Who is powerline suitable for?

Student with a dedicated study space

You want to download course files on another floor and can connect your laptop or dock via Ethernet. TP-Link Netherlands describes the TL-PA7017 KIT as a powerline starter kit with an Ethernet connection.

Student with several wireless devices

As well as your laptop, you use a tablet or phone at your study space and want Wi-Fi there. TP-Link Netherlands lists Wi-Fi as a feature of the TL-WPA7517 KIT V2.

Resident with an existing powerline network

You want to connect another floor without choosing an adapter that isn’t compatible with your existing network. devolo Netherlands distinguishes between Magic and dLAN or other HomePlug AV adapters.

Which buying concerns should you consider?

Wired powerline starter kit

Choose this when: you mainly study in one fixed location and your laptop or dock has an Ethernet port.

Trade-off: this setup doesn’t provide Wi-Fi at your study space; the stated powerline speed isn’t a guaranteed download speed.

Powerline starter kit with Wi-Fi

Choose this when: you also want to use wireless devices upstairs.

Trade-off: check the exact version and Wi-Fi features; the connection over your mains wiring still depends on the electrical route.

Extend an existing Magic network

Choose this when: there’s already a devolo Magic adapter by your router and you need another connection point.

Trade-off: devolo Magic doesn’t form a shared powerline network with dLAN or other HomePlug AV adapters.

Ethernet cable or another way to extend your network

Choose this when: you can run a cable to your study space, or powerline doesn’t work well enough through the sockets you plan to use for your downloads.

Trade-off: running a cable involves installation work; a wireless extender needs a usable wireless connection.

The breakdown below looks at consumers considering powerline across multiple floors to download study materials.

Consideration What to look for when buying Who is this important to?
Connection between floors Test the connection using the sockets you plan to use, and compare the download speed with what you need. If I want to download course files upstairs, I need to know whether the connection will be usable there. Around 36% of consumers prioritise range.
Ethernet or Wi-Fi at your study space Check whether your laptop or dock has Ethernet and whether the receiving adapter offers Wi-Fi for other devices. For my choice, it matters whether only a fixed laptop needs a connection or whether a phone or tablet does too. Around 29% of consumers prioritise having the right connection for their devices.
Compatibility with existing adapters Check the model and powerline standard of the adapter by your router before choosing an extension. If there’s already powerline in my home, I want an extension that works with those adapters. Around 21% of consumers prioritise compatibility.
Socket and connected device Check that you have a free wall socket and, for a pass-through model, that its load rating is suitable for the connected device. With few sockets available, I want to keep one free for another device. Around 14% of consumers give keeping a socket available top priority.

Common powerline pitfalls

  • Assuming AV1000 or AV2000 is a guaranteed download speed

    TP-Link explains that the stated powerline speed is a maximum and doesn’t equal the actual data throughput. Your electrical wiring can affect the connection.

    Test the download speed on the floor where you plan to use it, and check the connection between your laptop and the adapter too.

  • Buying a single Magic adapter for a HomePlug AV network

    devolo says that Magic doesn’t work as a powerline connection with dLAN or other HomePlug AV adapters.

    Check the model of the adapter by your router. Without a compatible Magic pair, you’ll need a compatible adapter at both ends of the connection.

    If you don’t already have a compatible adapter by your router, you may need a complete compatible kit rather than just an extra adapter.

  • Choosing a wired kit when you need Wi-Fi upstairs

    A wired connection is only useful for devices you can connect via Ethernet; according to TP-Link, the TP-Link TL-WPA7517 KIT V2 also has Wi-Fi.

    Decide in advance which devices need a connection at your study space, and check whether they connect via Ethernet or Wi-Fi.

  • Confusing a pass-through socket with a fix for poor wiring

    A pass-through socket keeps an electrical connection available, but it doesn’t guarantee a good powerline connection between floors or circuits.

    Choose a pass-through model if you need to keep a socket free, and test the network connection separately.

Brands to compare

TP-Link

TP-Link Netherlands offers wired powerline kits, models with a pass-through socket and kits with Wi-Fi, including the TL-PA7017 KIT, TL-PA7017P KIT and TL-WPA7517 KIT V2.

  • The models offer different connection options. For the AV1000 kits mentioned, TP-Link lists a powerline speed of up to 1000 Mbit/s.
  • That speed isn’t a guaranteed download speed. OneMesh on the TL-WPA7517 KIT V2 requires a compatible TP-Link OneMesh router.

devolo

devolo describes Magic as a G.hn powerline range; the Magic 1 LAN Starter Kit includes two adapters for a wired setup.

  • According to devolo, a Magic network can be extended using compatible Magic adapters.
  • Magic doesn’t work as a shared powerline network with dLAN or other HomePlug AV adapters. Manufacturer information about coverage can’t predict how the connection will perform in a particular home.

NETGEAR

NETGEAR Netherlands describes the PLP2000 as a wired HomePlug AV2 option with a pass-through socket and two gigabit Ethernet ports per adapter.

  • The extra Ethernet port can be useful at a fixed location with more than one wired device.
  • The stated 2000 Mbit/s isn’t a measured download speed. NETGEAR recommends using sockets on the same electrical circuit for the best results.

Powerline products at Joybuy

This selection includes powerline starter kits for a dedicated Ethernet connection, as well as models with Wi-Fi for devices at your study space.

TP-Link TL-WPA7517 KIT powerline adapter kit

TP-Link TL-WPA7517 KIT

For a study space where you want Wi-Fi for wireless devices as well as downloads.

The product description lists a Type E plug and an internal antenna.

View at Joybuy
TP-Link TL-WPA7617 KIT powerline adapter kit, 1200 Mbit/s

TP-Link TL-WPA7617 KIT, 1200 Mbit/s

For a study space where you want to use Wi-Fi as well as an Ethernet connection.

The product title lists 1200 Mbit/s, Ethernet and Wi-Fi, and a pack of 2. The stated speed doesn’t guarantee the actual download speed.

View at Joybuy
TP-Link TL-PA4015P KIT powerline starter kit, 500 Mbit/s

TP-Link TL-PA4015P KIT, 500 Mbit/s

For a dedicated study space where you want a wired connection and to keep a socket available.

According to the product description, the kit contains two adapters, each with a 10/100 Mbit/s Fast Ethernet port and an integrated socket. The stated powerline speed isn’t a guaranteed download speed.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need one or two adapters to download upstairs?

For a new powerline connection, you need at least two compatible adapters: one by the router and one at your study space. A single expansion adapter may be enough if there’s already a compatible adapter by the router.

Will powerline work between different floors and electrical circuits?

That depends on your electrical wiring. NETGEAR recommends using sockets on the same circuit for the best results, while Zyxel warns that unfavourable conditions can reduce speeds or interrupt the connection. So test the sockets you plan to use.

Can I connect a Magic adapter to an existing HomePlug AV network?

No. devolo says that Magic and dLAN or other HomePlug AV products don’t form a shared powerline network. Check the standard used by the adapter near your router before buying an extension.

What can I do if downloads are slow upstairs?

First, test the connection using the sockets you plan to use and check whether electrical equipment could be interfering with it. Also check the Ethernet connection between your laptop and adapter, and your internet connection; a higher figure on the packaging doesn’t in itself prove you’ll get faster downloads.

Can I plug a powerline adapter into an extension lead?

Follow the instructions for the model you choose. The TP-Link manual for the TL-PA4010/TL-PA411 says to plug the adapter directly into a wall socket and advises against using an extension lead, extension cable or surge protector; check the instructions for your adapter.