

Check the mode and receiver for the exact version. The manual for the Retro-Bit BIG6 2.4GHz version describes different input modes and LED colours; those instructions don’t automatically apply to the wired BIG6.