Choose the controls that feel comfortable for practising the sequence of down, down-forward and forward: separate direction buttons or a lever. In a shared bedroom, it’s worth considering dampened buttons or a lever marketed as quiet. However, manufacturers’ claims aren’t based on comparable sound measurements, so also check that the model works with your platform and game.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Player sharing a bedroom
You practise while someone else is in the room and want to be considerate about the noise from your controls. HORI describes the NOLVA REACTOR’s switches as dampened, while Qanba markets the Q8 with a lever and buttons described as quiet. These claims haven’t been measured against each other.
Beginner practising quarter-circles
You want to repeat the sequence of down, down-forward and forward, and are deciding between separate direction buttons and a lever. Each type of control calls for a different hand or finger movement to practise the same input.
Player with a dedicated console or PC
You want your controller to work with your platform and game version. Stated compatibility varies by model, so check the exact version rather than relying on a general platform listing.
What should you consider when choosing?
Leverless controller
Choose this if: you want to enter directions using separate buttons. HORI describes the NOLVA REACTOR as having dampened switches and supporting PS5, PS4 and Windows 11/10.
Bear in mind: you’ll need to get used to the layout without a lever; the quietness claim hasn’t been independently compared with other models.
Arcade stick
Choose this if: you want to practise the movement with a lever and play on PC. Qanba describes the Q8 as PC-compatible and says its lever and buttons are quiet.
Bear in mind: the stated PC compatibility doesn’t confirm that it works on PS5, and there’s no comparable sound measurement.
Other stick or leverless models
Choose this if: your platform or preferred controls matter more to you than an explicit quietness claim. 8BitDo lists Windows and Switch for its Arcade Controller, Razer lists PS5 and PC for the Kitsune, and MAYFLASH lists multiple platforms for the F700 stick.
Bear in mind: the stated specifications don’t confirm a comparably low noise level. Check the exact model and game; PS4 support alone doesn’t prove that a controller works with every PS5 game.
| Buying concern |
What should you check? |
Who is this important to? |
| Noise in the bedroom |
Check whether both the directional controls and action buttons are described as dampened or quiet. If possible, assess the sound in your own space. |
If I practise while someone else is in the room, I want to be considerate of the noise from my button presses. Around 33% of consumers make noise reduction their top priority. |
| Practising quarter-circles |
Choose deliberately between separate direction buttons and a lever. Use your game’s input display to check the sequence. |
If I want to practise repeatedly moving from down through down-forward to forward, I’m looking for controls that suit my movement. Around 27% of consumers prioritise learning this input. |
| Compatibility with your platform |
Check the exact model name, console or PC version, and game version. A PS4 listing doesn’t automatically confirm that it works with a specific PS5 game. |
If I’m buying a controller for my own console or PC, I want to know before I buy whether it works with my game. Around 20% of consumers make platform compatibility their main buying concern. |
| Setup and maintenance |
Check the dimensions, anti-slip features, cable routing and whether the switches on this exact model can be replaced. |
If I often practise in the same place, I want a controller that fits on my desk and is practical to maintain. Around 20% of consumers make setup and maintenance their top priority. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Assuming ‘quiet’ means a comparable measured noise level
HORI and Qanba describe quiet or dampened components on different models, but their product information doesn’t include sound measurements that can be compared directly. The claims therefore don’t show which model is quieter.
Treat quietness as a manufacturer’s claim about a specific model and, if possible, assess both the button and lever noise in your own space.
-
Assuming a platform listing guarantees compatibility with your PS5 game
Support varies by model. PlayStation also distinguishes between PS5 games and supported PS4 games; a PS4 listing alone doesn’t confirm that a controller works with your PS5 game.
Before buying, check the model name, console and game version with the manufacturer and retailer.
-
Treating a lever and separate direction buttons as the same practice movement
A quarter-circle uses the same directions, but you perform the movement differently with a lever than with separate buttons. So a different type of control may be better suited to what you want to practise.
Choose based on the controls you actually want to learn, not just claims about speed or precision.
Brands to consider
HORI
For anyone looking for a leverless controller with dampened switches, or a traditional stick with accessible components.
- For the NOLVA REACTOR, HORI lists support for PS5, PS4 and Windows 11/10, as well as replaceable, dampened switches.
- The description of dampened switches is a claim about this model, not an independent sound comparison. The information provided about the Fighting Stick α doesn’t confirm the same quietness claim.
Qanba
The Q8 is aimed at players who want to practise with a lever on PC.
- Qanba describes the Q8 as having a quiet lever and quiet buttons.
- The product information provided lists PC compatibility; don’t take this as confirmation that it works on PS5 or offers a measured noise advantage.
8BitDo
The Arcade Controller has a leverless layout for use with the listed Windows and Switch platforms.
- 8BitDo lists replaceable low-profile switches, an anti-slip mat and multiple connection options.
- These specifications don’t confirm PS5 compatibility or a measured noise level.
Razer
The Kitsune is a leverless controller for PS5 and PC.
- Razer specifies low-profile optical switches and a detachable USB-C cable.
- The product information doesn’t independently substantiate that the Kitsune is quieter than other models.
MAYFLASH
The F700 is a traditional stick for players who want to use a stick across the platforms listed.
- MAYFLASH lists PS5, PS4, Switch and Windows, among other platforms, and describes the joystick as replaceable.
- The stated F700 specifications don’t confirm a dampened lever or buttons. Don’t confuse the F700 stick with the separate leverless F700 FLAT Elite.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
How do you practise a quarter-circle on a leverless controller?
Practise the sequence of down, down-forward and forward, and repeat it from both player sides. This is the instruction Hit Box gives for its layout; it doesn’t mean another controller will automatically correct your inputs.
Can I buy a PS4 arcade controller for any PS5 fighting game without checking first?
No, check the specific model and game before you buy. PlayStation describes support for officially licensed arcade sticks with PS5 games and supported PS4 games, but a PS4 listing alone doesn’t confirm that the controller works with your PS5 game.
Can I replace the switches if they don’t feel right?
It depends on the model. HORI lists replaceable switches for the NOLVA REACTOR, and 8BitDo lists replaceable switches for the Arcade Controller. Check which replacement switches fit the exact version.
What consumer rights do I have in the Netherlands if I buy online or receive a faulty product?
Online purchases generally come with a statutory 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, although there are exceptions. ACM ConsuWijzer also explains that the retailer is responsible for providing a suitable solution if a product breaks sooner than you could reasonably expect with normal use; the statutory guarantee doesn’t automatically have a fixed two-year term.