For a bound recipe booklet, use the scanner glass; an automatic document feeder (ADF) is designed for loose sheets and is no substitute. Canon recommends this approach for scanning books. Then choose based on how you print: cartridge printers may suit occasional colour printing, an ink tank may be better for regular colour printing, and a black-and-white laser printer is an option if you don't need colour prints. Also measure the space needed with the scanner lid open, and check which connection options and consumables are compatible with the exact model.
Who is this relevant to?
Student with bound recipe booklets
Wants to digitise booklets clearly without taking out the pages, and needs to consider the scanner glass and the space required to open the scanner lid. Canon recommends using the glass to scan thick originals, such as books.
Student who prints in colour regularly
Scans recipes and also regularly prints recipes or study materials in colour. For the ET-2950, Epson describes an ink tank system and the use of the scanner glass.
Student who rarely prints
Needs a scanner but prints very little, possibly only in black and white. The Consumers’ Association points out that when you print very rarely, a relatively large amount of ink may be used for cleaning.
What should you consider when choosing?
Colour inkjet with cartridges
Suitable for: occasional colour printing, when a lower purchase price matters more than the cost per page if you print frequently.
Bear in mind: compare the compatible cartridges; if you use it very little, an inkjet printer may use ink for cleaning.
Colour inkjet with refillable ink tanks
Suitable for: regular colour printing, if you can spread the higher purchase price over enough prints.
Bear in mind: even an inkjet printer may use ink for cleaning if you use it very little; manufacturers’ page-yield claims depend on the conditions.
Black-and-white laser printer
Suitable for: scanning booklets and mainly printing text in black and white, if you don't need colour prints.
Bear in mind: you can't print in colour; also check whether the toner and any separate drum need replacing.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Bound booklets |
Check that the exact model has scanner glass, that the booklet fits on it and that the lid can open where you plan to put the printer. |
If I want to scan recipe booklets without forcing the binding, having usable scanner glass is my priority. Around 39% of consumers in this situation prioritise scanning bound pages. |
| Printing costs |
Estimate how many black-and-white and colour pages you print each month, then compare the compatible cartridges, ink bottles, toner and any drum. |
If I want to match ongoing costs to how often I print, I compare the consumables for the amount I expect to print. Around 23% of consumers in this situation prioritise costs based on their own printing frequency. |
| Space and connectivity |
Measure the available space with the scanner lid open, and check Wi-Fi, Wi-Fi Direct or USB compatibility with the exact model and your devices. |
In a small student room, I want to know whether the printer will fit and connect to my devices. Around 23% of consumers in this situation prioritise space and connectivity. |
| Colour prints |
Check separately whether the model scans in colour and whether it prints in colour. |
If I want to print coloured recipes or study materials, I need a model that can print in colour. Around 15% of consumers in this situation prioritise the option to print in colour. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Confusing an ADF with a book scanner
An ADF feeds compatible loose sheets through the printer; a bound booklet needs to be placed on the scanner glass.
Check the scanner glass and make sure the booklet fits on it. Only factor in the ADF capacity if you also scan loose documents.
-
Comparing only the purchase price
The right printer also depends on what you print and how often. If you use an inkjet printer very little, it may use ink for cleaning.
Compare the consumables for the exact model with the amount you expect to print. Assess an ink tank based on your own needs, not just the manufacturer’s page-yield claims.
-
Assuming every connection will work at home
Wi-Fi and USB options vary by model. For models where HP+ is activated, HP lists additional requirements, including an HP account, a continuous internet connection and original HP ink for the life of the printer.
Before buying, check which connection you can use and read the terms that apply to the exact model and any activation.
Relevant brands to compare
Canon
Canon PIXMA colour inkjets such as the TR4755i and TS7750i combine scanning, copying and printing; the models mentioned also have an ADF for loose sheets.
- Canon lists an ADF for up to 20 A4 sheets and PG-575/CL-576 cartridges for the TR4755i; for the TS7750i, Canon lists an ADF for up to 35 single-sided sheets and PG-585/CL-586 cartridges.
- An ADF is designed for loose sheets and is no substitute for the scanner glass when scanning a bound booklet. The ADF capacities and cartridges mentioned are model-specific.
Epson
The EcoTank ET-2950 is a colour model with refillable ink tanks, suited to anyone who wants to scan booklets and print in colour regularly.
- Epson describes the ET-2950 as having refillable ink tanks; the model’s manual explains how to place originals on the scanner glass.
- Epson’s savings and page-yield claims are subject to the manufacturer’s conditions. If you use an inkjet printer very little, ink may be used for cleaning, as explained by the Consumers’ Association.
Brother
The Brother DCP-L2660DW is a black-and-white laser multifunction printer for anyone who wants to scan but doesn't need colour prints.
- Brother lists an ADF for up to 50 sheets, Wi-Fi, and separate toner and drum units for this model.
- The ADF is designed for loose sheets, not for feeding a bound booklet. You can't print in colour with this black-and-white model.
HP
The DeskJet 4220e is a colour inkjet to compare if printing, scanning and copying are important; the connections and terms mentioned apply to this model or the relevant HP+ activation.
- HP lists two cartridges, 2.4GHz Wi-Fi and USB for the 4220e.
- According to HP, activating HP+ requires original HP ink for the life of the printer, an HP account and a continuous internet connection. Check whether these terms apply to your model and how you plan to use it.
Joybuy products
These products are suited to scanning bound pages and, depending on the model, printing in colour occasionally or regularly. Check each model’s book-scanning capabilities.
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7305 All-in-One
Suitable for anyone who wants to digitise bound pages using a flatbed scanner and also print in colour.
Refillable ink tanks; colour scanning and printing; Wi-Fi, Wi-Fi Direct and USB; automatic double-sided printing.
Joybuy
No image available
Canon PIXMA MG2556S
A colour model for anyone who wants to print in colour occasionally as well as scan; check that the scanner and lid are suitable for a bound booklet.
Printing, scanning and copying; two cartridges; optional XL cartridges; USB 2.0.
Joybuy
No image available
Epson WorkForce Pro WF-C5390DW
A colour printer for anyone who also wants to print colour pages; bear in mind that you'll need a separate scanning solution for the recipe booklet.
A4 colour inkjet printer with Wi-Fi and automatic double-sided printing. The product description states that it weighs more than 15 kg and recommends lifting it with two people.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Should a recipe booklet go through the automatic document feeder?
No. Place a bound original on the scanner glass and scan the pages you need individually; use the ADF for compatible loose sheets. Canon recommends using the glass to scan books.
What if I mostly scan and rarely print?
Consider whether you need a printer as well as a scanner. If you use a cartridge inkjet printer very little, it may use a relatively large amount of ink for cleaning, as the Consumers’ Association points out. A black-and-white laser printer is only suitable if you don't need colour prints.
How can I avoid unexpected costs or problems after buying?
Check which cartridges, ink bottles or toner are compatible with the exact model, whether the drum is replaced separately, and whether any subscription terms apply. In the Netherlands, the seller must provide a solution if a product is faulty; a manufacturer’s warranty does not replace your statutory rights, according to the Dutch Government.
Can I scan and share recipes from a copyrighted book?
The Dutch Government says you may make a private copy for your own use, but you may not distribute it or make it publicly available. This applies to the private-copy use described here; consider other uses separately.