Who is this choice relevant to?

Organiser of a multiplayer session

Wants to provide enough individual player positions using the club’s existing set-up, and starts by counting the controllers available. Team17 states that Overcooked! 2 supports up to four players; for the game on Switch, Nintendo recommends one Joy-Con per chef.

Player who wants a full-size controller

Prefers a complete gamepad and chooses one that suits the system in use. A Switch Pro Controller provides one player position; suitable models for PCs and other consoles vary.

Manager of a permanent TV set-up

Could consider a wired controller if the Switch is in its dock and the cable can safely reach the seats. The cable and the route it takes need to suit the room.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, choose a model that works with your system and game. Then count the available player positions and consider the controls, connection and charging.

For Overcooked! 2, Team17 confirms support for up to four players, while Nintendo recommends one Joy-Con per chef on Switch. The exact controller set-up and support can vary by system and game version.

What to consider What to check before buying Who should pay particular attention?
Compatibility Check the exact controller model and supported connection against your system and game. I want to make sure the controller works with our console or computer and the game we’ve chosen. Around 29% of consumers say compatibility is their main concern.
Individual player positions Count the players and usable controllers, then test the set-up together in local multiplayer mode. If several club members want to play at once, I want to know in advance how many individual player positions our existing set-up can provide. Around 24% of consumers prioritise the number of player positions.
Ease of use Try out the buttons and stick with the people who will be using the controller. I want club members to find the controls comfortable to use, whether they’re holding a single Joy-Con or a full-size gamepad. Around 18% of consumers say ease of use is their main concern.
Set-up and overall cost Check which cables, receivers and connections are needed, and how far away the screen is. I want to know what’s needed for each usable player position and whether cables can be routed safely past the seats. Around 17% of consumers focus mainly on the overall set-up and cost per player position.
Keeping controllers ready to play Check the charge, batteries, charging equipment and pairing in advance. I want the controllers to be ready for the next club night after storage, with no surprises when connecting or charging them. Around 12% of consumers give top priority to keeping their controllers ready to use.

Common pitfalls when buying game controllers

  • Counting a full-size controller as two player positions

    Nintendo counts a Pro Controller as one controller. Two Joy-Cons can also be used together as one controller, while individual Joy-Cons can provide separate player positions in Overcooked! 2 on Switch.

    Make a note of how many people want to play at once, and test your chosen Joy-Con or controller set-up in advance.

  • Going by the name of a controller model

    8BitDo lists Windows and Android compatibility for the Ultimate 2C Wireless, but Switch compatibility for the separate Ultimate 2C Bluetooth model. The model names therefore don’t indicate the same platform support.

    Check the full model name and the manufacturer’s platform list against the system your club uses.

  • Choosing a wired controller without checking the room

    According to PowerA, the wired controller reviewed has a detachable 3 m cable and works with the Switch in its dock. The cable could restrict seating arrangements and walking routes.

    Measure the distance from the console to the seats and keep cables out of walkways.

  • Confusing the warranty, cooling-off period and buying on behalf of the club

    The ACM distinguishes between the legal guarantee and the cooling-off period. Which consumer rights apply depends in part on who is legally making the purchase.

    Make a note of who is buying on behalf of the club and check which terms and conditions apply to that purchase.

Brands to compare

Nintendo

Options include Joy-Cons for compatible Switch games and Pro Controllers for anyone who wants one full-size controller.

  • For Overcooked! 2 on Switch, Nintendo recommends one Joy-Con per chef.
  • Original Joy-Cons don’t attach to Switch 2. To charge them with Switch 2, you’ll need an original Switch or a compatible charging accessory.

Microsoft Xbox

An Xbox Wireless Controller is worth considering if your club uses an Xbox or a supported Windows PC.

  • Microsoft lists Xbox and Windows compatibility, as well as Bluetooth, for this controller range.
  • The compatibility listed doesn’t confirm that the controller works with Nintendo or PlayStation consoles.

PlayStation

The DualSense is an option for a PS5 and for PC games that support the controller.

  • PlayStation lists USB and Bluetooth for compatible PC games.
  • According to PlayStation, some features may not be available on certain devices and in certain games.

PowerA

The wired Switch controller reviewed is designed for a permanent TV set-up, with the system in its dock.

  • PowerA lists a detachable 3 m USB cable and an official Nintendo licence for this model.
  • According to PowerA, this model only works when the Switch is in its dock; it doesn’t have motion controls or HD rumble.

8BitDo

Choose an Ultimate 2C model to suit your system: the Wireless version for Windows and Android, or the Bluetooth version for Switch.

  • For the Ultimate 2C Wireless on Windows, 8BitDo lists a 2.4GHz receiver or a cable.
  • Platform support for one Ultimate 2C model doesn’t automatically apply to the other.

Joybuy controllers for different gaming systems

This selection from Joybuy includes controllers for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2, Xbox, PS5 and supported PC games. Before buying, check that the model is right for your club’s system and game.

Nintendo Switch Joy-Con pair, neon red and neon blue

Nintendo Switch Joy-Con pair, neon red/neon blue

Suitable for a club playing Overcooked! 2 on Nintendo Switch and looking to use individual Joy-Cons as player positions.

This product is a pair; Nintendo recommends one Joy-Con per chef for this game on Switch.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller, black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller, black

Suitable for a player who prefers to use one full-size controller with Nintendo Switch.

A Pro Controller provides one player position.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller, black

Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller, black

Suitable for a player looking for a full-size controller for Nintendo Switch 2.

Check whether your club needs the Switch 2 version of the controller; this is a different model from the original Switch Pro Controller.

View at Joybuy
Xbox Wireless Controller, Robot White

Xbox Wireless Controller, Robot White

Suitable for a club playing on Xbox or a supported Windows PC, once you’ve checked that the game supports the controller.

Microsoft lists Xbox and Windows compatibility, as well as Bluetooth, for this controller range.

View at Joybuy
PS5 DualSense wireless controller V3, Cosmic Red

PS5 DualSense wireless controller V3, Cosmic Red

Suitable for a club with a PS5 or a PC game that supports DualSense input.

PlayStation lists USB and Bluetooth for compatible PC games; available features may vary by device and game.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How many controllers do four players need for Overcooked! 2?

Team17 states that the game supports up to four players, locally or online. For Overcooked! 2 on Switch, Nintendo recommends one Joy-Con per chef, so four separate Joy-Cons can provide four player positions. Check the local multiplayer mode and controller set-up if you’re using a different version of the game or another system.

Why can’t I connect a third wireless controller to the Switch?

According to Nintendo, when a Bluetooth audio device is connected, a maximum of two wireless controllers can be connected to the original Switch. Disconnect the audio device if your set-up needs a third wireless controller; this restriction applies to that specific situation.

How can you get controllers ready for the next club night?

Set up the player positions in advance and check that all controllers have enough charge. Original Joy-Cons can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but you’ll need an original Switch or a compatible charging accessory to charge them. The wired PowerA controller reviewed doesn’t need charging, but according to PowerA, it works with the Switch in its dock.

What warranty and cooling-off rules apply when buying on behalf of the club?

This depends in part on who is legally making the purchase. The ACM states that the legal guarantee applies to consumer purchases and that consumers generally have a 14-day cooling-off period for distance purchases. If you’re buying on behalf of an association or another organisation, you can’t automatically assume that consumer rights apply; establish who the buyer is and check the terms and conditions for that purchase.