Who is this relevant to?

Puzzle player who plays for long periods

Wants a button layout and grip that suit their hands, with buttons that are easy to reach during repeated input. A description of a controller as comfortable doesn’t guarantee that it will feel right for everyone.

Player on a single console

Is looking for a controller for their PlayStation or Nintendo console and also checks whether the specific puzzle game supports the desired controls.

PC player looking to minimise interruptions

Weighs up wired and wireless play, batteries and charging, after checking whether the puzzle game supports the controller.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, check the exact game and device. Then compare the controls and decide which power option suits your playing setup.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Device and game Check the exact controller model and whether the puzzle game supports it; connecting to your device alone isn’t enough. If I want to be sure that both my device and the specific game support the controller, I check each separately. Around 29% of consumers prioritise device and game compatibility.
Grip and buttons Compare the position of the D-pad and action buttons; check whether you can reach them without gripping the controller too tightly. For long sessions, I want to reach the buttons easily and choose a grip that suits my hand, without treating extra features as the deciding factor. Around 29% of consumers give controls and grip top priority.
Power Check whether batteries or a charging cable are included, and whether a cable is long enough for where you sit. If I don’t want to stop halfway through a puzzle to charge the controller or replace the batteries, I weigh up wireless play against using a cable. Around 24% of consumers start by considering the power supply.
Extra features and aftercare Compare what’s included in the box and only pay for features you expect to use; also check the warranty and returns terms. If I want to avoid unnecessary extras or unexpected additional purchases, I check what I actually need and what applies if something goes wrong. Around 18% of consumers prioritise cost, extra features and aftercare.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming ‘works with PC’ also means it works with your puzzle game

    A controller may connect to a PC even if the game doesn’t support the controls you want to use.

    Before choosing, check support for both the exact game and the controller model.

  • Confusing the two 8BitDo Ultimate 2C versions

    8BitDo lists Windows and Android for the Ultimate 2C Wireless, and Switch for the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth. So, despite their similar names, they aren’t designed for the same platforms.

    Compare the full model name with its platform specifications and your game’s controller support.

  • Assuming batteries are included or that the controller has a fixed battery life

    Microsoft says selected Xbox controller packages don’t include AA batteries. Nintendo notes that the battery life of a fully charged Switch Pro Controller may vary depending on the software and features used.

    Check what’s included in the package you choose and consider whether charging, replaceable batteries or a wired controller best suits how you play.

    Some wireless controllers may need a separate battery or charging solution; check before you order.

Relevant controller brands to consider

Microsoft Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is an option if you play on Xbox or another compatible device and want wireless connectivity and a D-pad.

  • Microsoft lists a textured grip and hybrid D-pad among this model’s features.
  • Grip is a personal preference. Check what’s included in the box too: selected newer controllers may be supplied without AA batteries.

Nintendo

The Nintendo Switch Pro Controller is designed for Switch players. Nintendo also says that, after wireless pairing, this model can be used with Switch 2.

  • Nintendo quotes around 40 hours of use for a fully charged Switch Pro Controller.
  • Battery life may vary depending on the software and features used. The Switch 2 Pro Controller is a different model, so don’t confuse the two.

Sony PlayStation

DualSense is the controller for PS5. Sony also describes connecting it to devices including a Windows PC via USB-C or Bluetooth.

  • Sony lists haptic feedback and adaptive triggers among DualSense’s features.
  • Check whether your puzzle game supports these features; connecting to a PC doesn’t automatically confirm that it does.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C is available in different versions for different platforms, such as Windows and Android for the Wireless version and Switch for the Bluetooth version.

  • For the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth, 8BitDo lists a D-pad and extra assignable bumpers.
  • The similar product names can make the differences easy to miss. Check the full version name and stated platform compatibility.

PowerA

The Advantage Wired is a wired option for Xbox players whose setup suits a cable.

  • PowerA lists a 10 ft USB-C cable and assignable buttons for this model.
  • The cable limits where you can sit. PowerA notes that some features vary by title.

Controllers at Joybuy

This selection at Joybuy includes wireless controllers for Xbox and PC, PS4 and PC, and Switch and PC. For each model, check that both your device and puzzle game support the controls you want to use.

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC - Ice Breaker Special Edition

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC, Ice Breaker Special Edition

For anyone looking for a wireless controller for Xbox Series or PC; also check whether the puzzle game supports controller input.

View at Joybuy
Black wireless Dualshock game controller compatible with PS4 and PC

Wireless Dualshock Controller for PS4 and PC

For anyone looking for a wireless controller for PS4 or PC; check support for the specific game.

View at Joybuy
Wireless Controller for PS4/PC with RGB lighting, dual vibration, touchpad and 1000 mAh battery

Wireless Controller for PS4/PC with touchpad

For anyone looking for a wireless PS4 or PC controller with extra input features; check which features the puzzle game uses.

The product name lists RGB lighting, dual vibration, turbo, a touchpad, a headphone socket and a 1000 mAh battery.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN wireless Bluetooth controller for PS4 with 600 mAh battery

VIELLAN wireless Bluetooth controller for PS4, 600 mAh

For anyone looking for a wireless Bluetooth controller for PS4; check that the puzzle game supports it before choosing.

The product name lists a 600 mAh battery and dual vibration.

View at Joybuy
Game controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

Game controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

For anyone looking for a controller with a motion sensor for Switch or PC; check that your device and puzzle game support this type of input.

The product name lists dual vibration and a gyroscope.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will every PC controller work with every puzzle game?

No. Simply connecting to a PC doesn’t prove that the game supports the controller. Steam shows support by game and controller type; also check the settings for your specific game.

Can you use the original Switch Pro Controller with a Switch 2?

Yes. Nintendo says that the original Switch Pro Controller can be paired wirelessly with a Switch 2. Also check that your puzzle game supports the controller input you want to use.

What if your Xbox Wireless Controller comes without AA batteries?

First, check what’s included in your package. Microsoft says selected controllers bought in December 2025 or later may be eligible for a rechargeable battery with a USB-C cable; to check, register the serial number and review the service option offered. This doesn’t automatically apply to every controller.

What are your rights in the Netherlands when you buy a controller online?

For online purchases from a business, the Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets says you usually have a 14-day cooling-off period from delivery, subject to legal exceptions. If the product is faulty, the seller is responsible for the statutory guarantee; this is separate from any manufacturer’s warranty.

Does a controller described as ergonomic mean you don’t need to take breaks?

No. Arboportaal guidance on repetitive hand movements and static postures relates to screen-based work and doesn’t set a safe playing time for any particular controller or game. So don’t treat a description of comfort as a guarantee that you won’t experience discomfort.