Keeper of irreplaceable recordings
You store original conversations and final edits, and your main priority is being able to recover files after they are lost or changed by mistake. The NCSC recommends keeping backups in different locations.
Start with an archive setup you can recover: decide who can edit files, make a separate backup and test that you can restore recordings. Then choose between a NAS with two or four drive bays, based on expected growth, the access volunteers need and the complete setup. The NCSC stresses that RAID is no substitute for a backup.
You store original conversations and final edits, and your main priority is being able to recover files after they are lost or changed by mistake. The NCSC recommends keeping backups in different locations.
Several volunteers need to find episodes, but not everyone needs to edit source files. The NCSC points out that a NAS needs to be configured securely.
As well as published episodes, you store masters and working files, and want to estimate how much usable storage you will need. The National Archives lists WAV and BWF as preferred audio formats in its guidance for government information.
First decide how you will recover and manage files. Then choose a capacity and number of drive bays to suit the collection you expect to build.
A good fit when: your estimated collection will fit on two drives and a small team wants to store files centrally.
Bear in mind: there is less room to add drives later, and you will still need a separate backup.
A good fit when: you also store masters, edits and published versions, and want room to increase capacity later.
Bear in mind: extra drive bays do not replace a separate backup; if the enclosure does not include drives, you will need to budget for them separately.
A good fit when: one administrator can already organise the collection and shared network access is not needed.
Bear in mind: you will still need backups in different locations and should test that recovery works.
| Consideration | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Recoverable recordings | Check that you can use a separate backup destination and test file recovery. | If recordings cannot be recreated, you will want to know how to restore them after they are lost or changed by mistake. Around 36% of consumers put recoverability first. |
| Volunteer access | Check that you can set up accounts and folder permissions by role, and decide whether access from outside the location is needed. | When volunteers have different responsibilities, you will want to limit editing rights to the right administrators. Around 29% of consumers prioritise controlled team access. |
| Usable capacity | Include masters, edits and published files in your calculations; work out the usable space for your chosen drive configuration and check drive compatibility. | If you keep several versions of each episode, you will want to avoid planning for your current collection alone. Around 21% of consumers put future storage space first. |
| Management and complete setup | Check whether drives are included and budget for a separate backup destination. Also decide who will manage accounts and settings. | If a small team needs to maintain the NAS, you will want to match its features and setup to what you can realistically manage. Around 14% of consumers prioritise easy management and the total purchase cost. |
RAID can keep the NAS available if certain drives fail, but it does not protect against every kind of NAS failure or the loss of an older file version.
Choose your backup and recovery approach before deciding on a drive configuration.
A separate backup destination also needs to be managed and tested regularly.
A NAS without drives is not a complete storage setup. Usable space also depends on the drive configuration you choose.
Compare complete setups and check which drives are compatible with the exact model you are considering.
Remember to allow for the drives you need and a separate backup destination.
Overly broad permissions increase the risk of source recordings being changed or deleted by mistake.
Agree on roles and give editing rights only to administrators who need them.
Storing files, sharing them within the team and publishing them publicly are different things. Recordings featuring identifiable people and copyrighted music each need to be assessed separately.
Keep private archive folders separate from files for publication, and check the legal basis for processing personal data and music rights before publishing.
The DS225+ has two drive bays, while the DS925+ has four. Compare these models if you want to weigh up Synology's sharing and backup features against the extra room you need for growth.
The TS-233 is a two-drive model worth comparing if central storage and management are enough for a small team.
The Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 AS3302T v2 is a two-drive alternative to compare for its snapshot and network connection features.
The F2-425 is a two-drive option to compare for its enclosure, drives and management features.
The NASync DXP2800 has two drive bays, while the NASync DXP4800 Plus has four. The latter is worth including when comparing options for a larger collection.
These Joybuy products are Synology NAS systems for central file sharing and a podcast collection that can grow over time.
No image available
An option to compare if you want to store and share podcast files centrally, with room to grow.
Hard drives are not included; choose compatible drives separately.
No image available
An option to compare if your team wants to share podcast files centrally and needs room to expand its storage.
No image available
An option for central file sharing if you want to compare a NAS with four drive bays.
Hard drives are not included; choose compatible drives separately.
No. A mirrored drive configuration is no substitute for a backup. The NCSC recommends keeping a separate copy in another location; you should also test that you can restore files.
Not if the team works from a single location. The NCSC recommends not making a NAS directly accessible over the internet wherever possible. First decide whether access from outside the location is needed, then set user permissions carefully.
Where possible, keep the original recording and note which version was published. The National Archives lists WAV and BWF as preferred audio formats, and MP3 as acceptable under its standard for government information. That standard does not automatically apply to a community archive.
There is no single set retention period for all interviews. The Information Commissioner's Office says that, when an organisation handles personal data, it must assess whether there is an appropriate purpose and lawful basis, and must not keep data for longer than necessary for that purpose.
Check music rights before making episodes public. According to the Dutch government, using copyright-protected music requires the creator's permission; a private copy for personal use must not be distributed or made public.