Who are these microphone options suitable for?

Recording at a noisy shared desk

If you want to record a single percussion source while someone else is using the desk, consider the microphone’s direction and how far it is from the source. Shure recommends pointing the microphone at the sound source you want to capture and placing it as close as is practical.

Making detailed percussion recordings

If you want to capture the nuances of instruments such as shakers or cymbals, consider a small-diaphragm condenser microphone. RØDE recommends the NT5 for overheads and cymbals, while AKG lists the P170 for percussion and overheads.

Working with limited setup space

A compact recorder can be practical if you want to set up or put away your equipment quickly. A microphone with an instrument clamp is another option if your instrument is suitable; check that it fits before choosing a model.

What should you consider when choosing?

Dynamic instrument microphone close to a single source

Choose this if: you want to record one drum or another percussion source directly and can place it close to the microphone.

Keep in mind: you’ll need the right microphone input and cable, as well as a stable position. A single close microphone won’t automatically give you a spacious sound across multiple instruments.

Small-diaphragm condenser microphone

Choose this if: you want to record shakers, cymbals or a small percussion setup, for example, and have a suitable spot above the source.

Keep in mind: it may pick up more ambient noise, and you’ll need to check the XLR connection and phantom power required by the specific model.

Condenser microphone with an instrument clamp

Choose this if: you have limited desk space and your instrument has a suitable place to attach the clamp.

Keep in mind: the clamp won’t necessarily fit every instrument. Check the connection and power requirements too.

Compact recorder with built-in microphones

Choose this if: you want to capture a practice session or several sounds at once, without a separate instrument microphone.

Keep in mind: the built-in microphones aren’t focused on a single source. Zoom recommends placing the H1essential above the desk when recording with its built-in microphones.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who this matters most to
Desk noise around a single source Check whether you can point the microphone at the instrument and place it close enough to the source without getting in the way of playing. If I want to hear one percussion source while the desk is in normal use, I focus on positioning. Around 36% of consumers prioritise reducing noise from the workspace.
Percussion detail Decide which instruments you want to record at the same time, whether there’s room for a stand and what phantom power the specific model requires. If I want to capture the nuances of instruments such as shakers or cymbals, the recording position and connection matter. Around 29% of consumers give percussion detail top priority.
Space and vibrations Check whether an instrument clamp will fit, where you can place equipment beside the desk and whether it can be kept off the moving desktop. With limited space, I want to be able to move equipment out of the way and reduce vibrations from the desk. Around 21% of consumers put setup space first.
Connections and quick recording Check whether you have a suitable XLR input and, if needed, phantom power, or whether you want to record independently or via USB. For a recorder, check what storage and power it needs. If I want to record quickly without setting up a separate microphone chain, I focus on the connection and controls. Around 14% of consumers prioritise a simple recording setup.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming a directional polar pattern blocks out all sound

    Even a carefully positioned directional microphone can pick up noise from the desk or other people using it, particularly if the percussion source is further away.

    Start by finding a position that works, then make a test recording while the desk is being used as normal. Don’t base your choice on the polar pattern alone.

  • Focusing only on the microphone and forgetting the connection

    A microphone may require a suitable XLR input and phantom power. The connections required vary by model.

    Before buying, check the complete signal chain and what you’ll need for the specific model.

  • Placing a recorder directly on a vibrating desktop

    Desk movement can create unwanted noise. Zoom also warns that reflections from the desk can affect recordings made with the H1essential’s built-in X/Y microphones.

    Before settling on a desktop setup, test whether you can position the recorder above or away from the desk.

  • Choosing a stereo pair when one focused recording is enough

    A stereo pair is a different recording option from using a single microphone. Using multiple microphones on the same source also means you’ll need to consider phase differences.

    First decide whether you want to record one instrument on its own or capture a more spacious overall sound.

Brands and models to consider

Shure

The SM57 is a dynamic instrument microphone for focused recording, while the PGA98D is designed to attach to a suitable drum or percussion source.

  • Shure says the SM57 has a cardioid polar pattern. The PGA98D has a gooseneck and drum clamp.
  • The PGA98D uses XLR and requires phantom power. Check that the clamp fits your instrument.

RØDE

The NT5 is a small-diaphragm condenser microphone that RØDE recommends for instruments, overheads and cymbals.

  • RØDE specifies XLR, P48 phantom power and a cardioid polar pattern for the NT5.
  • A single NT5 isn’t the same as a stereo pair. Positioning and the room will still affect unwanted noise.

AKG

The P170 is a small-diaphragm condenser microphone that AKG recommends for percussion and overheads.

  • AKG lists a switchable −20 dB pad and a power range of 44–52 V.
  • Check that your audio interface’s power supply meets the stated requirements.

Audio-Technica

The AT2020 is a side-address XLR condenser microphone for applications including home recording and instruments.

  • Audio-Technica says the AT2020 requires full 48 V phantom power via a balanced XLR microphone cable.
  • Check your interface, cable and available positioning space. The stated features don’t indicate better percussion isolation than the other options.

Zoom

The H1essential is a compact recorder with built-in X/Y microphones and a USB microphone function.

  • Zoom lists standalone recording and use as a USB microphone.
  • When using the built-in microphones, Zoom recommends positioning the recorder above the desktop to avoid possible reflections.

Products on Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will a cardioid microphone stop it picking up someone else using the desk?

A cardioid microphone can pick up less sound from outside its main direction, but it can’t guarantee that voices or keyboard noise won’t be heard. Point the microphone at the instrument, place it close to the source where possible, and make a test recording while the desk is in normal use.

Can I connect a condenser microphone directly to my computer?

That depends on the model and your computer’s connections. According to Audio-Technica, the AT2020 uses XLR and requires full 48 V phantom power. RØDE also specifies P48 via XLR for the NT5. The Zoom H1essential has a USB microphone function.

Where should I position a recorder or microphone at a shared desk?

Where possible, try to position your equipment away from the moving desktop. For recording with the H1essential’s built-in X/Y microphones, for example, Zoom recommends using a stand above the desk to reduce unwanted reflections. Desk movement can also create unwanted microphone noise.

What extra equipment might I need, and what about the warranty?

For each model you’re considering, check whether you’ll need a suitable cable, microphone input, phantom power, mount or recorder storage. According to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands. If a product is faulty, contact the seller to arrange a solution.

Can I record other people’s conversations at a shared desk?

This depends on the circumstances, the purpose of the recording and what happens to any identifiable voices. If an organisation processes personal data, it needs a lawful basis under the GDPR. The Dutch Data Protection Authority also says that employers cannot simply monitor their employees. Agree this with the other people using the desk, and avoid recording or sharing identifiable conversations unnecessarily.