If you mainly print text lists, start with a black-and-white laser printer and compare the cost of toner and any drum, as well as the paper tray and connectivity. Choose a colour ink tank printer if you also regularly need colour printing, scanning or copying, bearing in mind the costs at your actual print volume. If the lists contain personal data, the school must also make sure that unauthorised people cannot access them.
Who is this printer choice for?
Teachers who mainly print text lists
You need clear A4 lists, without necessarily needing colour or scanning functions. The Dutch Consumers’ Association considers a black-and-white laser printer a sensible option when black-and-white printing is enough. Also compare paper feed and connectivity for your classroom.
Classrooms with ongoing printing costs
You print regularly and want to look beyond the printer itself: compare toner or ink, paper and any separate drum. Brother, for example, states that the HL-L2445DW uses a separate drum and toner cartridge.
Teams sharing a printer
Several staff members need to be able to print, so check that the connection is compatible with the school network. If the lists contain names, also discuss who can access print jobs and printouts. The Dutch Data Protection Authority classifies names as personal data and highlights the importance of appropriate security.
What should you look for when choosing?
Start with the tasks you actually need to do: printing text lists, how often you print, shared use and any colour or scanning tasks. A list containing names includes personal data; the Dutch Data Protection Authority emphasises that organisations must protect access to personal data.
| Consideration |
What should you check? |
Which consumers is this important for? |
| Text and availability |
Check A4 support, the paper tray, connectivity and whether you need automatic double-sided printing. |
If I mainly need clear A4 lists, I want paper feed and connectivity that suit the classroom. Around 36% of consumers prioritise having usable text lists available when they need them. |
| Ongoing running costs |
Estimate the number of pages and compare toner or ink, any drum and paper over the same period of use. |
If I print regularly, I want to compare the cost of consumables with the cost of the printer, rather than comparing purchase prices alone. Around 29% of consumers give ongoing running costs top priority. |
| Shared use and access |
Check Wi-Fi, Ethernet or USB compatibility with the school network. For lists containing names, also discuss who can access print jobs and printouts. |
If colleagues share the printer, I want connectivity that suits the workplace and clear rules on access to lists containing personal data. Around 21% of consumers prioritise shared printing with appropriate security. |
| Colour and extra features |
Decide whether you really need colour, scanning or copying, and check that the exact model supports those functions. |
If I want to print colour documents as well as sign-up lists, or need to scan paper documents, those extra features are important. Around 14% of consumers say colour or extra document functions are their main priority. |
Common pitfalls
-
Comparing purchase prices alone
The cost of regular printing also depends on the number of pages and the consumables you need. A low purchase price alone doesn’t tell you what it will cost to use the printer over a longer period.
Compare models using the same estimated page count and period of use. For the Brother HL-L2445DW, include both toner and the drum.
Allow for toner or ink and paper; some models also use a separate drum. Check the terms of any print subscription too.
-
Choosing a colour inkjet for almost exclusively text lists
If you don’t need colour or scanning, extra features may not be useful for the task. The Dutch Consumers’ Association explains that liquid ink can dry out when the printer is used infrequently, and cleaning can then use up ink.
Compare a black-and-white laser printer if you mainly print text. Choose an ink tank or colour printer if you genuinely need the extra features and they suit your print volume.
If you use the printer infrequently, cleaning may use extra ink. Bear this in mind when comparing an inkjet printer with a laser printer.
-
Assuming a shared printer means your printing process is secure
A network connection doesn’t determine who can read a printed list. Names are personal data, and the Dutch Data Protection Authority emphasises that organisations must prevent unauthorised access.
Discuss with the school who can access print jobs and printouts. Agree how lists containing personal data will be collected and stored, too.
Brands and models to compare
The features below apply to the models named, not automatically to every printer from the same brand.
Brother
The HL-L2400DWE and HL-L2445DW are black-and-white laser printers for A4 text documents.
