Occasional rota printer
You mainly print clear black-and-white rotas, sometimes with long gaps between print jobs. The risk of ink drying out may be a factor; the Consumers’ Association identifies this as something to consider with inkjet printers.
If you mainly print text occasionally and black and white is enough, a black-and-white laser printer is a sensible option: toner does not have the drying-out problem associated with inkjet ink, as the Consumers’ Association explains. If you print colour rotas regularly, compare colour ink tank printers for their features, duplex printing and the balance between use and maintenance; ink tank printers are also inkjet printers. Protect rotas containing information that could identify employees in line with your organisation’s procedures, whatever type of printer you use.
You mainly print clear black-and-white rotas, sometimes with long gaps between print jobs. The risk of ink drying out may be a factor; the Consumers’ Association identifies this as something to consider with inkjet printers.
You print rotas more often or in larger quantities and want to weigh up running costs, paper capacity and duplex printing. Brother UK lists automatic duplex printing and a 250-sheet paper tray among the features of the HL-L2445DW.
Colour helps you distinguish between shifts or teams, and you’re also considering a scanner or copier. Epson and Canon describe models with colour and additional features, but duplex operation varies by model.
A good fit if: black and white is enough and you mainly print text documents, even after long periods without use.
Trade-off: you won’t get colour; also check whether you need a scanner and which toner and, where applicable, drum the model uses.
A good fit if: you print colour rotas regularly and want scanning or copying in the same device.
Trade-off: ink tank printers use inkjet technology; if used infrequently, the print head can become clogged. The Consumers’ Association also notes that their purchase price is generally higher than that of standard cartridge printers.
A good fit if: you need colour and have compared the expected print volume and costs for the specific model.
Trade-off: if you print infrequently, cleaning can use ink; a low purchase price alone doesn’t tell you what printing will cost over time.
| Point to consider | What should you check? | Who is this most relevant to? |
|---|---|---|
| Printing after a break | Decide whether black and white is enough and check which toner and, where applicable, drum the specific model uses. | If I only print text rotas occasionally, I want them to remain legible after a break. Around 33% of consumers say reliable black-and-white printing after a break is their main concern. |
| Regular use | Estimate your own page volume and compare suitable refills, paper capacity and the duplex function. | When I’m printing new rotas regularly, I want to be able to weigh up running costs and topping up the paper. Around 25% of consumers prioritise ongoing printing costs and paper handling. |
| Personal data | Make sure the printer’s location, access, storage and disposal of printouts comply with your organisation’s policies. | If rotas identify employees, I want to know who can access the printer and paper copies. Around 17% of consumers say protecting staff information is their main concern. |
| Use of colour | Check whether the rota is still clear in greyscale; if colour is essential, compare consumables and duplex operation. | When colour distinguishes shifts or teams, I want to keep that distinction clear on paper too. Around 17% of consumers consider colour the main factor in their choice. |
| Extra features and connectivity | Check scanning and copying separately from Wi-Fi and compatibility with the devices you use. | If I also want to digitise documents, I’m looking for a device that does more than just print. Around 8% of consumers prioritise this combination of features and connectivity. |
The cost of consumables depends in part on your print volume and the specific model. If you use an inkjet printer infrequently, it may also use ink for cleaning.
Compare the printer and compatible refills based on the number of pages you expect to print.
According to Canon, the Canon PIXMA G3570 requires manual operation for duplex printing; Brother lists automatic duplex printing for the HL-L2445DW.
Check the specifications for the exact model to see whether duplex printing is automatic if that’s important to you.
With manual duplex printing, you have to reload the paper yourself when printing rotas with multiple pages.
A wireless connection doesn’t control who can see printed rotas or how they are stored and disposed of. The Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that documents must be properly protected when working from home.
Follow your organisation’s policies and assess the printer’s location, access, storage and disposal together; don’t assume that a printer feature ensures compliance.
HP states that this model has dynamic cartridge protection, which may block cartridges without a new or reused HP chip, including after firmware updates.
Before buying, check which cartridges are compatible with the specific model and include them in your comparison.
You may be limited to cartridges with a new or reused HP chip.
The HL-L2445DW is an example of a black-and-white laser printer for text documents.
The LaserJet M209dw is a black-and-white laser model for rotas that don’t need colour.
The EcoTank ET-2950 is a colour ink tank model with scanning and copying functions.
The PIXMA G3570 is a colour MegaTank model with printing, scanning and copying functions.
These models are suited to printing rotas at home, with options for colour, duplex printing or extra features. Check that the features listed for each model suit your needs, and bear in mind the maintenance trade-offs of inkjet printers if you leave long gaps between print jobs.
No image available
An option to compare if you want to print colour rotas and also need duplex printing, scanning or copying.
Inkjet printer; if left unused for long periods, the ink can dry out and clog the print head.
No image available
An option to compare if, as well as printing rotas at home, you want to scan or copy documents.
Inkjet printer; if left unused for long periods, the ink can dry out and clog the print head.
No image available
An option to compare if automatic duplex printing and wireless printing suit the way you manage rotas.
Inkjet printer; if left unused for long periods, the ink can dry out and clog the print head.
No image available
An option to compare if you want to print colour rotas and need automatic duplex printing.
Inkjet printer; if left unused for long periods, the ink can dry out and clog the print head. The product information lists a weight of over 15 kg and recommends that two people lift the device.
No image available
An option to compare if you want to print colour rotas, scan or copy documents, and print double-sided.
Inkjet printer; if left unused for long periods, the ink can dry out and clog the print head.
A name or other information that could identify an employee is personal data. Ask your organisation to assess whether printing at home fits its procedures, and follow its rules on access, storage and disposal; the Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that documents must be properly protected at home.
Only if colour conveys information that would be lost in black and white. If black and white is enough, a laser printer is an option for text documents without the drying-out problem associated with inkjet ink; be sure to check the consumables for the specific model.
No, operation varies by model. Brother lists automatic duplex printing for the HL-L2445DW; Canon specifies manual operation for the PIXMA G3570. Check the specifications for the exact model.
Don’t keep personal data for longer than necessary for its purpose, while taking any other applicable retention requirements into account. Ask your organisation to set the appropriate retention period and arrange secure disposal; according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the GDPR does not set a general fixed period for this.
Check which refills are compatible with the specific model and compare them with your own print volume. According to Brother, the HL-L2445DW has a separate drum and toner; HP states that cartridge protection on the LaserJet M209dw may affect which cartridges can be used.