Piano mixer with a small desk
Wants to fit two speakers around a fixed listening position without large cabinets getting in the way of a symmetrical stereo setup. Genelec stresses the importance of symmetrical placement.
Choose a compact desktop pair if two larger speakers won’t fit symmetrically; choose two separate nearfields if you have the space and suitable connections. Point both speakers towards your listening position, then check the bass and listen for any hiss from where you mix at a low volume.
Wants to fit two speakers around a fixed listening position without large cabinets getting in the way of a symmetrical stereo setup. Genelec stresses the importance of symmetrical placement.
Works in a quiet room and wants to find out whether audible hiss is coming from the active monitors or is originating further along the audio chain. Genelec notes that self-noise can be audible at a short listening distance in a quiet room.
Wants to assess the balance of lower piano notes, taking into account the measurement conditions behind the specifications and the effect of the room.
When mixing piano in a quiet study, your choice mainly comes down to finding a suitable stereo setup, checking the bass, listening at low volume and making sure the connections work with your existing equipment.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who is this important to? |
|---|---|---|
| Piano balance and bass | Compare frequency limits only when the stated dB condition is also given, and assess the bass balance from your intended listening position. | If I want to assess lower piano notes reliably, I look at both the specification and the room. Around 31% of customers prioritise piano balance and bass. |
| Placement and stereo imaging | Measure the space on the left and right, and check that both speakers can be positioned at the same height and angled towards your listening position. | If my desk has limited space, I still want to be able to position a symmetrical stereo pair. Around 25% of customers say placement is their main constraint. |
| Hiss at low volume | If possible, listen from your usual working position without playing music, both with and without an audio source connected; the source or cables could also be causing noise. | In a quiet room, I want to know whether hiss is audible from my listening distance and whether it’s coming from the monitor or the signal chain. Around 25% of customers prioritise quiet performance at low volume. |
| Connections and stereo pair | Compare the outputs on your computer or audio interface with the inputs on the exact model, and check whether the package contains one monitor or a pair. | If I want to use my existing equipment, I need compatible connections and two speakers. Around 19% of customers prioritise connectivity and a complete stereo pair. |
The Yamaha HS5 is specified from 54 Hz at −10 dB, while ADAM Audio lists 45 Hz at −6 dB for the T5V. These figures aren’t directly comparable on their own when it comes to piano bass.
Note the measurement condition for each specification, then assess how your room affects the low frequencies at your listening position.
Yamaha lists the HS5 as packaged individually, while the PreSonus Eris 3.5 2nd Gen mentioned here is sold as a pair.
Before buying, check the pack size and the connections on the exact model.
For a stereo pair of monitors sold individually, you’ll need a second monitor and may also need suitable cables or connection equipment.
Your listening position, symmetry and reflections all affect what you hear. Measurement-based correction also has its own equipment requirements.
Plan your stereo setup first, then decide whether additional correction would suit your fixed listening position.
Measurement-based correction may require additional measuring equipment and a suitable audio interface.
The LP-UNF is designed for desktop mixing, while the LP-6 V2 is part of a larger product range.
The compact 8010A is a standalone monitor for setups where space for two speakers is limited.
The HS5 is a standalone active nearfield monitor with analogue connections and ROOM CONTROL.
The T5V is a 5-inch nearfield monitor for setups with room for two separate cabinets.
The Eris 3.5 2nd Gen is a compact analogue stereo set.
The KH 80 DSP is an option for a fixed setup where measurement-based correction is required.
Genelec recommends starting with a symmetrical setup, with you at the tip of an equilateral triangle and both monitors aimed towards your listening position. Reflections and the exact positioning still have an effect.
Listen from your usual working position and check whether the noise is still there with no audio source connected. Genelec distinguishes between self-noise from active speakers and noise coming in via the source or cables; a general statement isn’t a measurement of the model you’re buying.
No, a subwoofer isn’t automatically necessary. First work out which low notes you can’t assess well enough with your current setup and how the room affects them. Manufacturer frequency-limit figures also use different measurement conditions.
Be considerate of those around you and, if noise is an issue, agree arrangements with your neighbours. The Dutch government advises trying to agree on arrangements together first, such as the times when music can be played.