- Brother says both models have Wi-Fi, automatic double-sided printing and a 250-sheet paper tray.
- The HL-L2445DW uses toner and a drum as separate consumables. Compare the replacement costs of both parts.
HP
The LaserJet M110w is a compact black-and-white printer for a small printing area.
- HP lists a print speed of up to 20 pages per minute for this model and says it is suitable for teams of up to three people.
- HP specifies dynamic security: cartridges with a non-HP chip may be blocked. Check refill options for this exact model.
Canon
The i-SENSYS LBP243dw II is a black-and-white printer worth comparing if network connectivity and paper feed are important.
- Canon specifies Ethernet and Wi-Fi, with a standard 250-sheet input tray and a 100-sheet multipurpose tray.
- The maximum capacity of 900 sheets requires an optional cassette. This model prints in black and white and has no built-in scanning function.
Epson
The EcoTank ET-2950 is an A4 ink tank printer for anyone who needs colour, scanning or copying as well as printing lists.
- Epson specifies refillable tanks and double-sided printing.
- The savings and page yields quoted by Epson are manufacturer claims subject to conditions; assess them against your own usage.
Joybuy products
This selection includes inkjet printers for different paper sizes and tasks. Check whether each model’s size and listed features suit the sign-up lists in your classroom.
No image available
Canon PIXMA MG2556S inkjet printer, A4, 4800 x 600 DPI
An A4 inkjet option for printing sign-up lists on A4 paper.
Specifications: A4; 4800 x 600 DPI.
Joybuy
No image available
Epson EcoTank ET-M16680 inkjet printer, A3, 4800 x 1200 DPI, Wi-Fi
An A3 inkjet option if you also want to print sign-up lists on A3 paper.
Specifications: A3; 4800 x 1200 DPI; Wi-Fi.
Joybuy
No image available
Epson WorkForce Pro WF-C5390DW colour inkjet printer, A4, 4800 x 1200 DPI, Wi-Fi
An A4 colour option for anyone who needs colour printouts as well as sign-up lists.
Specifications: colour; A4; 4800 x 1200 DPI; Wi-Fi.
Joybuy
No image available
Epson EcoTank ET-5185 inkjet printer, A4, 4800 x 1200 DPI, 37 ppm, Wi-Fi
An A4 inkjet option for sign-up lists if Wi-Fi suits your chosen workplace.
Specifications: A4; 4800 x 1200 DPI; 37 ppm; Wi-Fi.
Joybuy
No image available
HP Smart Tank 7005 wireless all-in-one colour printer
A colour option for anyone who wants to copy or scan as well as print.
Specifications: wireless; colour; double-sided printing; copying; scanning.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is a black-and-white printer enough for sign-up lists?
Yes, if the lists only need to be clear and readable and you don’t need colour, scanning or copying. If you do need those functions, compare a multifunction colour model.
What should you check before connecting a printer to the school network?
Check that the exact model’s connection is compatible with what the school provides. Canon lists Ethernet and Wi-Fi for the i-SENSYS LBP243dw II; Brother lists Wi-Fi and USB for the HL-L2400DWE. If the printer is shared, also agree who can access print jobs and printouts.
How can you keep the printer in working order if you don’t print every day?
With an inkjet printer, allow for possible cleaning and ink use when it is used infrequently. The Dutch Consumers’ Association explains that liquid ink can dry out and cause blockages; follow the instructions for your chosen model when carrying out maintenance.
Which consumables and service terms should you check?
Check which toner or ink is compatible with the model, whether it needs a separate drum and the terms of any print subscription. Brother says the HL-L2400DWE can be used without an EcoPro subscription; check the current terms before making your choice.
Can a school leave sign-up lists with names by a shared printer?
Not if that could give unauthorised people access to personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority classifies names as personal data and says organisations must protect access to it. The appropriate measures depend on the list’s contents and context; the printer model alone cannot guarantee this.