Joybuy Insights

Buying pencils: how to choose the right pencils for writing, drawing and eyebrows

Buying pencils seems straightforward until you have to choose between coloured pencils, graphite pencils, mechanical pencils or an eyebrow pencil. A low price says little about whether a pencil is suitable for your needs. For example, children benefit from a sturdy shape that is easy to hold, while artists tend to focus on hardness, line thickness and colour intensity.

Marketing terms can also be confusing. That is why the Joybuy Product Recommendation Officer focuses on verifiable product specifications and practical usage scenarios.

Common pitfalls when buying pencils

1. More pencils are not always better value

A 48-colour pencil set may look appealing, but first check whether you really need that much variety. For school, simple colouring books or use on the go, a set of 12 or 24 colours may be enough. With a larger set, a good storage box is also important to prevent pencils from being lost or damaged.

2. “Ergonomic” does not mean the same thing for everyone

A triangular shape can provide extra grip, but the right size depends on the user. Young children may find thick coloured pencils more comfortable to hold than slim models. For writing pencils, also consider handedness: some ergonomic pencils are specifically designed for right- or left-handed users.

3. Claims about durability and performance need context

According to Faber-Castell’s own information, the special SV bonding helps to reduce lead breakage. This is a brand specification, not a guarantee that a pencil will be unbreakable in every situation. Terms such as “smudge-proof”, “waterproof” and “12 hours” used for eyebrow pencils are also claims from the product description or manufacturer. Always check the ingredients, warnings and recommended period of use on the packaging.

Important specifications to compare

Hardness and line thickness

With graphite pencils and drawing pencils, hardness determines how dark and soft the line will be. HB is a practical middle-ground choice for writing and schoolwork. 2B produces a softer, darker line and is better suited to sketching and shading. A pencil with a thinner lead, such as 0.5 mm in a mechanical pencil, is suitable for precise notes and technical lines.

For coloured pencils, you should focus more on the core, colour intensity and shape of the pencil barrel. According to the product description, the Faber-Castell Black Edition has a 5 mm core and B hardness. The STABILO Trio Thick uses a 4.2 mm core, which can be practical for larger areas of colour.

Shape and grip

A hexagonal barrel prevents a pencil from rolling easily off a desk. A triangular barrel can help provide a stable grip. Also check whether the shape is suitable for writing or drawing for long periods. Mechanical pencils may have a soft grip for extra comfort, but also pay attention to the refill mechanism and the availability of refills.

Materials, care and safety

Wooden pencils need to be sharpened regularly with a suitable sharpener. Store them in a dry place and avoid significant changes in temperature. With mechanical pencils, check the refill diameter: a 0.5 mm refill will not fit a model designed for 0.7 or 1.8 mm refills.

Cosmetic products require different considerations. An eyebrow pencil is intended for external use. Avoid contact with the eyes and stop using it if irritation occurs, in accordance with the safety information in the relevant product description. Also check the period after opening and choose a colour that complements your hair.

Our recommendations for each user profile

Suitable for: Budget-conscious beginners
Faber-Castell Coloured Pencils Black Edition 12 pieces

Faber-Castell Coloured Pencils Black Edition - 12pcs

Why it suits this profile: A neat set of 12 different coloured pencils for children, adults and beginners who do not need a large selection straight away.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The fixed number of colours makes comparison simple. The triangular shape and SV bonding applied by Faber-Castell, according to the brand, are clear specifications rather than just a general marketing promise.

Key benefit & advantages

12 colours, B hardness, 5 mm core and ergonomic triangular shape. Suitable for light and dark paper according to the product description.

Suitable for: Shoppers looking for premium quality
Faber-Castell Black Edition coloured pencils, 36 pieces

Faber-Castell Black Edition Colored Pencils Set - 36pcs

Why it suits this profile: For artists and hobbyists who want a range of colour tones for shading, blending and creative projects.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The metal storage tin provides a dedicated place for all 36 pencils. This gives you more variety without having to gather loose pencils in a pencil case.

Key benefit & advantages

36 colours, triangular shape, 5 mm core and wooden barrel. According to the product description, suitable for light, coloured and black paper.

Suitable for: Specific uses & intensive users
M&G metal mechanical pencils 0.5 mm

M&G Metal Mechanical Pencil - 0.5 mm, 3 Pack

Why it suits this profile: For school pupils, students, office workers and artists who want a consistent, fine line without having to sharpen the pencil repeatedly.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The 0.5 mm refill size is clearly stated. However, check that you have compatible refills and retract the tip when carrying the pencil to help prevent breakage.

Key benefit & advantages

Set of three, metal barrel, push-button mechanism and 0.5 mm black graphite refills for writing, drawing and sketching.

Suitable for: Specific uses & intensive users
Catrice Slim'Matic Ultra Precise Brow Pencil Waterproof

Catrice Slim'Matic Ultra Precise Brow Pencil Waterproof 040 Cool Brown

Why it suits this profile: For everyday use when you want a fine tip, an integrated brush and a waterproof eyebrow pencil.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product information states that it has a 0.05 g tip, an integrated spoolie and a waterproof formula. Performance will still depend on your skin, usage and conditions.

Key benefit & advantages

Ultra-fine tip, shade 040 Cool Brown, integrated brush and, according to the product description, a waterproof formula.

Looking for more options?

We have put together a complete, up-to-date list of products that fully meet these strict selection criteria and the applicable European safety regulations.

Frequently asked questions about buying pencils

Which pencils are suitable for school?

For everyday writing, HB graphite pencils are a practical choice. According to the product description, a set such as the STAEDTLER Noris Classic contains HB pencils and an eraser. For beginner writers, an ergonomic model such as STABILO EASYgraph may be a good fit. When choosing one, check whether the pencil is intended for left- or right-handed use.

What is the difference between coloured pencils and drawing pencils?

Coloured pencils contain a coloured core and are designed for colouring, layering and simple illustrations. Drawing pencils and graphite pencils use graphite in different hardnesses for lines, outlines and shading. Mechanical pencils use separate refills and are useful when you want to maintain a consistent point.

How long do pencils last?

Their lifespan depends on the core, how they are sharpened and the pressure applied. Store wooden pencils in a dry place, use a sharp sharpener and avoid applying unnecessary force. With mechanical pencils, the supply of refills determines how long you can use them in practice. For cosmetic pencils, follow the expiry information on the packaging; with an eyebrow pencil, always observe the stated period after opening.