Who is this choice relevant to?

Photographers with lots of project versions

If you want to keep several restore points, start by adding up your photos, catalogue files and versions. Adobe describes the Lightroom Classic catalogue as a database that keeps track of things such as photo locations and information about them; the original photos are separate files.

Photographers who back up frequently

If you regularly write large photo folders, compare the stated write speed and check that your computer’s connection is compatible with the model. Manufacturers quote maximum speeds, but the speed you get in practice may differ.

Photographers with sensitive images

If you carry a backup with you or want to restrict access to your images, check the security features of the exact model and keep a separate copy where appropriate. The Digital Trust Center advises against relying on a single storage location.

What should you look for when buying?

First, work out how much data and how many versions you want to keep. Then check the write speed and connection, and consider whether access security or a separate copy is relevant to the way you’ll use it.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Space for versions Add up your source folders and catalogue files, then decide how many versions you want to keep. Compare the total with the usable capacity. I want to be able to restore both the photo files and several project states, so I first add up everything included in my backup. Around 36% of consumers in this buying context prioritise space for versions.
Write speed Compare the stated write speed of the exact model and check which USB standard your computer supports. For regular, large transfers, I want to know how quickly data is written, not just how quickly it is read. Around 29% of consumers in this buying context prioritise write speed.
Connection Check whether your computer has USB-A or USB-C, and look up the full model or part number. I want to connect the flash drive directly to my computer, so I check the connection on the specific model. Around 21% of consumers mainly look for a compatible connection.
Security and recovery Check whether the exact model offers encryption. Also decide where you’ll keep a separate copy and test that you can restore it. If I’m carrying sensitive images with me, I want to restrict access and know I can restore the files. Around 14% of consumers prioritise access security.

Common pitfalls

  • Copying only the catalogue and assuming the photos are included

    In Lightroom Classic, the catalogue keeps track of things such as where photos are stored and which edits have been made; the original photo files are separate. A copy of the catalogue alone may not be enough to restore a project in full.

    Make a note of which source folders and catalogue files you back up, and test whether you can open a project using the restored files. Adobe describes the catalogue and photo files as separate components.

  • Assuming read speed tells you how fast your backup will be

    A maximum read speed doesn’t tell you how quickly large folders will be written to the flash drive. Stated performance and the computer you use can both make a difference. For example, Samsung lists a read speed for the BAR Plus models mentioned, but no comparable write speed.

    Compare the write speed of the exact model you’re considering and check your computer’s USB standard. Manufacturers such as Kingston and PNY note that performance depends on factors including the hardware used and operating conditions.

  • Confusing one up-to-date copy on a single flash drive with version control

    An up-to-date copy won’t automatically keep earlier project versions. And relying on one storage location remains a separate risk, even if the flash drive has enough capacity.

    Decide how many versions your backup method keeps, maintain a separate copy where appropriate, and test a restore from time to time. Microsoft explains how File History can restore previous versions of backed-up files and folders.

    Keeping a separate copy requires extra storage space and attention to ensure it stays up to date.

Relevant brands to consider

Kingston

DataTraveler Max is available in separate USB-A and USB-C models, with capacities of up to 1 TB according to Kingston. Check the connection and exact model, as the product range name alone doesn’t make this clear.

  • Kingston quotes maximum speeds of 1.000 MB/s read and 900 MB/s write for DataTraveler Max. These are manufacturer figures; Kingston says speed depends on factors including hardware, software and usage.
  • These speeds don’t automatically apply to every DataTraveler model. Kingston describes IronKey as a separate range for hardware encryption, so don’t assume DataTraveler Max has this feature.

PNY

The PRO Elite V2 Type-A range includes a 1 TB model for large files. Check the capacity and specifications of any Type-C model separately.

  • PNY quotes a maximum write speed of 500 MB/s for the 1 TB Type-A model when used with a suitable USB 3.2 Gen 2 host. This is a manufacturer figure based on internal testing.
  • A Type-C model doesn’t necessarily have the same capacity as a Type-A model: PNY lists 128 GB for the Type-C model referenced.

Transcend

According to Transcend, the JetFlash 920 is a USB-A range with capacities of up to 512 GB. Compare the capacity with the amount of space you’ve calculated for your version history.

