Who is this choice relevant to?

Mixing in a quiet workspace

You’re mainly assessing the balance and placement of backing vocals, and you don’t have an open microphone while mixing. An open-back model is a relevant option.

Singer who also records their own takes

You switch between recording and mixing, and want to prevent monitor sound from reaching the vocal microphone. Compare closed-back models and check how they fit your head.

Mixing at a desk with two monitors

You want to know whether the connection, cable routing and comfort suit your audio interface and desk. The number of monitors alone doesn’t determine which acoustic type of headphones you need.

What should you consider when choosing?

Open-back headphones

Choose this option: if you mainly mix in a quiet room and don’t have a vocal microphone open.

Bear in mind: they offer limited sound isolation, and monitor sound may leak into a microphone.

Closed-back headphones

Choose this option: if you also record vocals or need sound isolation.

Bear in mind: the actual seal also depends on the fit; a closed-back design isn’t automatically the right mixing reference for everyone.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Backing vocal balance Compare open-back and closed-back models using the same familiar vocal passage at a comfortable volume. If possible, also assess the balance using a second playback system you know well. If I mainly want to assess the balance between vocals in a quiet room, listening is my first priority. Around 36% of consumers say mix balance is their top priority.
Isolation while recording Check whether the model is closed-back, how the ear pads fit and whether monitor sound is audible in a test recording made with your microphone. If you also record backing vocals, you’ll want to keep monitor sound out of the microphone as much as possible. Around 29% of consumers put isolation first.
Connection and cable routing Check your interface’s headphone output, the plug or adapter you need, the cable length and which side the cable connects to on the exact model. If my desk is full of monitors and equipment, I want the cable to run conveniently around my workspace and connect to my interface. Around 21% of consumers prioritise this workspace connection.
Comfort and maintenance Assess the fit during a longer listening session and check whether cables or ear pads can be replaced on the version you’ve chosen. For long mixing sessions, I want headphones that feel comfortable and have replaceable parts if needed. Around 14% of consumers put comfort and maintenance first.

Common pitfalls

  • Treating a manufacturer’s claim about studio or reference sound as an independent comparison

    A description such as ‘accurate’ doesn’t automatically tell you how headphones will sound when you’re mixing backing vocals.

    First, choose based on whether you’re mixing in a quiet room or recording, then compare familiar vocal passages at the same comfortable volume.

  • Using an open-back model while recording vocals

    An open-back design offers little isolation, so monitor sound can reach an open microphone. You may then need to record the take again.

    Before an important session, make a short test recording using your own microphone and listening setup.

  • Checking only the plug and forgetting about cable routing

    A plug that fits doesn’t guarantee that the cable will run conveniently around your desk or that the headphones are connected to the intended output.

    Check the interface output, cable length, connection side and the exact contents of the version you’ve chosen. Don’t assume a Plus version comes with the same accessories as the standard version.

Brands to compare

beyerdynamic

The open-back DT 900 PRO X is a comparison model for mixing in quiet surroundings; the closed-back DT 700 PRO X is relevant if you also record.

  • Sound On Sound discusses the detachable cables on these models.
  • Sound On Sound flags weight as a consideration for comfort. These findings apply to the models mentioned, not the brand as a whole.

Sennheiser

The open-back HD 490 PRO is designed for mixing; the closed-back HD 480 PRO is an alternative if you also need sound isolation.

  • According to Sennheiser, the detachable cables on both models can be connected on either the left or right. Sound On Sound discusses the HD 480 PRO as a potential option for both recording and mixing.
  • Sennheiser’s claims about accurate reproduction come from the manufacturer. Check the contents of the standard and Plus versions separately.

Audio-Technica

The closed-back ATH-M50x is a wired comparison model if you’re looking for sound isolation and a detachable cable.

  • Audio-Technica lists a detachable cable and passive sound isolation for the ATH-M50x.
  • Decide for yourself whether the closed-back design and fit suit your mixing work; descriptions of the sound are manufacturer claims.

AKG

The open-back K702 is a comparison model for mixing in a quiet room.

  • AKG lists a replaceable cable and ear pads for the K702.
  • A 2010 hands-on test by Sound On Sound reported little isolation and noted that the fit could be an issue when moving around. That experience won’t necessarily apply to everyone.

Sony

The closed-back MDR-M1 is an additional comparison model if sound isolation is important during production.

  • Sony describes the MDR-M1 as a closed-back monitoring model with detachable cables.
  • Sony’s claims about sound accuracy and comfort come from the manufacturer, not from an independent comparison with the other models mentioned.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do you need headphones with two connections for two monitors?

No, the number of monitors doesn’t determine how many headphone connections you need. Select the intended listening output in your audio software and check that the plug or adapter fits your interface’s headphone output. Focusrite recommends connecting headphones directly to its interfaces.

Can the same headphones be used for both recording and mixing?

That may be a reason to compare a closed-back model, as long as it suits your recording setup and lets you assess the mix critically. The closed-back HD 480 PRO and DT 700 PRO X are models worth comparing, but that doesn’t prove either is the right choice for every room or listener.

How can you listen safely during long mixing sessions?

Keep the volume low and take regular breaks. According to the World Health Organization, the risk to your hearing depends on both the sound level and the duration of exposure. Without measuring it, a volume setting on an interface doesn’t tell you how many decibels reach your ears.

What if headphones bought in the Netherlands turn out to be faulty?

When you buy as a consumer, you’re entitled to a product that works properly. If it’s faulty, you may be entitled to a free repair, replacement or refund. According to the Dutch government, there’s no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands, and the seller is your point of contact. Normal wear and tear and damage caused by you aren’t necessarily covered.