Who is this choice relevant to?

Catalogue creator who puts recovery first

You keep catalogue files and object photos on a portable workstation and want to be able to restore a usable version after deletion, damage or a failure. The National Cyber Security Centre advises testing backup recovery.

Manager of a growing image archive

You regularly add photos or scans and want to weigh up the number of drive bays against the genuinely usable space and the need for a separate copy.

Coordinator of shared catalogue files

Several people need access to the same collection, while you want to manage access and permissions for each user. If an organisation processes personal data, the Dutch Data Protection Authority considers appropriate security measures important.

Which buying considerations matter?

Start by considering how recovery works and whether the backup client is compatible, then check that capacity and access permissions suit the way you work.

Consideration What should you check? Who should pay particular attention?
Restorable backup Select source folders and versions, test a restore and keep a separate copy outside the NAS. If I want to restore both catalogue files and photos after deletion or a failure, I look for recovery features and test them. Around 36% of consumers put recoverability first.
Backup from your workstation Check operating system support and what happens to tasks if there is an interruption. My portable workstation isn't always connected, so I want to know whether the backup task will resume later. Around 29% of consumers give workstation connectivity top priority.
Usable storage space Measure your current collection and expected growth; check the space available with your chosen drive configuration and whether drives are included. If I regularly add photos and scans, I want to work out the genuinely usable space, rather than just adding up the drive capacities. Around 21% of consumers put storage growth first.
Shared access Check user permissions and who will manage updates, backups and recovery tests. When several people manage the catalogue, I want to be able to tailor access for each user. Around 14% of consumers put manageable access to shared files first.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming two mirrored drives are two independent backups

    Drive mirroring can help if one drive fails, but by itself it does not give you a separate copy to use if the NAS is lost or files are changed unintentionally. The National Cyber Security Centre stresses that a NAS is no substitute for a backup.

    Also keep a copy in a different location and try restoring your catalogue files and linked photos from it.

    A separate copy requires extra storage and regular management.

  • Confusing raw capacity with usable storage

    The space available depends on the drives and the RAID configuration you choose. Versions can also differ in whether drives are included.

    Measure your catalogue and expected growth, and check the exact version, drives and usable capacity before choosing.

    You may need to buy compatible drives separately; also allow space for backup versions.

  • Assuming a faster network port guarantees faster laptop backups

    A port specification or a measurement taken in laboratory conditions does not automatically tell you how fast the entire connection to your workstation will be.

    Consider your workstation, the NAS connection and the other network components together. You may need to upgrade other network components to make the most of the connection you choose.

Brands and model ranges to consider

Synology

Synology describes the DiskStation DS223 as central storage with Btrfs snapshots, and documents Drive Client separately for computer backups. According to Synology, the DS225+ has a 2.5GbE connection.

  • A documented computer client may be useful if your catalogue is stored on a workstation.
  • Check software support and drive compatibility for the model you choose. Stated performance is no guarantee of speed on your own network.

QNAP

QNAP describes the TS-233 as a two-bay model for central file storage, sharing and syncing, with snapshot features.

  • The manufacturer lists snapshots as an additional file recovery feature.
  • QNAP lists one Gigabit Ethernet port and 2 GB of non-expandable memory. Snapshots do not replace a separate backup; also check the backup method for your workstation.

ASUSTOR

According to ASUSTOR, the Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2) is a two-bay model with Btrfs snapshots and 2.5 Gigabit Ethernet.

  • The connection may be useful if it suits the rest of your network and the way you use it.
  • ASUSTOR’s published transfer speeds were measured in laboratory conditions and may differ when using an everyday laptop.

Buffalo

Buffalo describes the LinkStation LS220DR as a two-bay range with drives included and backup options for Windows PCs and Macs.

  • A version with drives included can make it easier to choose a configuration.
  • Check the exact capacity, operating system and recovery process. Buffalo lists Gigabit Ethernet and software for each platform; this does not prove higher performance or that every version is suitable.

Joybuy products for growing storage needs

These Joybuy product picks focus on Synology NAS systems for growing catalogues, central storage and backup. Check which drives are required for each version.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Worth considering if you want to manage a growing image catalogue centrally and value room to expand.

Hard drives are not included; also keep a separate backup in another location.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

An option to consider if you want to store a growing image archive centrally and tailor the storage configuration to your collection.

Compatible hard drives must be installed; a NAS is no substitute for a separate backup.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Worth considering if you want to store a growing catalogue centrally and tailor the configuration to your collection.

Supplied without hard drives; choose compatible drives and also keep a copy outside the NAS.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to protect your pottery catalogue?

No. The National Cyber Security Centre stresses that a RAID setup is no substitute for a backup. Keep a separate copy and test whether you can restore your catalogue files and linked photos from it.

What should you set up first after installation?

Set up user permissions and management settings carefully, and decide which folders the backup task should include. Then run a recovery test. The National Cyber Security Centre advises against making a NAS directly accessible over the internet wherever possible.

What costs and warranty should you check?

Check whether the version you choose includes drives, and allow for separate storage for a second backup. If Dutch consumer law applies, statutory consumer rights apply in addition to any manufacturer’s warranty. According to the Government of the Netherlands, the retailer is your point of contact if a product is faulty. A business purchase is not automatically a consumer purchase.

Which privacy rules apply if the catalogue contains people’s data?

When an organisation processes personal data, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says it must choose appropriate security measures based on the risks. This includes deciding which users can access the data. Whether this obligation applies to your catalogue depends on its contents and how they are processed.