Carefully place fragile or bound stories on the flatbed glass, and use an automatic document feeder (ADF) mainly for suitable loose sheets. Choose an ADF that scans both sides only if you really need this feature: automatic double-sided printing does not mean that both sides are scanned automatically too.
Who is this relevant to?
People responsible for fragile originals
Digitising handwritten or bound stories where careful handling and checking the scan matter more than feeding paper through quickly. The National Archives describes quality control as part of the digitisation process.
Volunteers with piles of loose stories
Regularly processing several loose pages can benefit most from a suitable document feeder and a scan workflow that is easy to check. Make sure the feeder is suitable for the paper you want to scan.
Groups that also hand out copies
Scanning stories while also deciding between colour and black and white, and considering suitable refills. A black-and-white printer cannot print colour pages.
What should you look for when choosing?
First decide how to scan the originals safely and how often you process loose pages. Then consider copies and refills.
| What to consider |
What to look for when buying |
Who should pay extra attention? |
| Scanning originals carefully |
Check that the original fits on the flatbed and view a test scan to see if it is legible. |
If I’m digitising fragile or bound stories, I want to be able to position them carefully and check the image. Around 36% of consumers put preserving the original and keeping it legible first. |
| Processing loose pages |
Check the ADF capacity and whether it supports double-sided scanning. |
When we regularly process piles of suitable loose sheets, I want to spend less time feeding in or turning pages by hand. Around 29% of consumers prioritise processing loose pages. |
| Copies and refills |
Estimate the volume of colour and black-and-white printing, and compare the refills that are compatible with the model. |
If we hand out stories, I want to know whether we need colour copies and which consumables suit our usage. Around 21% of consumers put printing costs first. |
| Finding stories by searching the text |
Distinguish between a scan file and separate handwriting recognition, and plan to check any recognised text. |
When we want to search for words in stories later, an image alone is not enough and the text needs checking. Around 14% of consumers prioritise searchability. |
Common pitfalls
-
Confusing double-sided printing with double-sided scanning
Printing and scanning are separate functions. A printer can print on both sides automatically without automatically scanning both sides of a sheet.
Check the specifications for the exact model for double-sided scanning or a duplex ADF.
If the scanner processes only one side at a time, turning over and checking handwritten sheets takes extra time.
-
Using a document feeder for every old story
An ADF is designed for loose sheets; fragile, bound or unusual originals need to be assessed separately.
Sort the stories beforehand and assess fragile or bound items individually before placing them on the flatbed.
-
Looking only at the purchase price
The right running costs also depend on how many colour and black-and-white pages the group prints.
Compare the consumables for your expected volume, and don’t treat a stated page yield as guaranteed savings.
The Brother MFC-L2800DW model uses separate toner and drum consumables.
-
Publishing a scan or recognised text online straight away
Handwriting recognition can make mistakes. Stories may also contain personal information or work whose rights need to be assessed.
Check the transcription against the scan, and consider publication, access and rights before sharing files.
Checking the text and assessing publication and access takes time before files can be shared.
Brands to consider
Epson
The ET-4950 is an ink tank option for groups that print regularly as well as scan, and want to compare models with a duplex ADF.
- According to Epson, the ET-4950 supports double-sided scanning via the ADF.
- The ink savings and yield quoted by Epson do not calculate your group’s actual usage. Assess fragile originals individually before using an ADF.
Canon
The PIXMA TS7550i combines a flatbed with a single-sided ADF, while the MAXIFY GX4050 has refillable ink tanks.
- According to Canon, the TS7550i has an ADF for up to 35 sheets and two cartridges.
- The TS7550i’s ADF is single-sided. Double-sided printing or features of the MAXIFY GX4050 do not confirm that the PIXMA can scan both sides.
HP
The Smart Tank 7305 is an ink tank option with an ADF for groups that combine scanning with colour printing.
- HP lists a 35-sheet feeder, scanning to PDF and double-sided printing.
- Double-sided printing does not confirm that the device scans both sides. The ink yield quoted by HP is not a measure of your group’s usage.
Brother
The MFC-L2800DW is a black-and-white laser option with an ADF for groups that mainly print text copies.
- Brother lists a 50-sheet ADF and separate toner and drum consumables.
- This black-and-white model does not print colour pages. The stated toner yield is a manufacturer’s specification, not a guarantee of your group’s cost per page.
Joybuy product picks
Joybuy product picks related to this topic.
No image available
Canon PIXMA MG2556S
The listed features suit a group looking to combine printing, scanning and copying in one device.
A4 inkjet printer; the product name lists 4800 × 600 DPI.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Epson WorkForce Pro WF-C5390DW
Before buying, check whether this model also has a scanner if scanning the stories is essential.
A4 colour inkjet printer with automatic double-sided printing, Wi-Fi and Ethernet; the product name lists 4800 × 1200 DPI.
View at Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7305
The flatbed scanner lets you place originals individually; the ADF is intended for suitable loose sheets.
Colour printer with flatbed scanner and 35-sheet ADF; scanning to PDF is listed. Double-sided scanning is not available.
View at Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7005
The flatbed scanner is designed for originals you want to place individually; check that it suits the way your group handles stories.
Colour printer with flatbed scanner and scanning to PDF. No automatic document feeder is listed, and double-sided scanning is not available.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Does automatic double-sided printing mean the printer also scans both sides?
No. Check the scanning function separately from double-sided printing. Epson lists a duplex ADF for the ET-4950; Canon specifies a single-sided ADF for the PIXMA TS7550i.
How can you make scans of handwritten stories searchable later?
Keep an image of the page that you can check, and treat transcription as a separate step that needs reviewing. A scanner alone does not create reliable searchable text; handwriting recognition accuracy can depend on the style of handwriting.
What should the group agree on before use and as part of maintenance?
Agree who will position the originals, check scans for completeness and manage the files. When choosing a model, also compare the consumables that suit it and your expected print volume.
Can we put stories containing other people’s names online?
First consider personal information and rights; don’t assume you can publish without permission. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, information about other people may generally only be published online with their permission. Processing personal data requires a legal basis under the GDPR. Also check the creator’s rights before reproducing or making a protected story publicly available.