Who is this guide for?

Photo manager with limited desk space

You want to keep a local copy of your photos and catalogue in a small workspace, without a separate power adapter.

Photographer with a growing archive

You want enough space for your current photos and catalogue files, with room to add more.

Photographer who takes their backup drive with them

You connect the drive in different places, so you pay attention to its size, connection and protection against knocks.

What should you consider when choosing?

Compact, USB-powered HDD

A good fit for: periodic copies of a growing archive, especially if you want to use a drive on your desk without a separate power adapter. Toshiba states that the 2 TB version of the Canvio Basics is powered via USB.

Bear in mind: in 2022, Consumentenbond described HDDs as more vulnerable to shocks than SSDs. Also check that the cable and file system are compatible with your computer.

Compact portable SSD

A good fit for: frequent connections, taking it with you or transferring large files. Crucial lists the X9’s dimensions as 65 × 50 mm.

Bear in mind: stated maximum speeds are not guaranteed transfer speeds on your computer; the connection and test conditions matter.

Consideration What should you check? Who is this important for?
Space for your photo archive Compare the space used by your photos, catalogue and any export folders with the capacity of the exact variant. As my archive grows, I want enough space for the files I really want to keep. Around 29% of consumers prioritise archive capacity.
Restorable backup Check which folders the software copies, try restoring a file and plan how you’ll store the drive separately afterwards. I want to be able to restore both my catalogue and its associated photos. Around 29% of consumers give restorability top priority.
Space and connection Compare the variant’s dimensions, cable and connector with the space available and ports on your computer. On a small desk, what matters most to me is a drive I can use without an extra adapter and with a compatible connection. Around 21% of consumers prioritise desk space and connectivity.
Transfer and portability Check your computer’s USB specification and the cable supplied; don’t treat a stated maximum as a guaranteed backup time. If I connect or take the drive with me often, I look at its size and connection. Around 21% of consumers prioritise transfer and portability.

Common backup mistakes

  • Copying only the catalogue file

    Adobe says Lightroom Classic’s backup function only includes the catalogue file, so your original photos are not automatically backed up.

    Include the folders containing your original photos and any export files, and try restoring them.

    You still need a separate copy of your original photos and any export files.

  • Leaving the backup drive connected all the time

    Consumentenbond warns that ransomware can also affect files on connected external drives. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping backups in different locations, including locations that are physically separate.

    Disconnect the drive after backing up, and consider how you’ll keep a separate copy as well.

    An additional, separate copy requires another storage location or service.

  • Choosing based only on the stated maximum speed

    A maximum speed doesn’t tell you what transfer speed you’ll get on your computer; the connection and conditions also matter. The choice between an HDD and SSD also depends on archive capacity, size and how often you take the drive with you.

    First compare the capacity you need, available ports and how often you’ll use it. Treat MB/s figures as stated maximums.

  • Enabling password protection without a recovery plan

    Western Digital says data encrypted with WD Security can’t be accessed if you forget the password.

    Keep the password somewhere safe and also maintain a separate copy that you can restore.

Brands to compare

Toshiba

The Canvio Basics is a compact HDD range for straightforward local storage, powered via USB.

  • For the 2 TB version, Toshiba lists dimensions of 78 × 109 × 14 mm and a Type-A-to-Micro-B cable.
  • The drive is formatted as NTFS for Windows. If you use macOS, check the format and backup software.

Seagate

The Expansion Portable range is a portable HDD option for storage without a desktop enclosure and separate power supply.

  • Seagate lists USB 3.0, several capacity options and a Type-A cable included in the box.
  • Seagate says reformatting is required to use it with Time Machine; check the version you choose.

Samsung

The portable T7 SSD is an option if compact size and file transfers are important. The T7 Shield is a separate product range.

  • For the standard 2 TB T7, Samsung states maximum sequential read and write speeds of 1.050 and 1.000 MB/s.
  • These are Samsung specifications, not measured performance on your computer. Actual transfer speeds also depend on the connection.

Crucial

The X9 Portable SSD is a compact SSD option if desk space is a consideration.

  • Crucial lists the enclosure dimensions as 65 × 50 mm and specifies a USB-C connection.
  • The stated speed of up to 1.050 MB/s is a maximum measured by Crucial under specific test conditions; compatibility may depend on formatting and your computer.

Western Digital

My Passport is worth considering if, alongside portable storage, you’re also looking for supported password protection.

  • Western Digital lists My Passport among the drives that support WD Security.
  • Western Digital says encrypted data can’t be accessed if you forget the password. Password protection is no substitute for a separate backup.

Joybuy products

This selection from Joybuy includes portable SSDs for taking with you and transferring files, as well as portable HDDs for local photo archive storage.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

A portable SSD for local photo and catalogue files if you plan to take the drive with you regularly.

The product information lists drop protection from heights of up to 2 m and a stated transfer speed of up to 800 MB/s.

View at Joybuy
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

A 1 TB portable SSD for photos and other files if you’re looking for a compact drive to take with you.

The product information lists dimensions of approximately 8,5 × 5,1 × 1,0 cm and a weight of 46,9 g, as well as a stated read speed of up to 2.000 MB/s. This maximum speed requires a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 host; the write speed is lower.

View at Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 6TB White

Western Digital My Passport 6TB White

This portable HDD offers 6 TB of storage for a growing photo archive; the product information mentions software for scheduled backups.

The product information lists USB 3.0 and password protection. If you use WD Security, Western Digital says encrypted data may become inaccessible if you forget the password. According to Consumentenbond, an HDD is more vulnerable to shocks than an SSD.

View at Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 4TB Black

Western Digital My Passport 4TB Black

This portable HDD offers 4 TB of storage for photos and other files; the product information mentions software for scheduled backups.

The product information lists USB 3.0, bus power and password protection. If you use WD Security, Western Digital says encrypted data may become inaccessible if you forget the password. According to Consumentenbond, an HDD is more vulnerable to shocks than an SSD.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 2TB USB-C Graphite Black

WD Elements Portable 2TB USB-C Graphite Black

A 2 TB portable HDD for a local photo collection, with USB-C according to the product title.

The product information mentions plug-and-play use. According to Consumentenbond, an HDD is more vulnerable to shocks than an SSD.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does backing up my Lightroom Classic catalogue also back up my photos?

No. Adobe says Lightroom Classic’s backup function only includes the catalogue file. You should also back up your photos and any exported files.

How do you choose between an HDD and an SSD for your photo archive?

A compact HDD may be suitable if you mainly want to make periodic local copies of a growing archive; an SSD may be a better fit if a small size and portability are more important. Bear in mind that, according to Consumentenbond, HDDs are more vulnerable to shocks than SSDs, and maximum speeds don’t guarantee the transfer speed you’ll get on your computer.

Can you use a Toshiba Canvio Basics with your Mac without any preparation?

Not without checking the format first. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics is formatted as NTFS for Windows and may need reformatting for use with macOS. Check the exact version and backup method before erasing any existing data on the drive.

How do you back up to a Windows drive?

Microsoft describes File History as a way to copy libraries and added folders to an external drive and restore previous versions. Check that both your photo and catalogue folders are selected; the Windows Backup app syncs selected user folders with OneDrive and is not the same as a local drive backup.

What happens if you forget your WD Security password?

According to Western Digital, data encrypted with WD Security can no longer be accessed. Keep your password somewhere safe and maintain a separate backup that you can restore.