Who is a NAS suitable for?

Volunteer archive administrator

You manage the shared catalogue and mainly want to know whether you can restore deleted or lost photos. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping two backups of important files, in addition to the originals.

Team with several photographers

You want to collect photos centrally and give members access only to the files they need for their role. If photos show identifiable people, the Dutch Data Protection Authority considers them personal data.

Growing photography club

You expect the archive to grow and want to plan the usable storage space, drive choice and potential expansion in advance. Compare the capacity available with your chosen drive configuration, not just the combined capacity shown on the drive labels.

What should you look for when choosing?

NAS with a separate backup

A good fit when: several members regularly add or find files and the group has an administrator.

The trade-off: central access requires setup and ongoing management; you should also keep a copy in a separate location.

External drive for backups

A good fit when: one administrator updates the catalogue and shared network access is not a priority.

The trade-off: agree when the drive will be updated and keep a copy elsewhere; a drive at the same location will not protect against every incident there.

Cloud storage as a separate backup location

A good fit when: the group wants to keep a copy away from its own premises and can assess data access and processing in advance.

The trade-off: check whether the service can restore previous versions; synchronisation alone does not automatically provide a recoverable backup of deleted files.

First decide how the group wants to restore and manage files. Then compare access, usable capacity, and the costs and effort involved in buying and maintaining the setup.

Consideration What should you check? Who is this important for?
Recoverable backups Decide which files will be copied, where the separate copy will be kept and how you will restore files. If I want to be able to restore lost or deleted photos, I check the recovery plan and backups. Around 31% of consumers say recovery is their main buying concern.
Access and privacy Set out who can view, add, edit and delete files; if people are identifiable, also assess the legal basis and security measures. When several members work on the catalogue, I want to be able to assign permissions by role. Around 25% of consumers prioritise access management.
Usable capacity and growth Measure the current catalogue and its expected growth; check the capacity available with your chosen drive configuration and drive compatibility for each model. If the photo catalogue grows, I want to plan for enough usable space rather than just looking at the drive labels. Around 25% of consumers say room to grow is their main buying concern.
Purchase and management Check whether drives are included, what separate backup destination you will need and who will take care of installation and management. If we need a practical solution with straightforward costs and management, I want to know in advance what the complete setup involves. Around 19% of consumers prioritise simplicity and cost.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking RAID for a complete backup

    A RAID setup can protect against certain drive failures, but it does not guard against every cause of data loss. The National Cyber Security Centre warns that a NAS is not a substitute for a backup.

    Before you buy, decide how you will also keep a recoverable copy in a separate location.

    Keeping a separate copy requires an additional storage destination and time to test restoring your files.

  • Adding together the capacities of two mirrored drives

    With Synology SHR or RAID 1, the contents of two drives are mirrored. According to Synology, the capacity of one drive is then available.

    Plan based on the usable capacity with your chosen configuration, not the total shown on the drive labels.

  • Assuming hard drives are included

    A NAS may be sold as an empty enclosure. The Joybuy listing for the Synology DS1525+ states that HDDs are not included.

    Check what is included with the version you are buying, and factor compatible drives and a separate backup destination into your plans.

  • Giving every volunteer the same access

    Broader permissions than necessary can allow unwanted access or changes. This calls for extra care when photos show identifiable people.

    Appoint an administrator and assign viewing, adding, editing and deleting permissions according to each person’s role.

Relevant brands

Synology

The DS223j is a two-drive option for centralised files and backups; the DS1525+ has five drive bays for groups that demonstrably need more room to expand.

  • Synology’s datasheet describes photo management and backups to different destinations for the DS223j.
  • Synology’s datasheet lists five drive bays and built-in 2.5GbE for the DS1525+.
  • Check drive compatibility for your chosen model; more drive bays are not automatically necessary for a modest catalogue.

QNAP

QNAP positions the TS-233 for central photo storage, sharing and entry-level use.

  • For the TS-233, QNAP lists account security, two-step verification and snapshots.
  • These product features are not an independent test of recoverability; plan for a separate backup too.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Gen2 (AS1202T) is a two-drive option to consider if its connection suits your existing network and how you plan to use it.

  • ASUSTOR lists Btrfs snapshots and three USB 5Gbps ports for this model, including for backups.
  • ASUSTOR’s stated transfer speeds are laboratory figures, not results measured for your club.

NAS enclosures at Joybuy

This selection focuses on Synology NAS enclosures for centralised files and backup management. Also keep a separate copy in a different location.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS enclosure

Synology DiskStation DS1525+

Worth considering for a group that needs more room to grow; Synology lists five drive bays for this model.

Hard drives are not included; check drive compatibility and plan for a separate backup destination.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS enclosure

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Worth considering if your group needs space for a growing archive; check that the drive bays and expansion options suit your storage plan.

Alongside the NAS, plan to keep a separate copy in a different location.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Worth considering for central storage and backup management; check that this version suits your preferred drive configuration and room to grow.

This version is sold without hard drives; check which drives are compatible and plan for a separate backup destination.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID enough to back up the photo catalogue?

No. According to the National Cyber Security Centre, RAID helps a NAS cope with certain drive failures, but it does not replace a backup. Keep a separate copy and practise restoring files.

How do you set up a NAS for volunteers who change over time?

Give each member only the permissions their role requires and appoint someone to manage the system. Consider whether internet access is really necessary; the National Cyber Security Centre advises against making a NAS directly accessible over the internet wherever possible.

Why can’t you use all the stated drive capacity?

With two drives in Synology SHR or RAID 1, the contents are mirrored. According to Synology, the capacity of one drive is then available. Check the usable space for the drives and configuration you choose.

Does the group need to buy extra drives?

It depends on the version. Check whether the drives are included; the Joybuy listing for the Synology DS1525+ states that HDDs are not included.

Do privacy rules apply to identifiable people in the photo archive?

Yes. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable people in photos to be personal data. An organisation needs a legal basis under the GDPR to take and publish photos at an event; consent is one common option, but it is not the only one. You should also choose appropriate security measures and a retention period that suits the purpose.