Anyone who wants to preserve bound recipes
You want to digitise pages without removing them from the booklet. So check the flatbed, scan size and clearance around the spine. Brother Support explains how to use the flatbed for book pages.
For bound recipe booklets, a suitable flatbed scanner is more important than an automatic document feeder (ADF): scan the pages individually and don’t force the lid shut. An ADF is mainly useful for suitable loose sheets. Also choose based on whether you need colour printing and how much you actually print; printing infrequently doesn’t automatically make an ink tank the cheaper option.
You want to digitise pages without removing them from the booklet. So check the flatbed, scan size and clearance around the spine. Brother Support explains how to use the flatbed for book pages.
You scan booklets, but also print recipes in colour from time to time. Factor in your expected print volume and the refill costs for the exact model you’re considering.
You want to be able to search your scans by text later. Bear in mind that handwriting isn’t automatically recognised reliably; Microsoft Support notes that handwriting is rarely recognised using the Word method it describes.
Choose this option if: you want to scan bound pages individually and also print recipes in colour occasionally.
Bear in mind: an inkjet may use ink for cleaning if you print infrequently, so compare your own usage with the cost of refills.
Choose this option if: you regularly print recipes in colour as well as scanning them, and want to weigh your expected print volume against the purchase and refill costs.
Bear in mind: an ink tank alone doesn’t prove that your overall costs will be lower for the way you use it.
Choose this option if: you mainly print text in black and white and don’t need colour prints.
Bear in mind: prints are in black and white; when comparing consumables, check whether a separate drum is also required.
| What to consider | What to check before buying | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Bound pages | Check the flatbed, scan size and clearance beneath the lid for your booklet’s spine. Don’t force a thick book flat. | If you want to preserve recipes without removing the pages, how they sit on the flatbed and the clearance around the spine are key. Around 42% of consumers give preserving bound booklets their highest priority. |
| Printing costs | Compare the purchase price with the cost of compatible cartridges, ink bottles or toner for your expected black-and-white and colour printing. A manufacturer’s savings claim won’t necessarily apply to your circumstances. | If you mainly want to know what printing will cost for the way you use it, compare your expected volume with the consumables you’ll need. Around 25% of consumers put printing costs first. |
| Handwritten recipes | Check which scan file formats and software are supported. Test text recognition on a representative handwritten recipe, then check the ingredients and quantities. | If you want to search for recipes by text, allow for the extra checking handwritten text may require. Around 17% of consumers give searchability their highest priority. |
| Loose sheets | Check the ADF capacity and whether double-sided scanning is actually supported; double-sided printing doesn’t mean it is. | If you also process piles of loose recipes, an ADF can help with those, but not with bound pages. Around 16% of consumers give loose sheets and easy handling their highest priority. |
An ADF is designed for suitable loose documents; scan bound pages individually on the flatbed. How the page sits near the spine and the size of the flatbed determine what you can capture.
Check the flatbed and try positioning a representative booklet. Use the ADF as an extra feature for loose sheets.
Bound pages need to be turned by hand, one at a time.
The balance between purchase and running costs depends on how much you print. An inkjet may use ink for cleaning if you print infrequently; a laser model may need a separate drum as well as toner.
Compare the consumables for the exact model with your expected print volume and how long you plan to use the printer.
A scan preserves the image, but it doesn’t automatically make handwritten text reliably searchable. Microsoft Support says that handwriting is rarely recognised using the Word method it describes.
Keep the original scan and check any recognised ingredients and quantities before relying on them.
Allow time to check the results or create a manual index.
Brother Netherlands lists the DCP-J1360DW as a colour inkjet model with a 20-sheet ADF. The DCP-L2660DW is a black-and-white laser model with a 50-sheet ADF.
Canon Netherlands specifies an ADF of up to 35 sheets for single-sided feeding on the PIXMA TS7750i.
The Smart Tank 7005 is a colour all-in-one printer with an ink tank. This product range may be worth considering if you regularly print in colour as well as scan.
The EcoTank ET-2950 is a colour all-in-one printer with an ink tank; a model like this may be worth considering if you print in colour regularly.
These Joybuy product picks are for anyone who wants to print and digitise recipes. For each exact model, check that it has the scanning features, flatbed and clearance you need for a bound booklet.
No image available
An option to compare if you want to print recipes in colour as well as scan them; check that A3 suits your needs and the space you have available.
A3 colour inkjet; Wi-Fi.
No image available
Worth comparing if you regularly print in colour as well as scan recipes; weigh your expected print volume against the purchase and refill costs.
Wireless; double-sided printing.
Check separately whether double-sided scanning is supported.
No image available
An A4 inkjet to compare for home use; before buying, check that this exact model has the scanning function you need for recipes.
A4; 4800 × 600 DPI.
No image available
This A4 colour inkjet is suitable for a recipe archive only if the exact model also has the scanning function you need; check before buying.
A4; colour inkjet; Wi-Fi.
No image available
Worth comparing if you want to print recipes in colour and keep scans too; check that the scan size suits your booklet and that the lid has enough clearance.
Wireless; double-sided printing.
Check separately whether double-sided scanning is supported.
Use the flatbed for bound pages; an ADF is designed for suitable loose documents. Place the page you want to scan on the glass, and don’t force the lid shut over a thick booklet.
No. A scan will preserve the image, but handwriting recognition isn’t automatically reliable. Microsoft Support says that handwriting is rarely recognised using the Word method it describes. Check names, quantities and ingredients yourself.
Compare compatible ink, ink bottles or toner and, where relevant, a separate drum against your own print volume. For consumer purchases in the Netherlands, the statutory guarantee applies alongside any manufacturer’s guarantee. ACM ConsuWijzer also states that online purchases generally come with a 14-day cooling-off period from delivery, although exceptions may apply.
According to the Dutch government, you may make a private copy of copyright-protected books for your own use. You must not distribute or make that copy public, so the private-use exception doesn’t give you permission to share scans.