Who are these controllers for?

Home producer mixing vocal harmonies

Already has an audio interface and wants to compare vocal layers quickly in mono through the speakers, with the volume control close to hand.

Mixer short on power sockets

Wants to control the existing speaker setup without powering another device, so looks for passive models and compatible cables.

Producer who also records vocals

May want a separate, adjustable monitoring route for the singer and needs to check whether the existing interface can already provide one.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start with the mono function and power requirements. Then consider only the extra cue or switching options you’ll actually use.

Passive controller for one pair of speakers

Suitable if: your interface already handles recording and any headphone mix, and you mainly want to control the volume and mono switching at your desk.

Bear in mind: the controller doesn’t replace a separate headphone or cue route.

Passive controller with source or speaker switching

Suitable if: you genuinely need to switch between several audio sources or pairs of speakers without using an extra power socket.

Bear in mind: the extra switching options don’t provide a recording interface or a separate cue mix for the singer.

More advanced controller for recording with a singer

Suitable if: a singer needs their own headphone mix that you can’t control with your existing interface.

Bear in mind: extra features may require power and more cabling; check the complete signal path.

Consideration What should you check? Who is this important for?
Checking vocal layers in mono Check that the mono switch really combines the left and right channels. Also consider whether you need mute or dim. If I want to quickly hear what happens to panned vocal layers in mono while mixing, I want to be able to switch straight to it. Around 36% of consumers rank quick mono checks as their top buying priority.
Avoiding an extra power socket Check whether the exact model works without a power supply and whether its inputs and outputs are compatible with your interface and speakers. If power sockets are in short supply, I don’t want to have to connect a power supply just to control my speakers. Around 29% of consumers give avoiding an extra power connection top priority.
Setting up a separate cue mix for the singer First check your interface’s cue options. If needed, compare the number of headphone outputs and whether each has its own level control. If a singer needs a different mix to listen to while recording, I want to be able to control that separately from the speakers. Around 21% of consumers prioritise a separate headphone mix for the singer.
Switching between sources or speakers Count stereo sources and pairs of speakers separately, then compare those numbers and connections with the exact model. If I use several existing monitoring setups, I want to be able to switch between them without reconnecting cables. Around 14% of consumers give this switching option top priority.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a passive controller also provides a separate cue mix for the singer

    Passive speaker control and a separately adjustable monitoring mix are different functions. A passive controller doesn’t replace a headphone amplifier or recording interface.

    First check the headphone and cue options on your interface. Only choose extra equipment if you’re missing a monitoring route.

    If your interface can’t provide the cue mix, you may still need a headphone amplifier or another cue solution.

  • Confusing the Big Knob Passive with the Big Knob Studio

    Mackie describes these as different models: according to the manufacturer, the Big Knob Passive has no USB audio or headphone outputs. So the Studio version’s features don’t automatically apply to the Passive.

    Check the full model name and the features of the exact version you’re considering.

    This helps you avoid paying for interface features you already have or missing out on a headphone output you expected.

  • Counting connections without checking what they do

    Connection types and whether they can be used at the same time vary by model. Behringer warns that the alternative connection types listed for the MONITOR1 shouldn’t be used simultaneously.

    Map out the route from your interface to the controller and speakers. Then compare the connectors and the source and output options for the exact model.

    An incompatible connection may mean you need extra cables or a different signal path.

Brands compared

Mackie

The Big Knob Passive is designed for passive control of two sources and two pairs of speakers.

  • Mackie lists mono, mute and dim functions for the Passive.
  • According to Mackie, this model has no headphone outputs or USB audio; don’t confuse it with the Big Knob Studio.

Palmer

The MONICON M G2 is designed for one stereo source and one pair of speakers; the MONICON S G2 uses a more compact RCA connection.

  • For the M G2, Palmer lists balanced XLR/TRS combo inputs, XLR outputs, and mono, dim and mute functions.
  • According to Palmer, the S G2 works without a power supply but uses RCA connections and doesn’t offer the same choice of connections as the M G2.

Behringer

The MONITOR1 is a passive stereo volume controller for one speaker setup, with mono and mute functions.

  • Behringer lists XLR/TRS combo or 3.5 mm inputs and XLR or 3.5 mm outputs.
  • Behringer warns that the alternative connection types listed shouldn’t be used simultaneously. The quoted product specifications don’t mention a dim or separate headphone function.

Radial Engineering

The SAT-2 is designed for passive level control between an interface and one pair of active speakers.

  • Radial lists mono, mute and an adjustable dim function; the unit works without a power supply.
  • The stated use is with one pair of speakers; don’t base your choice on an unconfirmed second speaker route.

PreSonus

The Monitor Station V2 is designed for recording, with separate Main/Cue options, multiple headphones and talkback.

  • PreSonus lists four headphone outputs, each with its own level control and Main/Cue option.
  • Check what power your setup needs and whether your interface already provides the cue function.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I record vocal harmonies with a passive monitor controller?

Not with the controller alone: it controls your monitoring setup, while you use your audio interface to record. Separately, check whether your interface can provide a suitable headphone mix for the singer.

Where should I put a monitor controller, and how do I look after it?

Place an analogue controller designed for this purpose between your interface outputs and the inputs of your active speakers. First compare the connection types on all your equipment; Mackie recommends cleaning the Big Knob Passive with a dry cloth.

What are your rights if a controller bought online isn’t suitable or is faulty?

For online consumer purchases in the Netherlands, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, subject to legal exceptions, according to ACM ConsuWijzer. Separately, you have a statutory right to a product that, under normal use, does what you could reasonably expect; contact the seller if it’s faulty.

Does every monitor controller need to carry a CE mark?

Not necessarily. According to the European Commission, CE marking is required when applicable harmonised EU rules specify it for the product. The relevant rules must be determined for each product; the mark isn’t independent approval of the mixing quality.