Who is powerline suitable for?

Participant at a fixed workstation

You’re joining the workshop from a computer with Ethernet on another floor and mainly want to know whether the connection there will be usable. ACM ConsuWijzer recommends measuring internet speed with a network cable, close to the connection point.

Participant working wirelessly

You’re using a laptop or tablet on a floor where the Wi-Fi signal is weak. You’ll need to assess both the powerline connection and the Wi-Fi where you’ll be taking part.

Participant using different floors

You want to take part from different floors and need to work out how many connection points you’ll need. If you’re expanding your setup, check that the adapters belong to the same compatible product family. For example, devolo states that Magic doesn’t work with dLAN or other HomePlug AV products.

What should you look for when choosing?

Powerline with Ethernet

Suitable if: you’re joining the workshop on a desktop computer with an Ethernet port.

Trade-off: an Ethernet-only adapter doesn’t provide Wi-Fi for a laptop or tablet.

Powerline with Wi-Fi

Suitable if: you’re taking part wirelessly on a floor where the existing Wi-Fi signal is weak.

Trade-off: both the connection through your electrical wiring and the Wi-Fi need to work where you’ll be using them.

Expandable powerline setup

Suitable if: you need a separate connection point on more than one out-of-the-way floor.

Trade-off: additional adapters must be compatible with your chosen product family; adding more adapters doesn’t remove the need to test each location.

Network cable to your workstation

Suitable if: you can run a cable to your workshop location safely and without too much hassle.

Trade-off: running a cable can be inconvenient, but it gives you a direct comparison with the connection at your workstation.

What to consider What should you check? Which consumers is this for?
Connection at the workshop location Test the adapters in the intended plug sockets and try a practice call there. I want to use video and audio during the workshop on the chosen floor, so I’ll test the connection where I’ll be sitting. Around 33% of consumers put a reliable workshop connection first.
Wi-Fi for taking part Check whether the receiving adapter provides Wi-Fi, and whether you also need an Ethernet port. I use a laptop, tablet or phone without a network cable and want to take part wirelessly. Around 27% of consumers make wireless use their top priority.
Connection points on multiple floors Count the receiving adapters you need and check that any extensions are compatible with the product family. I want a dedicated connection point on different floors and don’t want to assume that one receiving adapter will cover every location. Around 27% of consumers prioritise having multiple connection points.
Compatibility with an existing kit Compare the full model numbers and powerline standards of your existing and new adapters. I want to keep and expand my existing powerline setup, so I’ll first check whether the adapters work together. Around 13% of consumers make keeping their existing kit their top priority.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming the speed on the box is the speed you’ll get during the workshop

    TP-Link distinguishes between the advertised powerline rate and actual data throughput. Throughput can vary at the location where you plan to use the adapter.

    Only compare specifications when they’re stated on the same basis. Test the connection in the chosen plug socket and try video and audio during a practice call.

  • Assuming one receiving adapter will cover every floor

    A separate connection point on an additional floor requires a suitable adapter; a starter kit won’t automatically cover every location you need.

    Map out where your router is and each workshop location, then count how many receiving adapters you’ll need.

  • Choosing an extension based on the brand name alone

    devolo states that Magic adapters don’t work with dLAN or other HomePlug AV products.

    Before buying, check the full model numbers and the compatible product family for both your existing and new adapters.

Brands to consider

TP-Link

TP-Link describes its powerline products as Ethernet kits and Wi-Fi powerline kits; the TL-WPA7517 KIT is a Wi-Fi powerline kit.

  • The manufacturer describes the TL-WPA7517 KIT as offering both wired and wireless connections.
  • The advertised powerline rate isn’t the same as actual throughput. Also check the exact hardware version.

devolo

devolo offers Magic products with LAN and Wi-Fi extensions, including a multi-room kit for multiple floors.

  • According to devolo, a Magic setup can be expanded with compatible Magic adapters.
  • devolo states that Magic isn’t compatible with dLAN or other HomePlug AV products. Test the connection at each location.

FRITZ!

FRITZ! describes the FRITZ!Powerline 1260 Set as combining powerline, Wi-Fi and Gigabit LAN.

  • The manufacturer lists both Wi-Fi and a Gigabit LAN connection.
  • Advertised speeds are manufacturer maximums, not measurements of the connection between your floors. Check which features will work with your network.

NETGEAR

NETGEAR describes the PLP2000 as a wired HomePlug AV2 kit.

  • According to the product specifications, each adapter has two Gigabit Ethernet ports and a pass-through socket.
  • The product specifications don’t list Wi-Fi. The advertised 2,000 Mbit/s isn’t a measured workshop speed.

Powerline products on Joybuy

This selection includes powerline options for a workshop location on another floor, with a choice of wireless or wired use. When buying, check the exact model and its CE marking.

TP-Link TL-WPA7517 KIT powerline adapter starter kit

TP-Link TL-WPA7517 KIT

Designed for a wireless workshop location on another floor. Check that the exact model on offer includes Wi-Fi and the Ethernet port you need.

Also check the CE marking on the model you’re planning to buy.

View on Joybuy
TP-Link TL-PA4015P KIT 500 Mbit/s Ethernet LAN, pack of 2

TP-Link TL-PA4015P KIT, 500 Mbit/s, 2 units

Suitable for a desktop computer you want to connect by cable at the receiving end. The product name lists 500 Mbit/s and two adapters; this isn’t a measurement of the actual throughput at your plug sockets.

The product information lists Ethernet. If you want to take part wirelessly, check that you also have Wi-Fi on that floor. Before buying, check the CE marking on the exact model.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I get a separate connection point on three floors with one starter kit?

Count the receiving adapters you need; the number of floors mentioned in a product claim doesn’t, by itself, tell you how many connection points the kit provides. You may need a compatible extra adapter or a multi-room kit for separate locations. devolo lists three adapters for the Magic 2 WiFi 6 next Multiroom Kit.

How do I install and test the kit before the workshop?

Follow the manufacturer’s installation instructions, connect the adapter by your router using Ethernet, then test the other adapter in the intended plug socket. Also test video and audio at your workstation. ACM ConsuWijzer recommends measuring internet speeds at several different times and using a cable close to the connection point.

What internet speed do I need for a virtual workshop?

This depends in part on the workshop platform and whether you’ll be streaming video yourself. Zoom lists 2.6 Mbit/s upload and 1.8 Mbit/s download for group video calls. These are requirements for this Zoom feature, not a general standard for every workshop and not a guarantee of your powerline connection.

What if the kit doesn’t work well at home or develops a fault early?

For an online consumer purchase, ACM ConsuWijzer says you’ll generally have a statutory 14-day cooling-off period after delivery. You’re also covered by the statutory guarantee: if a product develops a fault sooner than could reasonably be expected under normal use, the seller must resolve the issue free of charge, according to ACM ConsuWijzer.

What should I look out for when it comes to product safety in the Netherlands?

The Dutch government states that electrical appliances placed on the EU market must have a CE marking. Check the marking and product information for the exact model on offer; a product listing on its own doesn’t confirm that the model meets this requirement.