Groups with text-based rotas
You mainly need black-and-white text, and the printer may sit idle between uses. The Dutch Consumers’ Association explains the differences between laser and inkjet printers.
If your rotas are mainly black-and-white text and you don’t need colour, a multifunction mono laser printer is an obvious choice. If you do need colour, choose between cartridges and an ink tank based on your actual print volume. Also compare toner or ink costs, whether a drum is needed, automatic double-sided printing, and the document feeder and scanning features separately. The Dutch Consumers’ Association points out that inkjet ink can dry out if the printer is used infrequently. If several people share it, agree who can access rotas containing personal data.
You mainly need black-and-white text, and the printer may sit idle between uses. The Dutch Consumers’ Association explains the differences between laser and inkjet printers.
Regularly printing several colour-coded copies means weighing up the purchase price against the cost of refills. Epson and HP describe their ink tank models for colour printing.
If you also need to scan or copy paper documents as well as print rotas, the document feeder and scanning features become important. Canon and HP list document feeders on specific models.
Best when: rotas contain almost entirely black text and colour isn’t essential.
Trade-off: this option doesn’t print in colour; check the cost of toner and, if applicable, a drum.
Best when: you need colour, but your print volume doesn’t make an ink tank an obvious choice.
Trade-off: compare the cost of replacement cartridges, and bear in mind that occasional use may involve extra ink consumption for cleaning.
Best when: your group regularly prints colour rotas and other documents, and you want to weigh the cost of ink bottles against the printer’s purchase price.
Trade-off: manufacturers’ page-yield figures are based on their own conditions; actual consumption depends on how you use the printer.
Start by considering whether you need colour and how often you print. Then check the double-sided printing, scanning and shared-access features.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Clear black-and-white rotas | Automatic duplex printing, paper tray, and the cost of compatible toner and, if applicable, a drum. | If I mainly print text-based rotas and sometimes leave the printer unused for a while, I want the printing option to suit that pattern. Around 33% of consumers put black-and-white text at the top of their list of needs. |
| Colour printing | Estimate how many colour pages you print and compare the relevant cartridges or ink bottles. | If we regularly use colour coding across several rotas, I want to weigh up refill costs against our usage. Around 25% of consumers give regular colour printing their highest priority. |
| Occasional printing | Bear in mind that the printer may sit idle, and compare inkjet use with a mono laser if you don’t need colour. | If we mainly print when rotas change, I want to allow for the possibility of extra ink being used for cleaning. Around 25% of consumers say occasional use is their main consideration when choosing. |
| Scanning and shared use | Check the document feeder, double-sided scanning and connections for the devices you use. | If we want to digitise paper documents or share the printer, I want to arrange the feeder setup and access rules in advance. Around 17% of consumers prioritise document handling or shared use. |
Costs also depend on how much and how often your group prints, as well as the ink or toner you need.
Estimate how many black-and-white and colour pages you’ll print, then compare the refills compatible with the models you’re considering.
A feeder for multiple sheets doesn’t automatically scan both sides of a document. According to Canon, the Canon PIXMA TS7750i has a single-sided document feeder.
Check for double-sided scanning separately if you want to digitise paper rotas printed on both sides.
HP says the OfficeJet Pro 8132e has dynamic security that can block cartridges with a non-HP chip. This restriction doesn’t automatically apply to other HP models.
Check the cartridge terms for the exact model before choosing refills.
The DCP-L2627DWE is an example of a multifunction mono laser printer for text-based rotas.
The PIXMA TS7750i is a colour cartridge model with features for scanning multiple sheets.
The EcoTank ET-2950 is an example of a multifunction colour printer with refillable ink tanks.
The Smart Tank 7305 is an ink tank model; the OfficeJet Pro 8132e is a separate cartridge option.
These printer picks are aimed at printing colour rotas and group documents. Check that each model’s scanning, copying and connectivity features suit the way you work.
No image available
A colour ink tank option for regular colour rotas and multi-page documents. HP lists automatic double-sided printing and a document feeder for up to 35 sheets; double-sided scanning isn’t available.
No image available
An A4 inkjet option for those who need colour. Before buying, check that its scanning, copying and connectivity features suit your group’s devices and documents.
No image available
An A4 colour printing option with Wi-Fi, according to the product name. If your group needs more than printing, check whether this version has the scanning and copying features you’re looking for.
No image available
A colour ink tank option for rotas that also need scanning and copying. Automatic double-sided printing is listed, but double-sided scanning isn’t available. If you want to scan stacks of documents, check whether the version you’re considering has a document feeder.
No. The Canon PIXMA TS7750i lists automatic double-sided printing on A4 plain paper, but according to Canon it has a single-sided document feeder. Check both features separately if you want to digitise paper rotas printed on both sides.
Check that the connections on your chosen model work with the devices your volunteers use. Brother lists Wi-Fi and USB, among other connections, for the DCP-L2627DWE. If rotas contain personal data, also agree who can print or collect them.
According to the Dutch Consumers’ Association, inkjet printers may use ink for cleaning cycles when they’re used infrequently. Compare refill costs with your actual usage: the purchase price alone doesn’t give you the full picture.
No, not without considering the implications. Names and phone numbers are personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that when sharing data, an organisation must consider the purpose for which it was collected and decide on appropriate security measures. Which details can appear on a rota and who can receive it depends on the specific circumstances; owning a particular printer doesn’t give you permission to share them.
Before you buy, check whose name the purchase is made in and what terms the seller offers. The Dutch Government describes the consumer rights mentioned as applying to purchases made by private individuals; it doesn’t automatically follow that an organisation has the same rights. For purchases made by private individuals in the Netherlands, the Dutch Government describes statutory guarantees without a fixed Dutch guarantee period.