Who is this choice relevant to?

A racer sharing a bedroom

You play while someone else is resting or working in the same bedroom, so adjustable vibration and sound are important factors in your choice.

A console racer who wants a guaranteed fit

You want to make sure the controller works with your generation of Xbox, PlayStation or Switch and your racing game before weighing up any extra features.

A racer with limited setup space

You’re choosing between a handheld controller you can put away and a wheel with pedals that needs a suitable place to play.

What should you look for when buying?

First check that your console or PC and racing game are compatible. Then weigh up sound settings, your preferred controls and the space you have available.

What to consider What should you check? Who should give this more weight?
Sound and vibration Check the audio output, controller speaker and vibration settings on your platform. If someone is resting next to me, I want to be able to adjust vibration and sound to suit. Around 34% of consumers who share this priority put peace and quiet first.
Platform and racing game Make a note of the exact console or PC version, the full controller model and the support offered by your racing game. I want to be sure my controller will work with my system and game before I buy. Around 33% of consumers put compatibility first.
Racing controls Check whether the game supports the triggers, haptics or wheel model you want. If how I steer is my main concern, I’ll compare a gamepad with a wheel and pedals. Around 20% of consumers who share this priority want to improve their controls first.
Space and accessories Measure the space available and check what’s included in the box, as well as cables, mounting options and any extra accessories you may need. I want to know whether I can put the controller away after playing and whether a wheel setup will fit in my room. Around 13% of consumers prioritise space and additional purchases.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing the Switch Pro Controller with the Switch 2 Pro Controller

    Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller is compatible only with Nintendo Switch 2; the original Switch Pro model is a separate controller.

    Before ordering, check the full model name and your console version.

  • Assuming a headset will eliminate all sound in the room

    A headset and controller vibration are two different things. A vibration setting also tells you nothing about mechanical noise from buttons, the wheel or pedals.

    Check the audio connection and adjust the controller speaker or vibration if needed. Assess the noise from the physical controls separately.

  • Choosing a racing wheel based on force feedback alone

    The Logitech G923 combines wheel and pedal controls. Logitech’s description of its force feedback doesn’t tell you how much space the setup takes up or how loud it will be in your bedroom.

    Check that you have room for the wheel and pedals, and that the model and racing game are compatible with your platform.

    You may need a suitable space and mounting setup, so check the arrangement and the exact contents of the package too.

Brands to compare

Microsoft Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is a compact gamepad for Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • Xbox Support explains how to turn off vibration on Xbox.
  • According to Xbox Support, most features in the Accessories app aren’t available on Windows over Bluetooth, so don’t assume every connection offers the same settings.

Sony PlayStation

The DualSense is a gamepad for PS5, with adjustable speaker volume, vibration and trigger effects.

  • PlayStation describes haptic feedback and adaptive triggers as controller features.
  • These features depend on game support. For haptic feedback on PC, PlayStation specifies both game support and a USB connection.

Nintendo

Nintendo offers separate Pro Controllers for the original Switch and Switch 2.

  • Nintendo lists a 3.5mm CTIA headset jack on the Switch 2 Pro Controller.
  • Nintendo says this controller is for Switch 2 only. On Switch 2, turning off vibration applies to all synchronised controllers.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wired is a wired gamepad for supported Windows PCs and Android devices.

  • 8BitDo lists Hall effect sticks and triggers, USB and extra bumpers.
  • The stated polling rate is a manufacturer figure under ideal conditions; the product information doesn’t mention support for PS5, Xbox or Switch.

Logitech G

The G923 is a wheel-and-pedal setup for anyone deliberately looking for an alternative to a handheld controller.

  • Logitech lists TRUEFORCE force feedback and a pressure-sensitive braking system.
  • This product description doesn’t provide a comparable noise measurement for a shared bedroom. Check the platform version too.

Joybuy products

This selection of Joybuy products includes gamepads for Switch and Xbox or PC, as well as wheel-and-pedal setups for different platforms.

Hori HORIPAD Turbo Frost wireless controller for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2, white and transparent

Hori HORIPAD Turbo Frost Wireless Controller

A wireless gamepad for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2, worth considering if you want to avoid vibration. Check that your racing game supports this controller.

Stated battery life: 10 h. The product name mentions a C-button and button mapping.

Joybuy
Logitech G G923 Black USB 2.0 wheel with pedals for PC and Xbox

Logitech G G923 Black

A wheel-and-pedal setup for anyone with enough space who has checked that the racing game and model are right for their platform. The product name lists PC, Xbox One and Xbox Series S/X.

Connection listed in the product name: USB 2.0. The product description warns of powerful motor force: keep loose objects away during calibration and don’t let young children use the wheel unsupervised.

Joybuy
Thrustmaster H.E.A.R.T. Black, White USB gamepad for PC and Xbox One

Thrustmaster H.E.A.R.T. Black, White USB Gamepad

A wired gamepad for PC or Xbox One players who can use a USB connection where they play. Check that your racing game supports it.

The product name lists PC, Xbox One, Xbox One S and Xbox One X.

Joybuy
Thrustmaster T598-P Direct Axial Drive Force Feedback Racing Wheel for PS5, PS4 and PC

Thrustmaster T598-P Direct Axial Drive Force Feedback Racing Wheel

This wheel-and-pedal setup is for anyone specifically looking for a racing wheel and with enough space to mount it securely. Check that the game and model are suitable for your platform.

The product name lists PS5, PS4 and PC. Check the cables and mounting before use.

Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller, black

Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller

A handheld controller for Switch 2; check that your racing game supports it. Nintendo says this model is for Switch 2 only.

On Switch 2, turning off vibration applies to all synchronised controllers.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I turn off vibration when my roommate is asleep?

On PS5, you can adjust vibration intensity via Settings > Accessories > Controller (General). For an Xbox Wireless Controller, Xbox Support explains how to turn vibration on or off on Xbox. On Switch 2, you can turn off vibration, but the setting applies to all synchronised controllers.

Do all DualSense racing features work wirelessly on PC?

No. Check each feature and game: PlayStation says haptic feedback on PC requires both game support and a USB connection. PlayStation also specifies a wired connection for using the headset jack on PC or Mac.

Is a Switch 2 Pro Controller suitable for the original Nintendo Switch?

No. Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller is for Nintendo Switch 2 only. Don’t confuse it with the separate Pro Controller for the original Switch.

Who can help if a controller bought online is faulty, and can I return it?

According to the Dutch government, the seller must provide a solution if there’s a problem with a product. For distance purchases, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period, although the terms and exceptions depend on the order. Returning an item because you’ve changed your mind is different from getting a faulty product fixed or replaced.