Who is powerline in the loft suitable for?

Loft worker with a desktop PC

Regularly shares project files and mainly wants an Ethernet connection for a fixed workstation. The transfer speed at the sockets you plan to use is what matters. TP-Link explains that the stated powerline speed is not the same as actual throughput.

Workstation with several devices

For example, wants to connect a computer and network storage by cable. Check how many LAN ports the adapter has and whether the kit is compatible with the powerline technology used by your existing adapters. devolo says that Magic adapters cannot be used to extend an existing dLAN network.

Loft worker with a laptop

Needs wireless coverage as well as any wired connections. Check that the kit offers Wi-Fi; a LAN-only kit will not create a wireless network.

What should you look for when choosing?

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
File transfer Test file transfers between your devices using the sockets you plan to use; don’t treat the AV rating as guaranteed throughput. If I share large project files, I want to know what speeds the connection achieves at my own sockets. Around 40% of consumers put actual file transfer speeds first.
Electrical wiring Plug the adapters directly into the wall sockets you intend to use and test the connection there. I want to find out whether powerline works with the loft sockets first, without assuming in advance that the electrical wiring is suitable or unsuitable. For around 30% of consumers, this is their main priority.
LAN ports and existing adapters Count the devices you want to connect by cable and check the model and technology of your existing adapters. If I want to connect several devices by cable, the number of ports needs to be right and the kit needs to work with my existing network. Around 20% of consumers prioritise these connections and compatibility.
Wi-Fi in the loft Check whether the kit actually includes a Wi-Fi adapter and which hardware version is being offered. If my laptop also needs a wireless connection, I’ll look for a Wi-Fi model rather than a LAN-only one. Around 10% of consumers prioritise wireless coverage in the loft.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming the AV rating is the file transfer speed

    The stated powerline speed is not the actual throughput you’ll get when transferring project files. So a higher rating doesn’t tell you what speeds you’ll achieve using the sockets in your loft.

    Test file transfers between the devices you plan to use before choosing a kit based on a higher speed rating.

  • Plugging an adapter into an extension lead

    An extension lead or surge protector can weaken the powerline signal.

    Where possible, plug the adapter directly into a wall socket. If you need to keep a socket free, see whether a model with a passthrough socket would suit you.

  • Buying an add-on adapter without checking the technology

    devolo says that Magic and dLAN adapters are not compatible with each other as part of the same powerline network.

    Make a note of the full model number of your existing adapters and check compatibility before choosing an add-on.

Brands to consider

TP-Link

The range in the Netherlands includes wired HomePlug AV2 starter kits and a Wi-Fi powerline kit to suit different connection needs in the loft.

  • According to TP-Link, the TL-PA7017 KIT has one gigabit port; the TL-PA7017P KIT also includes a passthrough socket.
  • The Dutch product specifications for the TL-WPA7517 KIT V2 list dual-band Wi-Fi.
  • The stated speed rating doesn’t tell you what file transfer speeds you’ll get on your own electrical wiring. For a Wi-Fi model, also check the hardware version of the model being offered.

devolo

The Magic range includes, among other options, a LAN starter kit and a triple-adapter model for connecting several devices by cable.

  • According to devolo, the Magic 2 LAN triple adapter has three gigabit ports.
  • devolo says that Magic adapters are not designed to extend an existing dLAN network.
  • The number of ports and the product name don’t predict the file transfer speeds you’ll get using the sockets in your home.

NETGEAR

The powerline range in the Netherlands includes Wi-Fi models and models with a passthrough socket.

  • NETGEAR recommends plugging powerline adapters directly into wall sockets.
  • NETGEAR highlights electrical interference as something to consider; its product information is not an independent comparison of file transfer speeds between brands.

Joybuy products

These Joybuy products are designed for a powerline workstation in the loft: a kit with Wi-Fi or a wired kit with a passthrough socket.

TP-Link TL-WPA7517 KIT powerline adapter kit

TP-Link TL-WPA7517 KIT

Suitable for a workstation where you want Wi-Fi as well as a wired connection; the product description lists powerline, wired networking and wireless networking support.

Check the hardware version of the model on offer before buying. The specifications for version V2 may not apply to every version. The stated powerline speed doesn’t guarantee a particular file transfer speed, so test the kit using the wall sockets you intend to use.

Check the CE marking and product information for the exact model.

Joybuy
TP-Link TL-PA4015P KIT powerline kit, 500 Mbit/s, pack of 2

TP-Link TL-PA4015P KIT, 500 Mbit/s, pack of 2

Suitable for a single, fixed wired workstation where you want a powerline kit with a passthrough socket.

The product description lists one Ethernet port per adapter and an integrated socket. The Ethernet ports are Fast Ethernet (10/100 Mbit/s), which limits the wired connection when transferring large files. The stated powerline speed doesn’t guarantee a particular file transfer speed, so test the kit using the wall sockets you intend to use.

Check the CE marking and product information for the exact model.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is AV1000 the speed at which your project files will be copied?

No. TP-Link describes the stated powerline speed as the maximum speed of the physical connection, not its actual throughput. Test file transfers using your own sockets; the result won’t tell you what speeds you’ll get in another property.

Do both adapters need to be on the same electrical circuit?

Don’t rely on the circuit number alone; test the sockets you plan to use. TP-Link explains that a connection can weaken or be blocked when it passes through different parts of the electrical installation.

Can you add devolo Magic to your existing dLAN adapters?

Not to extend the same powerline network. According to devolo, Magic and dLAN use different technologies and are not compatible with each other.

What should you look for in a powerline kit with Wi-Fi?

Check that the kit actually offers Wi-Fi and find out which hardware version is being offered. TP-Link lists the Wi-Fi specifications for the TL-WPA7517 KIT V2; don’t assume that the same specifications apply to every hardware version.

What product safety requirements apply to a powerline adapter in the Netherlands?

According to the Dutch government, electronic devices placed on the market in the EU must meet the applicable product requirements and carry the required CE marking. Check the marking and product information for the exact model; a CE logo alone is not a performance test.