Who is this buying guide for?

People caring for delicate journals

They want to digitise bound copies without putting strain on the spine or pages; protecting the original matters more than scanning speed. The Library of Congress stresses that materials should be handled safely during the digitisation process.

Groups with large journal pages

They check the scan area and flatbed dimensions, not just the maximum print size. Brother lists maximum flatbed dimensions of 297 × 431,8 mm for the MFC-J6760DW.

Volunteers with loose archive sheets

They scan suitable loose pages as well as journals, so an automatic document feeder (ADF) may be useful. It is designed for loose sheets, not bound books.

What should you look for?

First, consider the binding and size of the original material. Then work out how many loose sheets and printouts the group expects to handle.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Delicate, bound pages Check whether the book can rest on the flatbed without being forced into position, and follow the instructions for thick originals. When I scan a delicate journal, I don’t want to press down on the spine. Around 33% of consumers prioritise preserving bound books.
Large or illustrated pages Measure the largest page and compare it with the scan area and flatbed dimensions of the exact model. I want to capture a large page in one go and be able to examine the details. Around 27% of consumers give a suitable scan area top priority.
Loose inserts Check the ADF capacity, which originals it can handle and whether you need double-sided scanning. If there are piles of suitable loose sheets, I don’t want to feed them in one at a time. Around 20% of consumers prioritise handling loose pages.
Printing and refills Check which refills are compatible and compare the stated yield conditions with the expected number of printouts. I also want to make copies, so I need to factor in printer refills. Around 20% of consumers give printing and refills top priority.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming an ADF is suitable for bound journals

    An automatic document feeder handles suitable loose sheets. Bound books need to be handled individually and carefully on the flatbed.

    Choose a scanning method to suit the binding, and use the ADF only for suitable loose inserts.

  • Assuming A3 in the product name means it can scan A3 pages

    Print size and scan size are separate specifications. If the flatbed is too small, a page may not fit in one go.

    Compare your measured page with the explicit scanning specification and flatbed dimensions of the exact model.

    If the flatbed is too small, you may need to scan the page in sections.

  • Looking at the printer alone

    If you print regularly, compatible refills and expected usage matter too; a stated ink yield is not a forecast for every group.

    Compare the right refills and their yield conditions against the same expected number and type of printouts.

Brands to compare

Brother

The MFC-J6760DW offers A3 scanning, while the DCP-T780DW is an A4 option with refillable ink tanks and an ADF.

  • Brother lists scanning up to A3 and a 50-sheet ADF for the MFC-J6760DW. The manual gives maximum flatbed dimensions of 297 × 431,8 mm.
  • The ADF is for loose sheets. For thick books, follow the instructions about the cover and don’t force the original flat.
  • Brother lists a 20-sheet ADF for the DCP-T780DW.

Canon

The PIXMA G650 combines A4 photo printing with scanning and copying; the PIXMA TS7750i has an ADF for loose pages.

  • Canon specifies six inks and manual double-sided printing for the G650.
  • Canon lists a single-sided ADF for up to 35 sheets for the TS7750i.
  • The TS7750i’s ADF specification doesn’t mean the G650 has this feature too.

Epson

The EcoTank ET-3950 is an A4 all-in-one with refillable ink tanks, designed for loose sheets and regular printing.

  • Epson lists a double-sided ADF and refillable ink tanks for this model.
  • Check separately whether bound pages fit within the scan area. Yield and savings claims depend on the conditions.

HP

The Smart Tank 7605 is an A4 ink-tank all-in-one with an ADF for loose documents and printing.

  • HP lists a 35-sheet feeder and scanning to PDF.
  • For journals, check the scan area separately and make sure the binding can rest safely on the flatbed.

Products on Joybuy

A selection of products on Joybuy related to this topic. Check whether the features listed for each model are suitable for scanning journal pages and loose inserts.

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One Color Printer

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One Color Printer

The flatbed scanner is suitable for pages within the stated scan area. Use the ADF for suitable loose originals, not for a bound journal.

Maximum scan area: 216 × 297 mm. ADF capacity: 35 sheets.

View on Joybuy
Canon PIXMA MG2556S Inkjet A4 4800 x 600DPI

Canon PIXMA MG2556S Inkjet A4 4800 x 600DPI

According to the product description, this A4 inkjet printer combines printing, scanning and copying. Check that the scan area is large enough for your journal pages.

A4 inkjet printer; the product name lists 4800 x 600DPI.

View on Joybuy
Epson WorkForce Pro WF-C5390DW colour inkjet printer

Epson WorkForce Pro WF-C5390DW

For a group mainly looking to print A4 colour documents. Before buying, check that this exact model has the scanning feature you need.

A4, Wi-Fi and automatic double-sided printing; the product name lists 4800x1200DPI.

View on Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One Color Printer

HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One Color Printer

The flatbed scanner and colour scanning feature may suit A4 pages. Handle the glass carefully when scanning a bound journal.

Maximum scan area: 216 × 297 mm. Scanning to PDF and refillable ink tanks are listed.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can a bound journal go through the automatic document feeder?

Use the ADF for suitable loose sheets, not for bound books. Brother recommends scanning a book on the flatbed and warns against forcing the cover shut or pressing down on it.

How should you start with a delicate or thick journal?

First, assess whether the original can be handled safely, and don’t try to force it flat. If the binding is delicate, a different scanning set-up or expert help may be more suitable than a standard all-in-one printer.

Does A3 printing automatically mean you can scan A3 pages?

No. Check the separate scanning specification and the flatbed dimensions. Brother lists scanning up to A3 for the MFC-J6760DW and also gives the maximum flatbed dimensions.

What should the group look for when it comes to refills and the warranty?

Check which refills are compatible with your chosen model and compare the yield conditions with your expected printing needs. The ACM explains the legal guarantee for sales to consumers; whether the group’s purchase counts as a consumer purchase depends on who enters into the agreement.

Can the group share scans of travel journals online?

Not automatically. The Dutch Government states that a private copy for personal use must not be distributed or made public; for protected works, check who can give permission. If scans contain other people’s personal data, the organisation must establish a lawful basis for processing it, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority. In most cases, permission is needed to publish online.