Who is this for?

Console players who want to be sure of compatibility

If you play on Switch, Switch 2, PS5 or Xbox, first check that the controller is designed for your system. For example, Nintendo confirms that the original Switch Pro Controller can be used wirelessly with Switch 2.

Platform game players who care about the D-pad

If you often change direction, compare the shape and position of the D-pad and action buttons with your own play style. Nintendo, Xbox and 8BitDo describe different layouts, but that doesn’t necessarily tell you which will feel most comfortable.

Players who want to control how much their controller lights up

If you play in a dark room, being able to adjust or switch off lighting zones may matter. PowerA documents these options for the Spectra Infinity; just check that the lights are where you expect them to be.

What should you look for?

Start by checking compatibility with your console or PC and the game you want to play. Then compare the directional controls, controller lighting and cable or charging requirements with your gaming setup.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
System and game Check the exact console or operating system, connection type and support in the game. If I mainly want to avoid buying a controller that doesn’t work with my system or game, I check that combination before looking at other features. Around 33% of consumers put system and game compatibility first.
D-pad and buttons Compare the shape of the D-pad, the ABXY layout and any mappable buttons; if possible, try them with your own game. When changing direction quickly, I want to know whether the button layout suits the way I play. Around 27% of consumers give directional controls and button layout top priority.
Lighting in the dark Find out where the lights are and whether you can adjust their brightness or switch them off completely. If I want to see my controller more clearly in the dark without unnecessary light in my field of view, I look at the position and adjustability of the lighting zones. Around 20% of consumers put adjustable controller lighting first.
Cable and power Check the required connection, cable length and routing, wireless connection options and charging method. My seating distance and preference for wired or wireless play determine which connection is practical. Around 20% of consumers base their choice mainly on the cable, connection or power supply.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming RGB lighting means the action buttons light up

    PowerA describes lighting zones on the Spectra Infinity, but that doesn’t mean the letters on the ABXY buttons light up.

    Check which parts are actually illuminated. For the Spectra Infinity, also consult the model’s manual if you want to adjust the brightness or switch off the LEDs.

  • Assuming controllers with similar names are interchangeable

    Support varies by model. For example, 8BitDo lists different compatible systems for the Pro 2 and Ultimate 2C Wireless; the Switch Pro Controller and Switch 2 Pro Controller are also different products.

    Compare the full model name with the compatibility information for your system. Don’t assume that features of another model apply to this one.

  • Choosing a wired controller without checking the cable route

    PowerA lists a 10 ft cable for the Spectra Infinity. Whether that’s long enough depends on the distance and route between your gaming spot and the connection.

    Measure the route in advance and think about where the cable will run.

Brands to compare

Nintendo

The Switch Pro Controller is an option for Switch players; Nintendo also confirms that it can be used wirelessly with Switch 2.

  • Nintendo lists one D-pad for the Switch Pro Controller and an estimated battery life of around 40 hours, depending on use.
  • These details don’t automatically apply to the Switch 2 Pro Controller. The listed specifications don’t confirm that the action buttons are illuminated.

PlayStation

DualSense is the PS5 option and, according to PlayStation, can be used with certain other devices via USB-C or Bluetooth.

  • PlayStation lists haptic feedback and adaptive triggers as DualSense features.
  • On PC, features depend on the game; according to PlayStation, haptic feedback requires a USB connection.

Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is an option for Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists a hybrid D-pad, button mapping and Bluetooth for the Xbox Wireless Controller.
  • The layout won’t tell you which D-pad you’ll prefer; if possible, compare it with your own play style.

8BitDo

The Pro 2 is an option for systems including Switch and Windows, and has mappable rear buttons.

  • The extra buttons give you another place to assign the actions you want.
  • According to 8BitDo, the Pro 2 doesn’t work with PS5 or Xbox Series X|S and can’t wake a Switch from sleep wirelessly. For Switch 2, check support for the exact model.

PowerA

The wired Spectra Infinity is an option if adjustable lighting zones are important to you.

  • According to PowerA, the Spectra Infinity has ten brightness levels and the LEDs can be switched off completely.
  • The lighting zones don’t confirm that the letters on the action buttons light up. Also consider the cable and your gaming setup.

Joybuy product picks

This selection includes controllers whose product names indicate compatibility with Nintendo Switch systems, plus a Lightning controller for iPhone and iPad. Check that the exact model is compatible with your device and game.

Turtle Beach Afterglow Wave wireless controller, RGB, transparent

Turtle Beach Afterglow Wave Wireless Controller, RGB, Transparent

A good fit if you’re looking for a wireless controller for Nintendo Switch systems with RGB lighting.

The product name lists Bluetooth, TMR sticks, 40-hour battery life, four RGB modes and two programmable buttons. Systems listed: Switch 2, Switch, Switch Lite and Switch OLED.

View at Joybuy
Hori Horipad Turbo Frost wireless controller, white and transparent

Hori Horipad Turbo Frost Wireless Controller, White & Transparent

A wireless controller for anyone looking for a model for Nintendo Switch or Switch 2.

The product name lists a C button, an assignable function and 10-hour battery life. The colour is white and transparent.

View at Joybuy
Turtle Beach Rematch Super Mario Jump wireless controller

Turtle Beach Rematch Super Mario Jump Wireless Controller

This model is for anyone looking for a wireless controller for Switch 2 or Switch OLED.

The product name lists a TMR joystick, C button, two programmable buttons and 40-hour battery life. This is the Super Mario Jump Edition.

View at Joybuy
Backbone ONE Gen 2 Controller, PlayStation Edition, with Lightning connector

Backbone ONE Gen 2 Controller, PlayStation Edition, iPhone/iPad, Lightning

An option if you’re looking for a Lightning controller for iPhone or iPad and want to play on the go. Check that your chosen game or service works on your device.

The product name lists a Lightning connector and the PlayStation Edition.

View at Joybuy
KONIX JoyPad controller pair for Nintendo Switch and Switch OLED, blue and red

KONIX JoyPad Controller Pair, Blue and Red

This controller pair is an option if you’re looking for a model for Nintendo Switch, Switch OLED or Switch 2.

The product name lists compatibility with Nintendo Switch 2 and Switch OLED.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does the original Switch Pro Controller also work with Switch 2?

Yes. According to Nintendo, you can pair the original Switch Pro Controller wirelessly with Switch 2. Nintendo also says it can be charged via a USB cable connected to the Switch 2 dock; also check that your chosen game supports the controls.

Can I switch off the PowerA Spectra Infinity lighting?

Yes. According to PowerA’s manual, pressing the LED Program Button once switches the Spectra LEDs off completely. Press it again to switch them back on.

How can I test whether my Switch controller buttons are responding?

Nintendo describes a button test under System Settings, Controllers and Sensors, Test Input Devices and Test Controller Buttons. The test doesn’t cover every button, including HOME and SYNC.

Who should I contact about a faulty controller bought in the Netherlands?

According to the Dutch government, you should contact the retailer about your statutory guarantee. The Netherlands has no fixed statutory guarantee period; what you can expect from a product depends on factors including the product, its price and the information provided. A manufacturer’s guarantee provides additional cover.

Can I return a controller bought online?

For distance purchases from a business, the Dutch government says you’re entitled to a 14-day cooling-off period in many cases. Check the terms for your purchase; according to the same government information, these distance-selling rules don’t apply to purchases from a private individual.