Who is powerline suitable for?

Manager of a multi-floor archive

Needs to provide a reliable connection on several floors and takes account of the number of connection points and workstations.

Volunteer looking for wireless access

Wants to access the archive from another floor using a laptop, phone or tablet, and needs Wi-Fi there—not just an Ethernet port.

Manager of existing adapters

Wants to add an archive location, so first checks that a new adapter is compatible with the existing powerline network.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, work out how many floors need a connection and whether users on each floor need Wi-Fi or a wired connection. Also check that the product carries the CE mark: the Dutch Authority for Digital Infrastructure states that electrical and electronic equipment must carry the correct CE marking.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Connection between floors Test the connection on every floor where it’s needed, using the wall socket you plan to use. NETGEAR recommends plugging an adapter directly into a wall socket. If I want the archive to be accessible on every required floor, I’ll first test the locations where the adapters will go. Around 36% of consumers put a connection between floors first.
Wi-Fi for mobile users Check whether the receiving adapter provides Wi-Fi and which floors need a wireless access point. If volunteers access the archive on their phones or tablets, I’ll need Wi-Fi on that floor. Around 29% of consumers make wireless access their top priority.
Connections for fixed workstations Count the wired devices on each floor and compare this with the number of Ethernet ports on the receiving adapter. If a desktop computer is used to access the archive, I’ll want to know whether it can be connected directly. Around 21% of consumers prioritise having the right Ethernet ports.
Access to archive data If the archive contains personal data, assess access rights and security separately from your choice of adapter. If the archive contains personal data, I’ll want to make sure a network connection isn’t treated as access security in itself. Around 14% of consumers prioritise protecting archive data.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming the stated powerline speed is the actual throughput

    TP-Link explains that the speed shown on the packaging is the maximum physical-layer speed, not the guaranteed throughput at the archive computer. The electrical wiring and interference can affect the connection.

    Test the connection on the floors where the archive will be used, with the devices and files the club needs.

  • Choosing a two-adapter kit for several archive locations

    A basic kit connects the router to one receiving location. You’ll need compatible additional adapters for other locations.

    Before buying, count the floors and workstations that need a connection at the same time.

    Expanding your setup may require extra adapters that are compatible with the existing range.

  • Assuming Magic and dLAN are interchangeable

    According to devolo, Magic doesn’t work with dLAN or other HomePlug AV products. An adapter from the wrong range won’t be a suitable addition.

    Make a note of the full model names and check the standard used by your existing adapters before expanding your setup.

    Choosing the wrong adapter could mean you still need to buy a different compatible adapter or kit.

  • Assuming Ethernet provides Wi-Fi on the archive floor

    An Ethernet port won’t, by itself, provide wireless access for phones and tablets.

    Work out which devices will access the archive on each floor, and choose Wi-Fi there if those devices need a wireless connection.

    You may need a Wi-Fi adapter or a separate access point to provide Wi-Fi on that floor.

Brands to consider

TP-Link

The range includes wired HomePlug AV2 kits and Wi-Fi kits, such as the TL-PA7017P KIT and TL-WPA7517 KIT.

  • According to the product specifications, the TL-PA7017P KIT has one Gigabit port and a pass-through socket; the TL-WPA7517 KIT adds Wi-Fi on the receiving adapter.
  • Check which hardware version of the kit is on offer. The model specifications don’t guarantee a connection from the sockets in your club building.

devolo

The Magic range includes LAN and Wi-Fi adapters, as well as kits for extending your setup to more rooms.

  • According to devolo, Magic LAN and Wi-Fi adapters can be combined within the Magic range.
  • The manufacturer states that Magic doesn’t work with dLAN or other HomePlug AV products. Check which range your existing adapters belong to before expanding your setup.

FRITZ!

The powerline range includes wired and Wi-Fi kits, including the 1220 Set and 1260 WLAN Set.

  • FRITZ! lists two Gigabit LAN ports per device for the 1220 Set and Wi-Fi for the 1260 WLAN Set.
  • These features apply to the kits mentioned; don’t assume every FRITZ! adapter has the same ports or Wi-Fi.

NETGEAR

Powerline options include wired adapters and Wi-Fi receiving adapters, such as the PLW1000 mentioned by NETGEAR.

  • NETGEAR recommends plugging adapters directly into wall sockets.
  • This placement advice doesn’t confirm that the electrical wiring in your club building is suitable; test the locations you plan to use.

Powerline products at Joybuy

This selection includes powerline kits with Wi-Fi for wireless access on another floor, and an Ethernet kit for a fixed workstation. Before choosing, check the connections and compatibility with your existing powerline network.

TP-Link TL-WPA7517 KIT powerline adapter starter kit

TP-Link TL-WPA7517 KIT

The product description mentions Wi-Fi and a wired network function. Consider this kit if you need both connection options on the receiving floor.

View at Joybuy
TP-Link TL-WPA7617 KIT, 1200 Mbit/s, Ethernet and Wi-Fi, 2 adapters

TP-Link TL-WPA7617 KIT, 1200 Mbit/s, 2 adapters

The product title lists Wi-Fi and Ethernet, making this an option if you need both wireless and wired access at the receiving location.

The stated 1200 Mbit/s isn’t guaranteed throughput at the archive computer; TP-Link distinguishes between the stated physical-layer speed and actual throughput.

View at Joybuy
TP-Link TL-PA4015P KIT, 500 Mbit/s Ethernet, 2 adapters

TP-Link TL-PA4015P KIT, 500 Mbit/s, 2 adapters

The product description lists two adapters, each with one Fast Ethernet port and no Wi-Fi. This suits a fixed network connection, but not a setup where mobile devices need to connect wirelessly on that floor.

The stated 500 Mbit/s isn’t guaranteed throughput at the archive computer; TP-Link distinguishes between the stated physical-layer speed and actual throughput.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do you get started with powerline for a club archive?

Connect one adapter to the router using Ethernet, then plug a receiving adapter in near the archive workstation. You’ll need compatible additional adapters for more locations. Test the connection where you plan to use it.

Can a new adapter work with the club’s existing adapters?

That depends on the existing range and standard, not just the brand. Devolo, for example, states that Magic doesn’t work with dLAN or other HomePlug AV products. Make a note of the full model names before choosing an adapter to expand your setup.

Does the stated Mbit/s mean archive files will open at that speed?

No. According to TP-Link, the stated speed is the maximum physical-layer speed, not the guaranteed throughput at the computer. So assess the connection on the floor where you plan to use it.

Is an adapter with Ethernet enough for phones and tablets?

Not if those devices need to connect wirelessly: an Ethernet port doesn’t provide Wi-Fi on its own. Check whether the receiving adapter has Wi-Fi, or whether you’ll need a separate access point.

Does a powerline adapter provide enough protection for personal data in the club archive?

Not on its own. If the club processes personal data, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says it must determine appropriate security measures based on its risks. Assess access rights for the archive separately from the security of the network connection.