Powerline is an option if running a network cable to the archive is difficult, but the actual connection depends on the electrical wiring and needs to be tested in the club building. Choose multiple LAN ports for several wired devices, Wi-Fi if members need wireless access there, and consider a standard network cable if running one is practical or if powerline does not perform well enough when used by several people at once.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Administrator with people accessing the archive at the same time
You want several people to be able to open files at the same time. Test the connection in the club building with real archive use: the quoted speed does not tell you how quickly files will transfer there. ID.nl and TP-Link point out that actual powerline performance depends in part on the connection and the electrical wiring.
Administrator of wired archive devices
You need more than one wired connection by the archive, for example for a computer and a storage device. Count the devices and check how many LAN ports there are on the adapter that will go by the archive.
Members who need wireless access to the archive
You also need Wi-Fi in the archive room for laptops or phones. A wired powerline kit does not automatically provide a wireless access point there, so check whether the Wi-Fi version provides a wireless connection in that location.
What should you look for in powerline for your archive?
Powerline with multiple LAN ports
Choose this if: several fixed devices need a direct wired connection by the archive.
Bear in mind: a wired version does not automatically provide Wi-Fi, and multiple ports do not increase the capacity of the shared powerline connection.
Powerline with Wi-Fi
Choose this if: members mainly need wireless access in the archive room using laptops or phones.
Bear in mind: wireless users share the underlying powerline connection; also check how many fixed devices you can connect.
A standard network cable
Choose this if: running a cable is practical, or a test shows that powerline does not perform well enough when several people access the archive at once.
Bear in mind: running a cable can involve more work, but it removes powerline as an intermediary.
| Concern |
What to check before buying |
Who should prioritise this? |
| Performance when used by several people at once |
Try the intended sockets and archive tasks with several users. TP-Link distinguishes between the quoted maximum powerline speed and actual throughput. |
If several members open files at the same time, I want to know how the connection holds up in real use. Around 29% of consumers in this club scenario prioritise performance when used by several people at once. |
| Wired connections |
Count the devices and check the ports on the adapter that will go by the archive. TP-Link and devolo list three Gigabit LAN ports on the relevant adapters in the kits mentioned. |
If I have a computer and a storage device by the archive, and both need a wired connection, having enough ports matters. Around 23% of consumers prioritise connections for several fixed devices. |
| Wi-Fi by the archive |
Check whether the adapter at the archive location is the one that provides Wi-Fi. TP-Link describes the TL-WPA7517 KIT as a Wi-Fi version with one Gigabit Ethernet port as well. |
If members use laptops or phones there, I want to know whether they can get online wirelessly. Around 18% of consumers give top priority to Wi-Fi by the archive. |
| Expanding with existing adapters |
Note down the full model numbers and the technology used. devolo says that Magic adapters do not work with dLAN; TP-Link says that G.hn adapters are not compatible with HomePlug AV/AV2. |
If I want to expand the club’s kit, an additional adapter needs to work with the existing equipment. Around 18% of consumers prioritise this compatibility. |
| Access to archive data |
If the archive contains personal data, decide who needs access and which security measures are appropriate. The Dutch Data Protection Authority stresses that organisations must protect personal data properly and prevent unauthorised access. |
If the club archive contains personal data, I want to prevent unauthorised people from viewing it. Around 12% of consumers in this situation prioritise protecting archive data. |
Common powerline pitfalls
-
Assuming the speed on the box is guaranteed archive speed
The quoted powerline speed is not the same as the actual file transfer rate. The quality of the electrical wiring affects performance, and several users share the connection to the archive.
Before the club relies on it, test opening and transferring representative files at the intended location with several users at once.
-
Assuming three LAN ports mean three separate connections to the router
The ports let you connect devices, but their data still travels over the shared powerline connection.
Count the ports you need and test the connection as a whole. Choose Wi-Fi only if users also need wireless access there.
-
Plugging a powerline adapter into an extension lead
According to TP-Link, extension leads and surge protectors can filter or block the powerline signal.
Plug the adapter into a wall socket. If you also need that socket for other equipment, check whether a version with a pass-through socket would suit you.
-
Choosing an extra adapter based on brand name or speed alone
Powerline adapters do not all use the same technology. For example, devolo says that Magic does not work with dLAN, while TP-Link says that G.hn is not compatible with HomePlug AV/AV2.
Check the full model numbers and compatibility information for your existing kit before expanding it.
An extra adapter that is not compatible may mean you need a different starter kit instead.
Brands to consider
TP-Link
The TL-PA8033P KIT is a wired option with multiple ports; the TL-WPA7517 KIT adds Wi-Fi for the archive room.
- According to TP-Link Netherlands, the relevant adapter in the TL-PA8033P KIT has three Gigabit ports.
- According to TP-Link Netherlands, the TL-WPA7517 KIT provides Wi-Fi and one Gigabit Ethernet port.
- These differences between models do not predict the speed the connection will achieve in the club building.
devolo
The Magic 2 LAN triple Starter Kit is a wired option for connecting several fixed devices by the archive.
- devolo lists three Gigabit LAN ports on the relevant adapter and says it can be expanded within the Magic range.
- devolo says that dLAN adapters are not supported; check your existing equipment before expanding the kit.
- The quoted speed is not a measured file transfer rate in the club building.
FRITZ!
According to the manufacturer, the FRITZ!Powerline 1220 Set is designed for a wired setup with multiple connections on each adapter.
- FRITZ! lists two Gigabit LAN ports per adapter.
- Check that the number of connections suits the fixed devices at the archive location.
MERCUSYS
The MP500 KIT V2 is a wired starter kit for a setup where one connection by the archive is enough.
- MERCUSYS lists one Gigabit port and compatibility with HomePlug AV and AV2.
- You will need extra connections if you want to connect several fixed devices there.
- The stated maximum speed is not a guaranteed file transfer rate.
Joybuy product selection
This product selection focuses on a wired powerline connection over the existing electrical wiring between the router and the club archive.
No image available
TP-Link TL-PA4015P KIT 500 Mbit/s, 2 adapters
A wired powerline kit for creating a network connection between locations over the existing electrical wiring.
The kit contains two adapters. Each adapter has one Fast Ethernet port (10/100 Mbit/s), not a Gigabit port.
The quoted maximum powerline speed of 500 Mbit/s does not guarantee the actual file transfer rate in the club building.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
How can you test powerline before the club relies on it?
Plug one adapter into a wall socket by the router and the other into a wall socket by the archive, pair them according to the product instructions, then try real archive tasks with several users. TP-Link warns that extension leads and surge protectors can filter or block the signal; the quality of the building’s wiring also plays a part.
Can you simply add a new adapter to the club’s existing kit?
No. First check the full model numbers and the technology used. devolo says that Magic does not work with dLAN; TP-Link says that G.hn adapters are not compatible with HomePlug AV/AV2. Also check whether you need a complete starter kit rather than a separate expansion adapter.
What should you check about service and warranty when buying for your club?
Check whether the package contains a complete starter kit or just an expansion adapter, and review the terms and warranty that apply to the actual buyer. Ondernemersplein distinguishes between consumer rights and business sales, so do not assume that consumer rules automatically apply to a purchase made by the club.
Which privacy rules apply to an online club archive?
If the archive contains personal data, the club must protect it appropriately and prevent unauthorised access. Decide who needs access and which measures are appropriate for the processing involved; a powerline adapter does not control who can view individual archive files.