Who is this approach for?

Careful archiving

You want to capture bound, old or delicate programmes and images without putting unnecessary strain on the originals. Start by checking their size and condition, and how the booklet can be placed on the scanner.

Scanning loose programme sheets

You have suitable loose sheets that you want to digitise in an organised way, perhaps so you can find the text later. Check that the sheets can go through the ADF, and bear in mind that OCR is a separate step. The National Library of the Netherlands notes that scan image quality affects text recognition.

Regular printing too

You want to print colour materials regularly after digitising them. Compare not only the scanning features, but also the running costs and your expected print volume. The Dutch Consumers' Association highlights print volume as something to consider when choosing a printer.

What should you look for?

Start with the condition and size of the originals. Then work out how many loose pages you want to process, and factor in printing costs if you also need physical copies. The Library of Congress advises considering the risk that the digitising method could pose to the material.

What to consider What to look for Who should consider this?
Size and fragility Check that the scanning area can capture the full image and that you can position the original safely. Don’t force a binding open. If you want to preserve a delicate or bound booklet, you’ll need to scan it in full without forcing it open; around 36% of consumers prioritise preservation and size.
Colour and legibility Check the optical scanning specification and scan a sample of both text and images. Print resolution doesn’t tell you how well the scanner performs. If the text and illustrations need to remain clear, you’ll want to assess the scanned file using a sample page; around 29% of consumers prioritise colour and legibility.
Processing and finding information later Check that suitable sheets can go through the ADF and that duplex scanning is supported if you need it. Searchable text requires a separate OCR step. If you have lots of loose sheets, you’ll want to reduce manual feeding and be able to find the text later; around 21% of consumers prioritise processing speed and being able to find information.
Ongoing printing costs Estimate how many colour and black-and-white pages you’ll print, then compare suitable refills and purchase costs over the same period of use. If you print regularly as well as archiving, you’ll want to weigh running costs against your print volume; around 14% of consumers prioritise ongoing printing costs.

Buying pitfalls

  • Confusing duplex printing with duplex scanning

    These are separate features. The Dutch Consumers' Association lists duplex scanning as a separate consideration if you need that feature.

    Check the scanning specifications specifically, and scan both sides as a test if needed.

  • Using print dpi as a measure of archive quality

    Print resolution and optical scan resolution describe different functions. The National Library of the Netherlands notes that scan image quality affects OCR accuracy.

    Look up the optical scanning specification and assess a representative page for both text and image quality.

  • Focusing only on the purchase price or a general ink claim

    Running costs depend in part on how much you actually print. A general manufacturer’s claim won’t calculate the costs for your project.

    Estimate your print volume, then compare suitable refills and terms.

  • Treating a bound booklet like a stack of loose sheets

    A document feeder isn’t automatically suitable for an old, bound or delicate original. The Library of Congress advises assessing in advance how to reduce the risk of damage.

    Choose a safe scanning method for each item, and use the ADF only for suitable loose sheets.

Printer brands to consider

Canon

Worth considering if you’re looking for a colour inkjet with a flatbed scanner and, potentially, an ADF for suitable loose sheets.

  • Canon specifies a flatbed scanner, an ADF for up to 20 A4 sheets and optical scanning at 600 × 1200 dpi for the PIXMA TR4755i series.
  • The ADF capacity doesn’t mean it’s suitable for feeding delicate booklets. Compare cartridge costs separately if you print a lot.

Brother

Worth considering if you genuinely need A3 scans or process lots of suitable loose sheets. The features listed are for different models.

  • Brother specifies scanning up to A3 for the MFC-J6760DW and an ADF for 50 sheets for the DCP-L3560CDW.
  • These are specifications for two different models, not an independent comparison of their scanning results. Measure the original before choosing A3.

HP

The HP Smart Tank 7005 is an all-in-one tank printer for anyone who wants to print colour pages regularly as well as scan.

  • HP lists automatic duplex printing and scanning to PDF for the Smart Tank 7005.
  • HP’s stated ink yield isn’t a cost calculation for your project. Assess the scanner’s features and your own print volume separately.

Epson

The EcoTank ET-2950 is an all-in-one A4 model for anyone who prints regularly as well as scanning and copying.

  • Epson lists printing, scanning and copying for the ET-2950.
  • A claim about lower printing costs won’t necessarily apply to every print volume. Compare costs based on your own usage.

Joybuy products

This selection includes models for scanning and printing, as well as a printer for printing only. Check that your chosen setup meets your scanning needs.

HP Smart Tank 7305 wireless all-in-one colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One

Suitable if you print colour pages as well as archive documents, and can feed suitable loose sheets into the printer.

The listed scanner is a flatbed model with an ADF for 35 sheets. Its maximum scanning area is 216 × 297 mm (A4), and its optical scan resolution is 1200 × 1200 dpi. Duplex scanning isn’t supported.

View at Joybuy
Canon PIXMA MG2556S A4 inkjet printer

Canon PIXMA MG2556S A4 inkjet printer

An option if you want to print A4 documents and scan and copy too.

The product information lists support for up to A4, a 60-sheet input capacity and a USB 2.0 connection.

View at Joybuy
Epson WorkForce Pro WF-C5390DW A4 colour inkjet printer with Wi-Fi

Epson WorkForce Pro WF-C5390DW A4 Wi-Fi

For printing: the product information describes a colour inkjet printer with automatic duplex printing. Don’t assume this model also meets your scanning needs.

The stated print speed is 25 ppm in black and white and colour. According to the description, the device weighs more than 15 kg and requires two people to lift it into position.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 wireless all-in-one colour printer

HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One

Suitable if you print colour pages as well as archive documents and want to use a flatbed scanner.

The scanner is a flatbed model with a maximum scanning area of 216 × 297 mm (A4) and a stated optical scan resolution of 1200 × 1200 dpi. This model has no ADF and doesn’t support duplex scanning.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I put a bound programme booklet through the automatic document feeder?

Use the ADF only for suitable loose sheets. For a bound or delicate booklet, first check whether you can position it safely and whether the flatbed can capture the full image you need. Don’t force the binding open.

Will scanning automatically make the programme searchable?

No, you’ll need to use OCR. Check the recognised text afterwards, especially on damaged or hard-to-read pages. The National Library of the Netherlands notes that scan image quality affects text recognition.

How can I check that scans are clear and legible?

Start with a test scan and check the edges, small print and images. In the scanning software you’re using, look at the settings for dpi, colour and file format.

Do I need an A3 printer for programme booklets?

Only if the original is actually larger than A4 and you want to scan it at full size. Brother specifies scanning up to A3 for the MFC-J6760DW. Measure the booklet and check that you can position it safely on the scanner before choosing that size.

Can a school share scans of programme booklets online?

Not automatically. According to the Dutch Government, making a copy for personal use doesn’t automatically give you the right to distribute or publish text or photographs. For publishing identifiable photos of pupils, the Dutch Data Protection Authority requires consent and appropriate security measures: parental consent is needed for pupils under 16, and consent from the pupil themselves is needed from the age of 16.