  • Transcend quotes a maximum write speed of 400 MB/s for the JetFlash 920 and says it comes formatted as exFAT.
  • The range’s maximum stated capacity is lower than that of the 1 TB models mentioned. The speed is a manufacturer figure, not an independent measurement.

Samsung

The BAR Plus range includes a 512 GB USB-A model. This capacity is most relevant if it meets your calculated storage needs.

  • Samsung Electronics quotes a maximum read speed of 400 MB/s for the 512 GB model.
  • The datasheet doesn’t give a write speed for this model, so you can’t use it to estimate how long a backup will take. Also check the full model suffix of the one you choose.

USB flash drives at Joybuy

These USB flash drives offer a range of capacities and connections for storing photo files and project versions. Compare the space you need with your computer’s port; a stated read speed isn’t a write speed.

SanDisk Ultra Flair USB flash drive, 512 GB, USB 3.0

SanDisk Ultra Flair, 512 GB, USB 3.0

This capacity may suit you if your photos and versions take up no more than 512 GB.

512 GB; USB 3.0; read speeds of up to around 150 MB/s according to the product description. No write speed is stated.

The description says it works with USB-A computers and Windows and macOS.

Joybuy
SanDisk Ultra Dual Drive Go, 512 GB, USB-C and USB-A

SanDisk Ultra Dual Drive Go, 512 GB, USB-C and USB-A

The two connections may be useful if you move files between devices with USB-C and the traditional USB connection.

512 GB; USB 3.1; read speeds of up to 150 MB/s according to the product description. No write speed is stated.

Joybuy
Kingston DataTraveler 512 GB, USB 3.2 Gen 1, metal casing

Kingston DataTraveler, 512 GB, USB 3.2 Gen 1, metal casing

512 GB may be suitable if your photos and the number of versions you want to keep fit within the usable capacity.

USB 3.2 Gen 1; metal casing; read speeds of up to 220 MB/s according to the product description. No write speed is stated.

Joybuy
Samsung MUF-512DA, 512 GB, USB-C

Samsung MUF-512DA, 512 GB, USB-C

This model may suit you if 512 GB is enough and your computer has a compatible USB-C port.

USB 3.2 Gen 1 (3.1 Gen 1); read speeds of up to 400 MB/s according to the product description. No write speed is stated.

Joybuy
Kingston DataTraveler Exodia DTX, 256 GB, USB 3.2 Gen 1

Kingston DataTraveler Exodia DTX, 256 GB, USB 3.2 Gen 1

At 256 GB, this model is worth considering if the files and versions you want to keep fit within that capacity.

USB 3.2 Gen 1; write speeds of up to 625 MB/s according to the product specification in the title. Check that the stated speed is compatible with your computer’s connection.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does a copy of your photo catalogue automatically save the original photos too?

Don’t assume that it does. Adobe describes the Lightroom Classic catalogue as a database that keeps track of things such as photo locations and edits, while the photo files are stored separately. When testing a restore, check both the catalogue and the original photos. If you use other software, follow its documentation.

How can you keep and test earlier project versions in Windows?

Microsoft describes File History as a way to restore previous versions of included files and folders from an external drive. Check which folders are included, then try restoring an older version.

Is one USB flash drive suitable as your only backup?

Don’t make your recovery plan depend on a single flash drive or storage location. The Digital Trust Center advises organisations to use different storage locations and test recovery regularly. Apply this advice according to your own use and level of risk.

What can you expect in the Netherlands if the flash drive fails too soon?

When you buy as a consumer, you may have statutory rights as well as a manufacturer’s warranty. ACM ConsuWijzer explains that the seller must offer an appropriate free solution if a product doesn’t perform as you could reasonably expect under normal use. In the Netherlands, there isn’t one fixed statutory guarantee period in years for every USB flash drive. A warranty for the flash drive doesn’t guarantee that lost photo files can be recovered.

Does the GDPR apply to photos you keep privately on a USB flash drive?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the exception for personal or household use may apply if you keep photos private or share them with only a very limited group. This exception doesn’t automatically apply to business use or publication for a wider audience; consider those situations separately. This doesn’t mean that every private user needs a particular type of USB flash drive.