Who is this guide for?

Owner of a mixed film collection

You may have both 35mm film and larger portrait negatives, and want to check in advance whether a single scanner can handle the formats in your collection.

Scanner buyer with limited cupboard space

You’re looking for a compact scanning set-up, or would rather not keep a device permanently. A compact film scanner, a flatbed and outsourcing each require a different approach to space.

Preserver of portrait detail

You want to assess faces, colour transitions and damage carefully, and are happy to spend more time on settings and post-processing to do so.

What should you look for?

Start with the types of film in your collection, then compare the workspace required, control over the image, processing time and costs for your project.

Compact film scanner with computer

Choose this if: your collection consists of 35mm negatives or slides and you want to manage the scanning settings and post-processing yourself.

The trade-off: according to the manufacturer, the Plustek OpticFilm 8300i SE is designed for 35mm film; you’ll also need a computer while scanning.

Standalone film scanner

Choose this if: you want to scan without a computer and save images directly to an SD card. Reflecta lists 35mm support for the x33-Scan, and support for 120 film as well for the x66-Scan.

The trade-off: check the supported formats and holders for each model. The x66-Scan’s 22MP output is interpolated, while its sensor is 14MP.

Flatbed scanner with film holders

Choose this if: you want to scan 120/220 film as well as 35mm, along with printed photos or documents. Epson specifies support for these formats and an A4 scanning area for the Perfection V600 Photo.

The trade-off: the stated dimensions of the casing are 280 × 485 × 118 mm, so measure your workspace before choosing this option.

Have your collection digitised

Choose this if: you have a one-off collection and don’t want to keep a scanner permanently, or would rather outsource the post-processing.

The trade-off: you’ll need to hand over your negatives temporarily and will usually pay per image. Ask in advance about resolution, file format, and dust and scratch correction.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who should consider this?
Supported film format Take stock of your film strips and slides. Check the supported formats and included holders for the exact model. If I want to scan both 35mm and 120 portraits, my chosen option needs to handle both formats. That’s why around 26% of consumers prioritise support for all the film formats they own.
Workspace and storage Compare the device’s dimensions with your workspace, and allow room for holders, the power supply and, if necessary, a computer. If I want a compact set-up or don’t want to keep a device permanently, I need to consider not only cupboard space but also the room required while scanning. Around 26% of consumers prioritise the storage and workspace needed.
Portrait detail and corrections Check which capture and correction features work with your type of film. For the reflecta x66-Scan, don’t compare the 14MP sensor solely with its interpolated 22MP output. If faces and colour transitions need to be assessed carefully, I want to know which corrections will work with my film. Around 21% of consumers prioritise preserving portrait detail and having control over corrections.
Scanning and post-processing Try a representative strip of film and factor in the time needed for loading, scanning, corrections and saving usable files. If I have a large pile of old portraits, I want to know in advance how much work I’ll need to do myself, not just how long a scan takes. Around 16% of consumers prioritise the total time needed for scanning and post-processing.
Total project cost For your number of images, compare the current cost of scanning them yourself with a quote for digitisation and the finish you want. Whether I have a one-off or recurring collection, I want to weigh the cost of the whole project against the time and equipment needed to scan it myself. Around 11% of consumers prioritise total project costs.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming ‘film scanner’ means it supports every negative format

    A model designed for 35mm may not be suitable for 120 film. This means some of your collection may not be compatible with that scanner.

    Sort your collection by format first, then check the supported formats and holders for the exact model.

    Removing dust, correcting colours and organising files all take extra time on top of capturing the images.

  • Expecting infrared correction to work with every old negative

    Infrared-based dust detection doesn’t work in the same way with traditional black-and-white film that has a silver halide layer as it does with colour film.

    Check your film type and the correction options in the supplied software before relying on automatic dust correction.

Brands to consider

Plustek

Plustek describes the OpticFilm 8300i SE and 8200i SE as scanners for 35mm negatives and slides.

  • According to Plustek, the OpticFilm 8300i SE has a built-in infrared channel and comes with QuickScan Plus and SilverFast SE Plus 9.
  • These 35mm models aren’t confirmed as a suitable choice for 120 film. Infrared correction isn’t a solution for traditional black-and-white film.

reflecta

The standalone x33-Scan is designed for 35mm; according to reflecta, the x66-Scan also supports formats including 120 film.

  • According to reflecta, both of these models can scan to an SD card without a computer.
  • The x66-Scan has a 14MP sensor and interpolated output of 22MP. Its wider format support doesn’t prove that it delivers better image quality.

Epson

The Epson Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed scanner for anyone who wants to scan film formats as well as printed photos or documents.

  • Epson specifies holders for 35mm and 120/220 film, along with an A4 scanning area. The stated dimensions of the casing are 280 × 485 × 118 mm.
  • The Consumentenbond recommends paying extra attention to software compatibility when considering older or second-hand flatbed scanners.

Related products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell whether my larger portrait negatives will fit?

First identify the film format, then check the holder and scanning area of the exact model. The OpticFilm 8300i SE is designed for 35mm, while Epson specifies 120 film support for the Perfection V600 Photo and reflecta does so for the x66-Scan.

What do I need to scan without a computer?

According to the manufacturer, the reflecta x66-Scan saves images as JPEG files to an SD card. Before buying, check which card and film holder you’ll need, and allow space for the device and power supply. A scanner that uses computer software works differently.

How can I deal with dust on old black-and-white negatives?

Don’t rely on infrared-based automatic dust correction with traditional black-and-white film. LaserSoft Imaging describes a software-based correction option; check which features are included in your software version and assess the results image by image.

What warranty applies when buying in the Netherlands?

According to the Dutch Government, you’re entitled to a product that works properly, and there’s no fixed statutory warranty period for all products in the Netherlands. If a product is faulty, the retailer is your point of contact; a manufacturer’s warranty is in addition to your statutory rights.

Can I share scanned old portraits online?

According to the Dutch Government, making a private copy of someone else’s copyright-protected photographs is for personal use, not for distribution or publication without the creator’s permission. Whether you can publish a particular portrait also depends on the rights and circumstances surrounding that photograph. Scanning it for private use doesn’t automatically give you permission to share it online.