Who is this choice relevant to?

Nintendo Switch players

You want a controller that suits your console generation and the controls your game requires. Nintendo Netherlands says that the Switch 2 Pro Controller does not work with the original Switch.

Players in a bright room

You want to see the screen clearly and play comfortably. Nintendo Netherlands says that you can adjust the brightness of the Switch 2 screen in handheld and tabletop modes, but not using the controller.

Players who switch between PC and console

You’re comparing controllers for more than one system, so check which connections and game features each device supports. Microsoft, Sony and 8BitDo outline requirements that vary by model and connection.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, check that the controller works with your system and game. Assess screen visibility separately, then compare the controls and connection.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
System and game Check the exact console version, PC support and any requirements such as Joy-Con controls or a firmware update. If I want to be sure my controller suits my console and game, compatibility comes first; around 36% of consumers feel the same way.
Screen visibility Assess your playing environment and screen separately. Nintendo Netherlands says you can adjust the brightness of the Switch 2 in handheld and tabletop modes. If you play in a bright room, you’ll want to make sure you can see the picture clearly before choosing a controller; around 29% of consumers put visibility first.
Directional controls Compare the position and design of the directional pad, and check that the controls suit your game. If I prefer to use a directional pad for jumps and movement, I focus on the controls; around 21% of consumers prioritise them.
Connection and playing environment Check whether a cable suits your setup and which features are available with your chosen wired or wireless connection. For consumers considering the cable, distance from the screen and connection, the practical setup matters most; around 14% put it first.

Buying pitfalls

  • Assuming Switch and Switch 2 controllers are interchangeable

    Nintendo Netherlands says that the Switch 2 Pro Controller does not work with the original Switch. The older Switch Pro Controller does work wirelessly with Switch 2, but it cannot wake that console from sleep using the HOME button.

    Before you buy, check the full model name and your console generation.

  • Choosing a wired Switch controller for handheld play

    PowerA says that the Enhanced Wired model reviewed only works when the Switch is in its dock. It is also unsuitable for games that require Joy-Con controllers exclusively.

    Check your playing style and the control requirements of the specific game.

  • Assuming Bluetooth supports every PC feature

    Microsoft says that audio through the Xbox controller is not supported on Windows via Bluetooth. Sony says that DualSense haptic feedback and adaptive triggers depend on the game and may require a USB connection.

    Check which features your game supports and whether they work with the connection you want to use.

  • Expecting a different controller to make the screen easier to see

    Nintendo Netherlands describes brightness as a Switch 2 screen setting for handheld and tabletop modes, not a controller feature.

    First assess your viewing position and screen settings, then choose a controller based on its controls and compatibility.

Brands to consider

Nintendo

Worth considering when your Switch generation and its features are the main priorities.

  • Nintendo Netherlands lists features of the Switch 2 Pro Controller including a directional pad, motion controls and GL/GR buttons.
  • The Switch 2 Pro Controller is designed exclusively for Switch 2. The older Switch Pro Controller works wirelessly with Switch 2, but cannot wake that console using HOME.

PowerA

Worth considering if you’re looking at a wired controller for a docked Switch setup.

  • PowerA lists a 3 m cable and two mappable buttons for the Enhanced Wired model reviewed.
  • PowerA says this model does not have HD rumble, motion controls, amiibo NFC or a C button. It only works when the Switch is in its dock.

Xbox

Worth considering for compatible Xbox and Windows setups.

  • Microsoft lists a hybrid directional pad on the Xbox Wireless Controller.
  • Feature support on Windows varies by connection. Microsoft says that audio through the controller is not supported via Bluetooth.

PlayStation

Worth considering for PS5 and PC games that support DualSense.

  • Sony lists USB-C and Bluetooth for connecting to a PC.
  • Haptic feedback and adaptive triggers only work when supported by the game and may require a USB connection.

8BitDo

Worth considering if you want to compare compatible Switch and Windows setups.

  • 8BitDo lists a charging dock for the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth Controller.
  • The manufacturer says Switch 2 compatibility is available after a firmware update. Check the firmware and which features your game supports.

Controllers at Joybuy

This selection includes controllers for a range of Switch, PlayStation and PC setups. Check which systems, connections and features suit your game for each model.

PlayStation DualSense wireless controller – Marvel's Wolverine Battle Yellow Limited Edition

PlayStation DualSense wireless controller – Marvel's Wolverine Battle Yellow Limited Edition

For a PS5 setup; the product information lists haptic feedback, adaptive triggers, and Bluetooth and USB-C connections.

View at Joybuy
Hori Wired Controller HORIPAD Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 – Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

Hori Wired Controller HORIPAD Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 – Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

For a wired Switch or Switch 2 setup; the product information lists USB, Turbo, a C button and programmable rear buttons.

View at Joybuy
Black wireless Dualshock controller for PS4 and PC

Black wireless Dualshock controller for PS4 and PC

For a PS4 or PC setup; the product information lists wireless connectivity, dual vibration motors, a turbo function, touchpad controls and a 6-axis gyroscope.

View at Joybuy
Game controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

Game controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

For a wireless Switch or PC setup; the product information lists Bluetooth 4.0, dual vibration, a turbo function and a 6-axis gyroscope sensor.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN wireless controller with Hall effect joysticks, PC and PS5 layout

VIELLAN wireless controller with Hall effect joysticks, PC and PS5 layout

For PC platform games; the product information lists Hall effect joysticks, Hall effect triggers, three programmable rear buttons and USB-C charging. PS5 layout in the product name refers to the design and does not, on its own, confirm compatibility.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will a new controller make the screen easier to see in a bright room?

No. Assess the screen separately. Nintendo Netherlands says that on Switch 2, in handheld or tabletop mode, you can adjust automatic brightness or set the brightness manually. This setting is not available in TV mode.

Can I use a Switch 2 Pro Controller with the original Switch?

No. Nintendo Netherlands says that the Switch 2 Pro Controller does not work with the original Switch. The older Switch Pro Controller can be used wirelessly with Switch 2.

How do I connect the PowerA wired controller reviewed?

PowerA says that the Mario Punch model reviewed only works when the Switch is in its dock and comes with a detachable 3 m USB cable. Check beforehand that your game does not require Joy-Con controllers exclusively.

What can I do if my controller breaks too soon during normal use?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, if a product breaks during normal use sooner than you could reasonably expect, the seller must offer an appropriate solution free of charge. This could be a repair or replacement, for example; there is no single fixed statutory warranty period for every controller.

Can I return a controller bought online if it isn’t comfortable to hold?

ACM ConsuWijzer says that products bought online are generally covered by a statutory cooling-off period, which ends 14 days after delivery. Check the conditions for unpacking, trying out and returning the product, and whether an exception applies.