Who is this relevant to?

Moving with irreplaceable notes

You want to copy your archive before packing and be able to restore it after the move. The NCSC and Safe Online recommend keeping a separate backup: a NAS or RAID setup alone is not a backup.

Researcher using multiple work devices

You want to manage your notes centrally from different devices after the move, so you’re comparing the NAS enclosure, drives and network connection as a complete setup.

Manager of confidential notes

You may be processing personal data, so you need to tailor your security accordingly. The Dutch Data Protection Authority points out that organisations must protect personal data appropriately.

What should you look for when choosing?

Complete NAS with two drive bays

Choose this option: if you don’t already have a NAS and want to manage your notes centrally after the move.

Bear in mind: you’ll need drives and a separate destination for your backup; RAID is no substitute for that copy.

Standalone NAS hard drive

Choose this option: if you already have a suitable NAS and mainly want to add storage or replace a drive.

Bear in mind: the drive won’t provide network access on its own; check that it’s compatible with your exact NAS model.

Concern What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Ability to restore data during the move Keep a recent copy in a separate location and try restoring a few files before you pack. The NCSC and Safe Online recommend a separate backup. I want to be able to restore my notes if the NAS is damaged during the move or becomes inaccessible. Around 36% of consumers put the ability to restore data during a move first.
Suitable storage and drives Work out how much usable space you need and check that the exact drive and NAS models are compatible. Synology notes that usable capacity depends in part on the drives and RAID configuration. If archive space or a suitable replacement drive is my main concern, I want to know how much storage the configuration actually provides. Around 29% of consumers give storage and compatibility top priority.
Access from multiple devices Check which network port the NAS has and whether it works with your own network. Synology lists 2,5GbE for the DS225+; QNAP specifies one gigabit port for the TS-233. A port specification doesn’t guarantee a particular speed in your setup. I want to be able to open my notes from more than one work device after the move. Around 21% of consumers put centralised access first.
Security for sensitive notes Decide who needs access and tailor permissions and protection to the data and risks. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that organisations processing personal data are required to protect it appropriately. If my archive contains confidential information, I want to restrict access and protect the copies while they’re being transported. Around 14% of consumers give confidentiality top priority.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming two drives mean two independent copies of your archive

    RAID can help keep data available if a drive fails, but it isn’t a substitute for a backup. The NCSC recommends keeping a separate copy.

    Before the move, make a recent copy outside the NAS and try restoring important files from it.

    A separate backup destination requires extra storage space and time to check that you can restore your files.

  • Assuming the drives’ raw capacity is the space available for your archive

    Usable capacity can vary depending on the drives and RAID configuration you choose, as Synology points out.

    First work out how large your archive is, then compare how much usable space the configuration you’re considering provides.

  • Choosing a drive based on the brand name alone

    Drive technology and compatibility policies vary by model. Synology notes that support may be more limited for issues with drives that aren’t on its compatibility list.

    Check the full drive model, your NAS model and the latest compatibility information. For Synology, don’t assume older information applies to models running DSM 7.3.

    You may need to replace an unsuitable drive, so check in advance what support is available for that combination.

Brands to compare

Synology

Worth considering for a NAS enclosure with central storage and backup features, or a standalone drive for an existing NAS.

  • Synology lists a 2,5GbE port and device backup features for the DS225+.
  • Synology’s performance figures are based on internal tests and don’t guarantee a particular speed. Check the latest drive compatibility information for your model and DSM version.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay NAS for anyone looking for central storage who can work with this model’s connections and hardware.

  • QNAP specifies two drive bays and 2 GB of memory for the TS-233.
  • The memory isn’t upgradeable and the model has one gigabit Ethernet port. These specifications alone don’t tell you how it will perform in your studio setup.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 AS1102T is a two-bay enclosure for 3.5-inch SATA hard drives.

  • ASUSTOR specifies one 2,5GbE port and RAID 1 for this model.
  • The 1 GB of memory isn’t upgradeable. The stated maximum raw capacity doesn’t mean you’re guaranteed the same amount of usable storage.

Western Digital

WD Red ranges are worth considering if you’re looking for a standalone hard drive for an existing or new NAS.

  • Western Digital distinguishes between Red drives with SMR and Red Plus and Red Pro drives with CMR. WD recommends its CMR ranges for ZFS.
  • Check that the exact drive model is suitable for your NAS and intended use.

Seagate

The IronWolf ranges are another option to consider when choosing standalone NAS drives.

  • Seagate positions its NAS drives for long-term NAS use.
  • Seagate recommends checking the NAS supplier’s latest compatibility list. This isn’t an independent comparison with other drives.

Joybuy products

These Joybuy products include standalone Synology drives for a compatible existing NAS, and Synology NAS enclosures for central storage and file sharing.

Synology SATA HDD 6 TB

Synology SATA HDD 6 TB

An option if you already have a suitable NAS and need more storage. This is a standalone hard drive, not a NAS enclosure.

Capacity: 6 TB. Connection: SATA.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

A NAS option for setting up central storage and file sharing.

Hard drives aren’t included and must be chosen separately.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

A NAS option for central storage and file sharing with a suitable setup.

This is a diskless version; hard drives must be bought separately.

Joybuy
Synology SATA HDD 16 TB, 7.200 rpm

Synology SATA HDD 16 TB, 7.200 rpm

An option if you already have a suitable NAS and need more storage. This is a standalone hard drive, not a NAS enclosure.

Capacity: 16 TB. Connection: SATA. Rotational speed: 7.200 rpm.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

A NAS option for central file sharing and backup management.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to back up your files for the move?

No. RAID can help keep a NAS available if one drive fails, but the NCSC stresses that RAID is no substitute for a backup. So keep a recent copy in a separate location too.

Do you need to buy hard drives separately for a NAS enclosure?

Check what’s included with the specific version before ordering. A listing of drive bays or supported drive types doesn’t tell you on its own whether drives are included. Also check that the drives you choose are compatible.

How do you set up a NAS securely for shared research notes?

Give users only the permissions they need and change the default passwords. The NCSC also advises against making a NAS directly accessible over the internet. This is security advice, not a guarantee that a particular model is secure by default.

What should you do if your notes contain personal data?

If you process personal data as an organisation, the GDPR requires you to protect it appropriately. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says you should tailor your measures to the risks involved in processing the data. This doesn’t mean there’s one mandatory NAS feature for every buyer.

Can you trade in an old NAS when buying a new one?

For individuals, the Dutch government describes a free take-back scheme when buying a similar electrical appliance, including online purchases. According to the Dutch government, the scheme doesn’t apply to businesses. Before handing over your old NAS, make sure no one can access data left on its drives.