Editing alongside colleagues
You edit percussion while others work in the same room. Agree on when speakers can be used; Arboportaal notes that even quieter sounds can be disruptive.
Start by agreeing on noise levels. If speakers would disturb your colleagues, headphones are the more practical choice for everyday editing; schedule speaker checks for a time or place where they’re appropriate. If you can use monitors, choose a stereo pair that fits on your desk and connects to your computer or audio interface. Only compare bass response at the same dB tolerance, and bear in mind the effect of the room.
You edit percussion while others work in the same room. Agree on when speakers can be used; Arboportaal notes that even quieter sounds can be disruptive.
You want to assess hits and stereo positioning from a fixed listening position. Genelec recommends pointing monitors towards your listening position and, ideally, arranging them in an equilateral triangle.
You’re looking for a compact stereo setup that fits your workspace and connects to your computer or audio interface output. ADAM Audio and Kali Audio list USB-C and balanced TRS connections for the D3V and LP-UNF respectively.
When: if speaker sound would disturb colleagues or isn’t allowed under your workplace agreements.
Trade-off: a separate monitor check is still useful when making decisions about speaker playback. Keep your listening volume in mind when using headphones, too.
When: if speaker use has been agreed and two speakers can be placed symmetrically on a small desk.
Trade-off: ADAM Audio lists USB-C and balanced TRS for the D3V; Kali Audio also lists RCA for the LP-UNF. The stated low-frequency limits of different models are only comparable when their dB tolerances are given too.
When: if you have room for two monitors positioned evenly and a suitable analogue output.
Trade-off: check how many monitors are included in the box and which cables you’ll need. Yamaha lists XLR and TRS inputs for the HS5; European product information states that it is packaged individually.
| What to consider | What to check before buying | Who is this most relevant to? |
|---|---|---|
| Sound in a shared workspace | Agree on when and where you can test monitors; don’t assume that listening at close range will prevent disturbing others. | If colleagues work next to me, I want to know in advance when speakers are appropriate. Around 36% of consumers say avoiding disruption to colleagues is their top priority. |
| Percussion details and stereo positioning | Check whether two speakers can be positioned at the same height and distance, pointing towards your listening position. | If I want to assess hits and left-to-right positioning, I need a fixed, symmetrical listening position. Around 29% of consumers prioritise drum details and stereo. |
| Kick and other bass | Only compare frequency limits at the same dB tolerance; if necessary, assess the bass using a second suitable monitoring setup as well. | If low-frequency percussion is my main concern, I want to know how the monitor specifications were measured and what I’ll hear from my listening position. Around 21% of consumers put bass monitoring first. |
| Desk space, connections and complete setup | Measure the available space on both sides; check the inputs, cables and whether the box contains one speaker or a pair. | If I need a complete stereo setup, both monitors must fit and connect to my equipment. Around 14% of consumers prioritise setup and connections. |
Genelec lists the 8010A and Yamaha lists the HS5 as individually packaged, while desktop models such as the ADAM D3V and Kali LP-UNF are described as stereo systems. The number of speakers affects what else you’ll need for a complete stereo setup.
Check how many are included and which connections and cables you’ll need for two speakers.
If a model is packaged individually, you may need a second speaker and a suitable cable for stereo.
The stated frequency limits for these models don’t all use the same dB tolerance. Placement and the room also affect what you hear.
Check the dB definition for each frequency range. If necessary, make important bass decisions using a second suitable monitoring setup as well.
Noise disturbance and the effect of the room are separate considerations; extra bass response won’t automatically solve either one.
First agree on when speakers can be used and assess their placement before adding extra bass response.
The D3V is a desktop stereo system; the T5V is a separate active nearfield monitor.
Kali Audio describes the LP-UNF as a stereo system for desktop mixing; the LP-6 V2 is part of a separate series of nearfield monitors.
The 8010A is a compact, separate active monitor for a workspace with limited room.
The HS5 is a separate active nearfield monitor for a workspace where two speakers and a suitable analogue connection are possible.
The ROKIT 5 Generation Five is an active monitor with adjustable playback modes and placement EQ.
Agree on their use with your colleagues and workplace. Arboportaal notes that even quieter sounds can be disruptive, so it’s still important to agree on when and where you can play audio.
Point both monitors towards your listening position and, ideally, arrange them in an equilateral triangle, as Genelec recommends. Keep their height and distance equal on both sides; desks and walls can affect playback.
No, connections vary by model. ADAM Audio lists USB-C for the D3V and Kali Audio does the same for the LP-UNF; Yamaha lists analogue XLR and TRS inputs for the HS5. Check the output on your computer or audio interface and which cables you’ll need.
Not on the basis of that figure alone. Compare frequency limits at the same dB tolerance, and also take account of the placement and the room you’re listening in.
Check the quantity included in the listing. Yamaha lists the HS5 and Genelec lists the 8010A as individually packaged; in that case, you’ll need two monitors for a stereo pair.