Recording in a noisy classroom
You want the piano to remain audible without underestimating the room acoustics and background noise. A test recording and carefully chosen position can help you assess the balance, as described by Bax Music and Shure.
For a quick recording without a computer, a standalone stereo recorder is a good fit. If you want to position the microphones separately around the piano, consider a stereo pair with a suitable recorder or audio interface. Make a test recording from the intended position before the performance: greater distance can capture more of the room, but also more classroom noise. If pupils are recognisable, agree the purpose of the recording and whether it may be shared with the school in advance.
You want the piano to remain audible without underestimating the room acoustics and background noise. A test recording and carefully chosen position can help you assess the balance, as described by Bax Music and Shure.
You want to make a stereo recording quickly and independently, without first setting up a computer and separate microphones.
You want to position the microphones precisely and can use extra channels, cables and set-up time to tailor the recording to the instrument and room. Shure and RØDE describe stereo configurations using separately positioned microphones.
Choose this if: you want to record quickly without a computer and have a suitable place to position the recorder.
Bear in mind: the recorder’s position determines both the balance of the piano and how much sound from the room is captured.
Choose this if: you already have a compatible recording device and want to use one positionable stereo microphone.
Bear in mind: you’ll need to match the connection, cable and power supply to your recording device.
Choose this if: you want to adjust the positions for the lower and higher notes separately and have two suitable recording channels.
Bear in mind: this set-up requires more equipment and time to assemble. Also check how the recording sounds in mono.
Bax Music explains how distance affects the balance between the direct piano sound and the room. Shure points out that a stereo pair can cause phase cancellation when played back in mono, so assess the set-up with a test recording.
| What to consider | What to look for | Who this matters most to |
|---|---|---|
| Balance between the piano and the room | Compare a position closer to the piano with one further away. Listen to see whether background noise overpowers the piano. | If I’m recording in a noisy room, I want to hear how much piano comes through compared with the background noise; around 40% of consumers prioritise this balance between the piano and room noise. |
| Quick, standalone recording | Check standalone recording, the storage medium and the power supply. Also test in advance that you can play the recording back. | For a performance, I want to be able to start quickly without a computer and make a stereo recording on my own; around 30% of consumers prioritise this simple recording set-up. |
| Stereo balance of the piano | Make a test recording with your chosen set-up and listen to it in mono too. Shure warns that phase cancellation can occur. | If I want to balance the lower and higher notes of the piano separately, I want to be able to adjust the microphone positions; around 20% of consumers prioritise this stereo balance over a quick set-up. |
| Adding microphones later | Compare the number of simultaneous channels, connections and phantom power with the microphones you want to use. | If I want to connect separate microphones later, I want to know now whether the recorder has enough inputs and power; around 10% of consumers prioritise this option to expand their set-up. |
Distance and positioning affect the balance between the piano and the sound of the room. Choosing a position without testing it can therefore produce a different balance of sound from the one you’re looking for.
Before the performance, make a recording from the intended position and play it back. If necessary, move the recorder or microphone and compare the results.
The RØDE NT5 is a set of microphones, not a recorder. According to RØDE, each NT5 needs an XLR connection and P48 phantom power.
Check that your recording device has two suitable channels and provides the required power, and find out which cables and stands or mounts you’ll need.
As well as the stereo pair, this set-up requires a suitable recorder or interface, cables and a stable position.
Privacy rules may apply when people are recognisable. Rights may also apply to protected repertoire and performances.
Agree the purpose of the recording, how it will be stored and whether it may be shared with the school in advance. Check the applicable legal basis for processing and any rights separately.
The H1essential is a standalone stereo recorder with built-in X/Y microphones. The H4essential adds two XLR/TRS inputs for external microphones.
The DR-40XP combines adjustable stereo microphones with two XLR/TRS inputs and phantom power. It could suit you if you want to start recording independently and use external microphones later.
The NT5 matched pair is a stereo pair for anyone who wants to position two small condenser microphones separately around an acoustic piano.
The AT8022 is a single X/Y stereo microphone for anyone who already has a suitable recording device and doesn’t want to set up two separate microphones.
Start with a test recording by the piano, then move the set-up while listening back. According to Bax Music’s recording tips, a closer position gives a more direct sound, while greater distance can capture more of the room. The best position varies between an upright piano and a grand piano, so don’t treat any one distance as a fixed rule.
Yes. According to RØDE, each NT5 needs an XLR connection and P48 phantom power. Before buying, check that you have two suitable recording channels, the required power, cables and a stable set-up.
No. The recording format doesn’t change microphone positioning or remove distracting room noise. So use a test recording to assess the balance between the piano and the room, even if your recorder supports 32-bit float.
If the school processes personal data about recognisable pupils, it must have a valid legal basis under the GDPR and inform pupils and parents, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority. Its guidance on consent for recognisable images does not automatically apply in the same way to every sound recording. Agree the purpose of the recording, how it will be stored and whether it may be shared with the school.
Don’t assume that you can. The Dutch Government distinguishes between a private copy for personal use and distributing or making protected music available to the public. Performers’ work may also be protected by related rights. Before publishing, check which rights and permissions you need for the piece and the performance.