Who is powerline suitable for?

Manager of a fixed archive computer

Wants to connect a single wired device to the existing network from the club workspace. The connection through the sockets you plan to use needs to be reliable enough for the job.

Team with wireless laptops

Needs Wi-Fi in the shared space, so checks whether the powerline kit itself broadcasts a wireless signal.

Workspace with several wired devices

Wants to connect, for example, a computer and another network device, and checks how many Ethernet ports the adapter has.

What should you look for?

First, decide which devices need a wired or wireless connection. Then check that the existing setup and any powerline adapters you already have are compatible with the kit you choose.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Connection to a fixed computer Test the connection between the sockets you plan to use and check that the adapter has an Ethernet port. If I’m connecting one fixed computer by the archive, I want to know whether the connection works there. Around 33% of consumers prioritise wired access to the archive.
Wi-Fi for laptops Check whether the kit includes a Wi-Fi adapter; a wired kit doesn’t automatically provide a Wi-Fi access point. Built-in Wi-Fi is important if team members need to work wirelessly in the workspace on their laptops. Around 25% of consumers give wireless access their top priority.
Multiple connections Count the Ethernet ports you need and check whether you want a pass-through socket. If a computer and other devices need to be connected by cable at the same time, I want enough ports without having to buy extra equipment. Around 25% of consumers say multiple wired connections are their main requirement.
Existing setup and adapters Make a note of the models and technology used by your existing adapters, and try the kit in the sockets you intend to use. If you want to add to your existing adapters, check beforehand that the technologies are compatible. Around 17% of consumers make compatibility their main reason for buying.

Common purchasing mistakes

  • Assuming the stated powerline speed is guaranteed at the archive

    Your actual connection also depends on the electrical wiring and the environment. A product specification therefore won’t tell you what speed you’ll get in the club workspace.

    Test the connection between the sockets you plan to use, with the devices and archive tasks you’re buying the kit for.

  • Choosing a wired kit when the workspace needs Wi-Fi

    Powerline models vary in the connections they offer. A model with Ethernet only won’t provide Wi-Fi automatically.

    Decide in advance which devices need wireless access and which need a wired connection, then check that the kit has the Wi-Fi features you require.

  • Assuming an adapter will automatically work with your existing system

    Compatibility isn’t a given. For example, devolo states that Magic 2 LAN cannot be extended with adapters from the dLAN range.

    Make a note of the full model names of your existing adapters and check the stated compatibility before choosing an extension.

  • Confusing a network connection with access management for the archive

    A powerline connection doesn’t determine who can view or edit files.

    If the archive contains personal data, manage access permissions and secure the archive system separately from the network connection.

Brands to compare

TP-Link

The range includes wired powerline kits, Wi-Fi kits and models with several Ethernet ports. The type of connection is therefore a useful point of comparison.

  • According to TP-Link, the TL-PA7017 KIT has one gigabit port, the TL-WPA7517 KIT combines Wi-Fi with Ethernet, and the TL-PA8033P KIT has three gigabit ports.
  • These are model specifications, not measurements of the connection in a club building. Test the setup where you plan to use it.

devolo

The Magic range is worth considering if you want to expand an existing Magic system; the Magic 2 LAN Starter Kit is a wired option in the range.

  • devolo states that its Magic range can be expanded with additional adapters.
  • devolo says that Magic adapters are not compatible with the dLAN range. Don’t treat the two systems as interchangeable when choosing an extension.

Strong

The Powerline 1000 V2 Duo EU is a wired HomePlug AV2 kit with two adapters and a pass-through socket.

  • Strong states that each adapter has one gigabit port and a maximum rated speed of 1000 Mbps.
  • The stated range applies within the same electrical circuit; the maximum rated speed doesn’t guarantee a particular speed at the archive.

D-Link

The DHP-P601AV is a wired HomePlug AV2 kit with a pass-through socket.

  • D-Link lists a gigabit port and a filtered pass-through socket for this model.
  • D-Link marks revision B as ‘End of Sale’. Check the product and service information before considering this revision as a new purchase.

Powerline products at Joybuy

These products are suited to powerline access in a shared workspace: a kit with Wi-Fi for wireless laptops and a wired kit for a single device.

TP-Link TL-WPA7517 KIT powerline kit with Wi-Fi

TP-Link TL-WPA7517 KIT

Suitable if laptops in the shared workspace need Wi-Fi and you also want a wired connection.

TP-Link lists dual-band Wi-Fi and one gigabit Ethernet port for this model. Test the powerline connection using the sockets you plan to use; the stated data transfer speed doesn’t guarantee the speed you’ll get at the archive.

View at Joybuy
TP-Link TL-PA4015P KIT powerline kit, 500 Mbit/s, twin pack

TP-Link TL-PA4015P KIT 500 Mbit/s, pack of 2

Suitable for a setup with one fixed wired device at the workspace.

The product name states 500 Mbit/s. The Ethernet ports are Fast Ethernet (10/100 Mbit/s), not gigabit. Check that this suits the connection you need, and test the powerline connection using the sockets you plan to use.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do you connect a powerline kit to the archive computer?

Connect one adapter to the router using Ethernet and plug the other in near the workspace. Pair them according to the instructions; TP-Link recommends using wall sockets rather than extension leads. Check the indicator lights and, if needed, try a different wall socket.

Can you extend an existing devolo dLAN adapter with Magic 2 LAN?

No. According to devolo, Magic 2 LAN can be extended with adapters from the Magic range, but not with adapters from the dLAN range. Check the full model names of your existing setup before choosing an extension.

Is a powerline adapter enough to secure a membership archive containing personal data?

No. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that organisations must protect personal data appropriately and determine and document access permissions. A powerline adapter doesn’t manage access to the archive; the measures you need depend on the processing involved and the risks.